Do you make this trade?

[Bang' Em Smurf]

I'm in a long time keeper league, with a roster of

PG- Rodney Stuckey | Acie Law | DJ Strawberry
SG- Leandro Barbosa | Anthony Parker
SF- Al Thornton | Brandon Rush | Josh Childress
PF- David West | Joey Dorsey | Jason Smith | Louis Amundson
C- Brook Lopez | Joel Prybilla | Fabricio Oberto

Someone proposed this trade to me:

I give: Stuckey - Childress - Amundon

I get: Mo Williams - Jared Dudley - Josh Powell

The reason i'm thinking of doing it is because Williams is still pretty young, has good scoring and assists but i'm scared of his injuries too.

Childress is out of the NBA for now, maybe for a few years?

Should i gamble and take the Williams PG or keep Stuckey and hope he develops like people think he will?

Thoughts?

[Young_Star11]

I'd go for Mo.

[DNYLkiller]

Mo, no question. All your PG's could see no relevance this season, You need MOwill. It's a steal.

[ZenBaller]

I'm in a long time keeper league, with a roster of

Someone proposed this trade to me:

I give: Stuckey - Childress - Amundon

I get: Mo Williams - Jared Dudley - Josh Powell

Thoughts?

This is a no brainer. The 3 players you're getting are better than each one of the others.

Mo Williams is much better than Stuckey right now and for the next 2-3 years for sure, maybe forever.
I don't see Childress returning for 2 years at least.
Powell and Amundson are both undraftable and they shouldn't even exist in any roster but at least Powell played some quality minutes in LA when Brand and Kaman were out.

Do it as fast as you can!

[Stanford]

Yeah, if you need another opinion, I'd take the deal as well. Statwise, I'd say Stuckey's potential is around Williams anyway. Plus, I doubt Childress is back for a while.

[BigSlam]

I'm on board with everyone else. If nothing else at least Mo will give you some 3's - something your team seriously lacks!!