Pickled Prunes wrote:It's a slippery slope. Silver probably doesn't want to fine him and probably couldn't without turning this into a league wide issue. Yet inaction opens the door for the next time a player breaks the dress code for something that they believe in. Next thing you know a player warms up in a shirt with a dog firing a machine gun on it and when asked why he says, "I believe them kittens got to go!"
My take:
Great shirt by Rose
Good no call by Silver
Yes, them kittens got to go!
+1 for the slippery slope point... I agree that it seems cold and heartless to fine somebody for this, but that level of discretion puts the league in a place where it is choosing which causes do and don't deserve a free pass on skirting the rules. If a player felt strongly about gay marriage and wore a shirt due to some incident, would the league let that slide? If a player felt strongly in the other direction and wore a shirt supporting "traditional marriage" would the league also let that slide? I am not trying to say that either side of that issue is the same, better than, or as important as this cause... but if the league is now in a position to excuse the lack of following the dress code based upon the public opinion of the cause in question it could get ugly.