GoBobs wrote:SWedd523 wrote:I think everyone, even those down on Scoot, believe he has "better than Terry" potential.
I think he has the physical tools and mental makeup to be a great player. He also has a great name, which is half the battle.
All of my concerns with him are purely about fit. I don't see a world where he can play off ball because he's too short and not a willing nor good shooter.
That means you push Melo off the ball. Can he be successful off ball? Yes. Does taking the ball out of his hands reduce some of the magic he creates in an ad lib scenario? Absolutely.
It also makes me nervous about how he takes that entire situation. He's already made his feelings known and we're all nervous about if he wants to stay here or not. Does bringing in another PG and reducing his usage piss him off and push him out? Not sure.
If it proves successful then I'm sure everything would be copacetic. But there is definitely some extra curricular stuff to consider with Scoot
A lot of good points in here. I would want to know how LaMelo feels about things.
Agreed - I believe the wise move would be to get Ball's input on the two options. Not that LaMelo is choosing our players for us, but when you have a rising superstar/franchise player that you want to keep around long-term, it's a prudent move to gauge his interest in playing beside either player.
I think Scoot is the better player, higher potential, Westbrook (minus the headcase) level of impact and balances LB's gaps (driving through traffic, rim play, mid-range game and defense).
I do think Miller, if drafted as a SG that can flex to multiple wing positions, can also be an equally impactful player beside 'Melo. Giving us a Paul George-Brandon Ingram kind of lengthy player. The thought of a 6'7" PG and a 6'9" SG, both under the age of 22 running our backcourt is also pretty enticing.
Much the way Scoot would provide us PG insurance if 'Melo does decide to leave town, Miller would be SF insurance if Miles can't get his head screwed on correctly.
This does remind me quite a bit of the Bryce-Stroud conversation. Both guys will be franchise altering players, 1A & 1B from a value standpoint at 2.....but which one is the better fit and "better" all around player for this franchise?
We need to keep 'Melo