Trade offer

[magicfan4life05]

I was offered

Luol Deng and Kevin Durant

for

Josh Smith and Chris Duhon



I would be getting deng and durant.


deal or no deal?

[jorgo]

What categories? H2H/Roto? Keeper league?

Your current lineup?

At first glance I would prefer the josh smith/duhon side.

[robertjanssen007]

Durant's the wild card here.

I'd gamble for it since Deng should be more than serviceable too.

[magicfan4life05]

It's H2H

with FG%, FT%, 3PTM, PTS, REB, AST, ST, BLK, TO



my team looks like

josh smith
arenas
duhon
magloire
michael redd
horford
bogut
farmar
wilson chandler
sefolosha
roger mason
al thornton
richard hamilton
bargnani
tyrus thomas

man I'm really torn!


so deal or no deal?

[eyeatoma]

Take Smith...

Duhon can still get you assists...

So no deal...

[Relentless88]

No deal keep J-Smoove.

[Alex_De_Large]

The difference between Deng and Duhon is higher than the difference between Josh and Durant, so i would take Durant and Deng. It depends in the system of the league also, if blocks and steals are more important than the normal points then Smith is better, but not so much better than KD.

[Death Knight]

I would take the Josh Smith side as well. Just keep this in mind, some of Josh Smith's numbers took a slight hit when Bibby got traded to Atlanta, most noticeably the blocks and steals...this is according to ESPN. His the end of the season numbers still held up pretty well, but the numbers post and pre Bibby should be taken into consideration.

[pillwenney]

Smith is a fantasy monster--keep him.

[Curtis Lemansky]

Keep Smith

[magicfan4life05]

thanks everyone