Joe Johnson vs Tracy Mcgrady

weeezy · Post #1 » by **weeezy** » Wed Jan 16, 2008 11:50 pm

I got offered T-mac for my Joe Johnson in an 12 team roto league..

One thing is for sure is that T-mac once use to be a top fantasy player and now he has become too injured prone..

Then again Joe has been the most consistent roto player for me..Do i take T-mac? (he returns for the spurs game)

Wonka_INC · Post #2 » by **Wonka_INC** » Thu Jan 17, 2008 12:08 am

hmmm... i'd give Tmac a chance, the hawks have so many weapons carrying the load. I think Tracy could start producing for the rest of the year he'll get laughed at once he gets injured (again).
My opinion, trade for Tracy.
But that's just me.

weeezy · Post #3 » by **weeezy** » Thu Jan 17, 2008 4:18 am

Wonka_INC wrote:hmmm... i'd give Tmac a chance, the hawks have so many weapons carrying the load. I think Tracy could start producing for the rest of the year he'll get laughed at once he gets injured (again).
My opinion, trade for Tracy.
But that's just me.

ya the only thing restraining me from hitting that accept button is T-macs health. Thanks for the input though, anymore opinions to help me decide is appreciated

mavsfoty · Post #4 » by **mavsfoty** » Thu Jan 17, 2008 5:10 pm

I'd stick w/ Joe. The #'s are practically a wash.

T-Mac is a great player when healthy. But when and for how long will that be?

realsniper09 · Post #5 » by **realsniper09** » Fri Jan 18, 2008 10:15 am

I prefer Joe Johnson to T-Mac, even regardless of health. They are both very similar though, but JJ's FG% is much better and that gives him the edge.

Adding in injury concerns, I think you take JJ.