FlyingArrow wrote:Madhouse wrote:the term generational is overused because it seems every other year someone is called that and then also more than 5 players in the NBA are called that when it should be something reserved for a player who comes around once every 20-25 years.
And then next year the kid from Utah is also going to be 'generational'. Maybe everyone should just call them great prospects.
In general usage, the word "generation" means about 20 years. Few players are actually productive for 20 years, though, so in basketball terms in makes sense to think of a basketball generation as 10-15 years. Still, you're right that the term is overused. With that definition, if you aren't clearly the best player for ~10 year era, you aren't a generational talent. That gives us... Wilt, Kareem, Jordan, LeBron. I can't think of any others based on that definition.
Magic/Larry cancel each other out. As do Duncan/Shaq/Kobe. You could even argue that Russell/Wilt cancel each other out, too.
Another, less restrictive, use of the term 'generational' could mean best at a given position for the generation. This is a much looser usage of the term, and it would allow you to use the term for Duncan, Shaq, Kobe, Magic, Bird, Durant, Curry, and a host of others. It would open up the term for up to 5 players at a time in the NBA. Probably less than that, though, because often, for a given position there isn't just one player who dominates that position for ~10 years. For example, Duncan/Shaq/Kobe were generational talents based on this usage, but what point guard was a "generational" talent from that era. Certainly some great players (Kidd/Nash), but none that stand out from their peers enough for the label.
Generational prospects are prospects that have the ability to be the best player for next 10 years. That's why Wemby is considered generational, Zion looked to have that same ability out of Duke. I honestly thought MPJ pre-injury and Embiid pre-injury were generational prospects. That kid from Duke looks like the same breed of prospect right now. Just because you are a generational prospect doesn't mean you are a generational player.














