12footrim wrote:So name all the truely great players with 15.0 PER's seasons of "greatness".
OK first of all, nobody's calling Middleton a HOF player, nor even an all-star at this point. But we're saying he's WORTH the money, given what the cap will look like. The percentage of the cap his contract will take up, averaged over the length of the contract, will be a percentage you can live with, even at max money. Meaning he can still be ther 3rd, or even 4th best player on your team, with a max contract, and you'll still be fine. The cap will go up to ~67 mil, then ~89 mil, then ~108 mil in the next 3 years. That's 20 mil extra per year. If they Max Khris now at $15, and Max both Giannis and Jabari at the assumed 108 mil salary cap (27 mil each!!) in 2017/2018 (assuming cap stays at 108mil in 2018), that means they maxed Khris at nearly half the yearly value of those two players! Even if they go this route, that's only 69 million commited to those 3 maxed players, meaning they have an additional ~40 million to round out the roster, without going into luxury tax. That shouldn't be too hard to fill out a roster, especially given that they will still have rookie level deals on contract. By the time he's in the 3rd year of this potential max contract, it'll only be 15/108 = 14% of the cap. That would translate to just under a $9 million contract given today's cap. If you don't think he's worth a relative $9 million contract in today's NBA, then I'm sorry, but you're wrong. I'm guessing, over the life of the contract, the relative, pro-rated value of this max deal would only be in the 10-11 mil range, assuming the cap goes to and stays at 108 mil into the 4th/5th year of the deal.
Hollinger admits: "PER largely measures offensive performance. Hollinger freely admits that two of the defensive statistics it incorporates—blocks and steals (which was not tracked as an official stat until 1973)—can produce a distorted picture of a player's value and that PER is not a reliable measure of a player's defensive acumen. For example, Bruce Bowen, widely regarded as one of the best defenders in the NBA (at least through the 2006–07 season), has routinely posted single-digit PERs.
"Bear in mind that this rating is not the final, once-and-for-all answer for a player's accomplishments during the season. This is especially true for players such as Bruce Bowen and Trenton Hassell who are defensive specialists but don't get many blocks or steals.""
But yes, there are all-star and HOF level players with season(s), or even career PER's under 20, with seasons in the 15 range. Keep in mind, Middleton was younger in this season, than many of these guys were in their rookie years.
Reggie Miller: HOF. Career 18.4, First 2 seasons 14.0, 15.7, then into the 21 range, then dipped to 17.6 in the 5th year.
Dennis Rodman: HOF. Multiple champion. Career PER of 14.6. Multiple seasons in the 13 range during his prime.
Ben Wallace: One of the best defenders of a generation. DPOY, Champion. Career PER 15.5, crossing into the 18's only once.
Gary Payton: HOF. One of the best PG's of all time, one of the best PG defenders ever. First 2 seasons had PER in the 13's, then 17.
Jamaal Wilkes: HOF. Career PER of 16.5, highest of 18.0
Gus Johnson: HOF. Career PER of 16.7.
Gail Goodrich: HOF. Career PER of 16.7. Multiple seasons in the 14 and 15's, including his rookie season below 12.
Lenny Wilkens: HOF. Career PER of 16.8. Didn't exceed a PER of 16 until he was 30, in his 8th season.
Dave Cowens: HOF. Career PER of 17. Never exceeded 20.
Dikembe Mutumbo: HOF. One of THE BEST defensive players of all time. Averaged 10/10/3blk career, Career PER 17.2. In the three years he averaged 11/12/4 blk on 50% shooting, his PER was 17, but had DWS in the 4-5 ranges during this time.
Nate Thurmond: HOF. Averaged 20/18/3ast/3blk for a lot of his career (15/15/3/2blk career average even after a few weak seasons at the end of his career), PER never exceed 20, averaging 16.5 for the career, with several seasons of 15 or less at the beginning and end of his career.
Mike Mitchell: Averaged 20pt 5.5reb over a 10 year caeer, 49+% fg, 32mpg, Career PER 16.7, with several seasons in the 15's.
Mo Cheeks: 11/3/7/2stl on the career, 52% fg, All-star, NBA champion, exceeded PER of 20 only twice, 16.6 career average with seasons in the 15's.
Sidney Moncrief: Multiple DPOY winner, still had seasons in the 15 PER range, at the beginning and end of his career.
Bruce Bowen: Career PER of 8. 3 time champion playing 30+mpg.
Ok so there's a few examples. Players in the HOF, with low Career PER's, including low PER's during their prime years. NOW will you admit that PER isn't 100% foolproof, and that yes, there are indeed scenarios where a player, especialy a good defensive player, can have their abilities and worth overlooked by a single metric such as PER, which focuses largely on the offensive side of the game?