Pickled Prunes wrote:dougthonus wrote:Pickled Prunes wrote:Don't compare him to Roy... that ain't right!
The funny thing about this is I'm not sure if you think this is insulting to Roy or MPj.
All these accolades belong to either Roy or Porter... I'll let you guess which.![]()
Western Conference All-Star in his 2nd, 3rd and 4th seasons
All-NBA Second Team - 2009
All-NBA Third Team - 2010
Player Of The Week - 12/09/2007, 12/16/2007, 12/01/2008, 4/13/2009, 3/15/2010
Rookie Of The Year - 2007
All-Rookie First Team - 2007
Rookie Of The Month - Jan. 2007, Feb. 2007, Mar. 2007
PBWA Magic Johnson Award - 2009
If Roy had cartilage in his knees he would be HOF bound. MPJ... I don't think so. A better comp might be Gallinari.
Porter had one really healthy year vs four, so it's hard to really gauge. He showed enough in that year that if you project forward he would have been a hell of a lot better than Gallinari.
Of course, Porter may still have healthy years in front of him, we don't know yet, but I am not hopeful for him.
Certainly Roy was the more proven of the two guys.


