luss54321 wrote:Biff wrote:dice wrote:animals play defense. see kevin garnett, MJ, etc.
Exactly. They also have a positive +/- rating. The only thing Kyrie is good at is scoring, he's pretty terrible at virtually everything else.
True, but scoring is BY FAR the most valuable skill a player can have.
eh...the range of offensive impact RAPM-wise is not that much greater than the range of defensive impact. it's like a 55-45 split. and scoring obviously isn't close to the only factor in a great offensive player. so arguably a great defensive player has more value than a great one-dimensional scorer
I can't off the top of my head think of a better example of a great defender w/o offensive skill than dikembe mutombo (though dikembe was a good garbageman offensively). but compare his value to some great scorer who was/is a notably poor defender and not good in other areas...the best all-time example might be Adrian dantley. one of the best pure scorers in league history. was dantley BY FAR a more valuable player than mutombo? I think that's a fairly ridiculous assertion. was he more valuable straight up? I think it could be argued either way
we're talking about a 25 year old who scored 25 PPG on 47%/40%/90%... That's pretty incredible
first of all, most guys have entered their prime by age 25. particularly in the 1 and done era. secondly, the only % that really matters is TS%. and kyrie matched his career high w/ 58% this season. good but not elite. 26 per 36 on 58% is outstanding. Adrian dantley AVERAGED 24/62% for his career. so kyrie is not on his level as a player
You win games by scoring more points than the other team
or by surrendering less points than the other team surrenders
yin meet yang
here might be 5 players in the league who could put up 25 PPG on those shooting numbers
hmmm...again, if we're talking overall scoring efficiency:
kyrie, Durant, curry, Thompson (perhaps, if not on the warriors), kawhi, LeBron, IT, kevin love (if not 3rd wheel on the cavs), harden, cp3 (if he wasn't such a great and willing passer), kemba, butler, PG, mccollum, lillard, hayward...anyone else I'm missing? AD if we're including guys who play inside the arc. I'd also argue that gallinari was a more
effective scorer this past season. as was jokic
the donald, always unpopular, did worse in EVERY state in 2020. and by a greater margin in red states! 50 independently-run elections, none of them rigged