D-12 for Marion and Kidd

[flipmode800]

10 Team Roto league - FG, FT, 3s, Pts, Reb, Ast, Stl, Blk.

Someone just traded Dwight Howard and Elton Brand for Shawn Marion, Jason Kidd and Nick Collison?

Comments welcome

[Stanford]

A roto league without %s and TOs is such a cop out.

I would say Dwight is a top five player with this kind of scoring system. Marion and Kidd probably aren't in the top 25.

Basketball monster says Dwight is #7. Kidd is 43 and Marion is 32. Names aside, I'd say it's about even. The fact that you're getting Brand (playing for a new contract) puts you over the top.

What's the point of asking for comments on a trade that's already been completed, btw?

[flipmode800]

Sorry when I said FG and FT i meant FG% and FT% are categories, but you are correct that there is not a TO category.

The reason I asked about the trade after it was completed is because to me it seems like a terrible deal and I was not involved. Just wanted to know if other people saw it as fair or not.

[kiz5]

Without turnovers, Howard is a top top player, and Marion drops a lot.

[magicfan4life05]

A roto league without %s and TOs is such a cop out.

I would say Dwight is a top five player with this kind of scoring system. Marion and Kidd probably aren't in the top 25.

Basketball monster says Dwight is #7. Kidd is 43 and Marion is 32. Names aside, I'd say it's about even. The fact that you're getting Brand (playing for a new contract) puts you over the top.

What's the point of asking for comments on a trade that's already been completed, btw?

stanford, what do you mean by this statement? im in a roto league that counts fg and ft percentage as well as to's, do you mean they shouldnt count? why...thx

[Stanford]

-= original quote snipped =-




stanford, what do you mean by this statement? im in a roto league that counts fg and ft percentage as well as to's, do you mean they shouldnt count? why...thx

Roto leagues without negative stats are cop outs. They defeat the purpose of roto leagues.