RealGM

Bring the positive, negative feedback, i know its useless, but it adds value to productive posters and trolls. If anyone ever been to bodybuilding.com forums, they have it there.

This topic's already been brought up before... it would cause chaos because people would just vote down anyone they don't like.

There's no point to it, plus biased people would just ruin it anyway.

This is a good idea, so long as its used by mods only. Like for example, a place they could make disciplinary comments about users, and then use a color code to show to us how often mods comment on a certain user. We wouldnt even have to see the comments - just that there are X amount of negative comments from mods.

I think that would be 10x more helpful, especially for people visiting boards they dont usually frequent...

510Reggae wrote:This is a good idea, so long as its used by mods only. Like for example, a place they could make disciplinary comments about users, and then use a color code to show to us how often mods comment on a certain user. We wouldnt even have to see the comments - just that there are X amount of negative comments from mods.

I think that would be 10x more helpful, especially for people visiting boards they dont usually frequent...

That would be more like a warning system. And TBH I don't think it would be a good idea to start showing how much trouble people are in.