ubernathan wrote:lakegz1 wrote:As a Laker fan, I am not afraid.  I say bring it on.  Basketball is a team game and no matter how many glamorous stars you pack onto a team, you still need valuable role players and guys willing to play defense and get dirty when it matters.  I thought we had a guaranteed championship when we brought in Karl Malone and Gary Payton to team up with Shaq and we saw what happened.  Play the games!
True, but this isn't comparable. This is like if the Lakers had had prime Payton, Malone, Shaq, and Kobe together for 6 years.
 
For team makeup-playing valuable roles, I would not put Bosh too ahead of yes, even 40 year old Malone.  He played 
superb post D that year, passed from the post better than anyone I've seen, and consistently hit the 15 foot jumper, something which fit that Laker team that season like a glove. Go ahead and argue numbers, I know them too, but Karl Malone had legit impact on the team that year. Gary Payton was definitely on the tail end of his career but I think he still managed 14ppg that year and gave us good point guard play, something we haven't had since.... I can't even remember that far back.
Those were tail end of career all stars, but they played their roles perfectly throughout the whole season.  Can these prime all stars compromise and do the same?  I will believe it when I see it.