My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time

Moderators: bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake

User avatar
GeorgeMarcus
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 18,761
And1: 23,913
Joined: Jun 17, 2006
     

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#81 » by GeorgeMarcus » Thu Jul 24, 2025 6:59 pm

M2J wrote:
GeorgeMarcus wrote:Chauncey was vey good, but not top 3 pg of all time good... Top 10 ish sounds fair. I also disagree with the notion that AI --> Billups turned Denver into a contender when they were similarly good with Iverson


Chauncey and a matured Jr Smith plus others gave Melo what he'd never had in Denver with can't
Camby Nene and Martin and Andre Miller.... Floor spacing release valves. AI of course with the ball creates space, but both Melo and AI wanted mid range and layups. So he did change Denver for the better with his play style.


I wouldn't argue DEN being better off with Billups for the reason you describe, but I don't think it's fair to say they went from non-contender to contender
The Legend of George Marcus

"Where I'm from, bullies get bullied." - Zach Randolph
DC_Melo
Rookie
Posts: 1,020
And1: 1,481
Joined: Jul 02, 2023
       

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#82 » by DC_Melo » Thu Jul 24, 2025 7:03 pm

M2J wrote:
DC_Melo wrote:
M2J wrote:
Says I have a memory that pre dates YouTube and social media where you've learned all about Billups. So tell me more about how great a defender is (actual topic) instead of asking me to reveal news footage from before you watched basketball for some Internet gotcha moment you feel hurts my feelings (especially when I know I'm right).


So in other words… you can’t find the video… because it doesn’t exist. It’s your claim this ever happened mate, so put up or shut up.

As for why he was a great defender… well he had positive DPMs every season with the pistons, was selected to 2 all nba def teams and got voted for 6 others, had far better than league average def ratings, there are numerous articles from coaches and players at the time praising his defense, and there are articles since then that take an analytical look at his impact and further discover just how impactful he was and his merits for HoF consideration. Here’s an example:
https://www.statitudes.com/p/is-chauncey-billups-a-hall-of-famer

Cool how the article also notes he was the most efficient offensive player for the Pistons championship team. Didn’t you say he was inefficient?

Crazy what you can achieve with sources




Rudy gobert has more dpoy than anyone... The discussions today about his he sucks is what the discussions were about including Billups over several other guards on those teams simply because he was on a great defensive team and much like you media voters can't determine defense and those Pistons teams weren't winning due to Chauncey averaging mid teens ppg and under 45% shooting.... It was defense led by their front court. Watch a game... See what you can achieve then


Nice, pivot to Gobert cuz you can’t link your made up video lol.

I do watch games my friend, and I read. And if you did the same, you would see that in the links I sourced, he was not only a defensive stalwart with a sub 99 def rating his championship season, he was also the most efficient player on that offense.

Now, I have made my case why he was a lot more to that championship team than you originally stated. And I have provided actual facts and sources. I invite you to do the same, but otherwise I’m really not interested in talking in circles with someone who ignores facts and can’t provide any sources of his own. You want to say Billups was the worst defender on that Pistons team? Provide some proof
M2J
Analyst
Posts: 3,638
And1: 1,856
Joined: Sep 04, 2012

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#83 » by M2J » Thu Jul 24, 2025 7:18 pm

DC_Melo wrote:
M2J wrote:
DC_Melo wrote:
So in other words… you can’t find the video… because it doesn’t exist. It’s your claim this ever happened mate, so put up or shut up.

As for why he was a great defender… well he had positive DPMs every season with the pistons, was selected to 2 all nba def teams and got voted for 6 others, had far better than league average def ratings, there are numerous articles from coaches and players at the time praising his defense, and there are articles since then that take an analytical look at his impact and further discover just how impactful he was and his merits for HoF consideration. Here’s an example:
https://www.statitudes.com/p/is-chauncey-billups-a-hall-of-famer

Cool how the article also notes he was the most efficient offensive player for the Pistons championship team. Didn’t you say he was inefficient?

Crazy what you can achieve with sources




Rudy gobert has more dpoy than anyone... The discussions today about his he sucks is what the discussions were about including Billups over several other guards on those teams simply because he was on a great defensive team and much like you media voters can't determine defense and those Pistons teams weren't winning due to Chauncey averaging mid teens ppg and under 45% shooting.... It was defense led by their front court. Watch a game... See what you can achieve then


Nice, pivot to Gobert cuz you can’t link your made up video lol.

I do watch games my friend, and I read. And if you did the same, you would see that in the links I sourced, he was not only a defensive stalwart with a sub 99 def rating his championship season, he was also the most efficient player on that offense.

Now, I have made my case why he was a lot more to that championship team than you originally stated. And I have provided actual facts and sources. I invite you to do the same, but otherwise I’m really not interested in talking in circles with someone who ignores facts and can’t provide any sources of his own. You want to say Billups was the worst defender on that Pistons team? Provide some proof



He was finals MVP never said he didn't matter to the team.

I pivoted to gobert because the evidence is there and you can't claim a lack of sources from 20 years ago as you've pivoted your entire discussion.

Never said I had a video. Didn't even look for one.... You need one because you're ignorant on the subject outside of some cherry picked stats. Defensive rating man is not the same as defensive writing now. The points per game was totally different. Defensive rating for individual player is also reflective on the overall team. I.E. it would be a bench able offense for someone to have 113 defensive rating for team with a 97 drtg. You judge individual players defensive rating based on their overall teams numbers not the leagues.... Not saying he is his way different than the teams rating ...just say throwing out 99 pretending like he's the reason for it is showing the way you watch basketball...on paper and random sources.
ReddoverKobe
Head Coach
Posts: 6,447
And1: 7,423
Joined: Feb 12, 2019
   

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#84 » by ReddoverKobe » Thu Jul 24, 2025 7:29 pm

We need to add downvotes just for this post
DC_Melo
Rookie
Posts: 1,020
And1: 1,481
Joined: Jul 02, 2023
       

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#85 » by DC_Melo » Thu Jul 24, 2025 7:57 pm

M2J wrote:
DC_Melo wrote:
M2J wrote:


Rudy gobert has more dpoy than anyone... The discussions today about his he sucks is what the discussions were about including Billups over several other guards on those teams simply because he was on a great defensive team and much like you media voters can't determine defense and those Pistons teams weren't winning due to Chauncey averaging mid teens ppg and under 45% shooting.... It was defense led by their front court. Watch a game... See what you can achieve then


Nice, pivot to Gobert cuz you can’t link your made up video lol.

I do watch games my friend, and I read. And if you did the same, you would see that in the links I sourced, he was not only a defensive stalwart with a sub 99 def rating his championship season, he was also the most efficient player on that offense.

Now, I have made my case why he was a lot more to that championship team than you originally stated. And I have provided actual facts and sources. I invite you to do the same, but otherwise I’m really not interested in talking in circles with someone who ignores facts and can’t provide any sources of his own. You want to say Billups was the worst defender on that Pistons team? Provide some proof



He was finals MVP never said he didn't matter to the team.

I pivoted to gobert because the evidence is there and you can't claim a lack of sources from 20 years ago as you've pivoted your entire discussion.

Never said I had a video. Didn't even look for one.... You need one because you're ignorant on the subject outside of some cherry picked stats. Defensive rating man is not the same as defensive writing now. The points per game was totally different. Defensive rating for individual player is also reflective on the overall team. I.E. it would be a bench able offense for someone to have 113 defensive rating for team with a 97 drtg. You judge individual players defensive rating based on their overall teams numbers not the leagues.... Not saying he is his way different than the teams rating ...just say throwing out 99 pretending like he's the reason for it is showing the way you watch basketball...on paper and random sources.


I’ve maintained the same position this entire time:
-He wasn’t the worst defender on the pistons championship team
-there isn’t any video of pistons players laughing at him when he made an all defensive team.
-he was not an inefficient offensive player.

Those were your original claims that I refuted, with stats, sources, and common sense.

You have provided:
-zero evidence of any such video existing
-zero argument for how he was the worst defender on the pistons when all stats and defensive metrics say otherwise
-zero evidence for how he was inefficient even tho he had the highest PER (Player Efficiency Rating) on that starting team

But yea man… Rudy Gobert
User avatar
SkyBill40
General Manager
Posts: 7,733
And1: 6,512
Joined: Oct 24, 2014
Location: Phoenix
       

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#86 » by SkyBill40 » Thu Jul 24, 2025 8:00 pm

ReddoverKobe wrote:We need to add downvotes just for this post


They could be called "technicals" seeing that upvotes are and1's. LOL
SweaterBae wrote:It's the perfect trade when nobody is happy.
NZB2323
RealGM
Posts: 14,107
And1: 10,723
Joined: Aug 02, 2008

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#87 » by NZB2323 » Thu Jul 24, 2025 8:28 pm

M2J wrote:
DC_Melo wrote:
M2J wrote:


Rudy gobert has more dpoy than anyone... The discussions today about his he sucks is what the discussions were about including Billups over several other guards on those teams simply because he was on a great defensive team and much like you media voters can't determine defense and those Pistons teams weren't winning due to Chauncey averaging mid teens ppg and under 45% shooting.... It was defense led by their front court. Watch a game... See what you can achieve then


Nice, pivot to Gobert cuz you can’t link your made up video lol.

I do watch games my friend, and I read. And if you did the same, you would see that in the links I sourced, he was not only a defensive stalwart with a sub 99 def rating his championship season, he was also the most efficient player on that offense.

Now, I have made my case why he was a lot more to that championship team than you originally stated. And I have provided actual facts and sources. I invite you to do the same, but otherwise I’m really not interested in talking in circles with someone who ignores facts and can’t provide any sources of his own. You want to say Billups was the worst defender on that Pistons team? Provide some proof



He was finals MVP never said he didn't matter to the team.

I pivoted to gobert because the evidence is there and you can't claim a lack of sources from 20 years ago as you've pivoted your entire discussion.

Never said I had a video. Didn't even look for one.... You need one because you're ignorant on the subject outside of some cherry picked stats. Defensive rating man is not the same as defensive writing now. The points per game was totally different. Defensive rating for individual player is also reflective on the overall team. I.E. it would be a bench able offense for someone to have 113 defensive rating for team with a 97 drtg. You judge individual players defensive rating based on their overall teams numbers not the leagues.... Not saying he is his way different than the teams rating ...just say throwing out 99 pretending like he's the reason for it is showing the way you watch basketball...on paper and random sources.


No one else besides you here has any “memory” of this video, so the onus is on you to provide proof. Unless some of our Pistons fans can chime in and confirm your story.

Like, if I said I saw a video of a 40 year old Michael Jordan destroying LeBron in 2003 in a one-on-one game, everyone would be asking for the source. The same thing is true of your claim.

Of if I make a claim that there’s a video of you saying that Billups is the GOAT, you would say, “What video? I never said that. Show me the video.”

Or if I said there was a video of Billups beating Kobe in a game of 1 on 1 where Kobe didn’t score any points, you’d ask for the source.

I think you get the point. You need to provide the proof for your claim.

And everyone who watched the Pistons knew that Billups was a better defender than Rip. You say Billups just has a good defensive rating because of his teammates, but then why does Rip have a negative defensive rating?

And I know this is a red herring argument from you, but Rudy is a great defensive player and his playoff defense “shortcomings” have been overblown. He successfully defended and beat Luka, LeBron, Booker, Durant, and Jokic in the playoffs.
Handlez
Starter
Posts: 2,180
And1: 2,630
Joined: Dec 27, 2023

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#88 » by Handlez » Thu Jul 24, 2025 8:38 pm

Jwill white chocolate absolutely dogs Billups and the Pistons in game 6 to lead the Heat to the title...

https://youtu.be/upDxJ1-dv5s?si=l50gG9wJU1yjUA6e
LakersLegacy
Head Coach
Posts: 7,436
And1: 4,012
Joined: Apr 27, 2015
   

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#89 » by LakersLegacy » Thu Jul 24, 2025 9:31 pm

Finals MVP
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 49,450
And1: 26,683
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#90 » by dhsilv2 » Thu Jul 24, 2025 9:36 pm

GeorgeMarcus wrote:
M2J wrote:
GeorgeMarcus wrote:Chauncey was vey good, but not top 3 pg of all time good... Top 10 ish sounds fair. I also disagree with the notion that AI --> Billups turned Denver into a contender when they were similarly good with Iverson


Chauncey and a matured Jr Smith plus others gave Melo what he'd never had in Denver with can't
Camby Nene and Martin and Andre Miller.... Floor spacing release valves. AI of course with the ball creates space, but both Melo and AI wanted mid range and layups. So he did change Denver for the better with his play style.


I wouldn't argue DEN being better off with Billups for the reason you describe, but I don't think it's fair to say they went from non-contender to contender


They went from fun teams who could go deep to a really dark horse contender imo. In short, yes they moved up a tier but not to LEGIT contender.
User avatar
Calvin Klein
RealGM
Posts: 15,440
And1: 10,264
Joined: May 20, 2008
Location: Buenos Aires, Argentina
Contact:
   

Re: My hot take - Billups is the 3rd best PG all time 

Post#91 » by Calvin Klein » Thu Jul 24, 2025 10:11 pm

Take is not hot, just bad

Return to The General Board