tsherkin wrote:ThatBoyNick wrote:Someone who brings what Fred does on defense and offense management while also being an above average scoring guard is basically prime Chris Paul, which is far cry from just a “starter level talent”
Not really, no. Paul was an elite offensive weapon in a variety of ways.
No, I'm just well accustomed to his limitations.
Their scoring rates are actually pretty similar. In the macro CP is better at making shots with a roughly 5% higher TS (comping their primes).
CP in the micro, was mainly a much better scorer in the paint, which is Freds core limitation, which does entirely change the dynamics as an offensive threat.
Fred is a good 3PT and mid-range shooter. His mid range jumper in particular wasn't even utilized until 2021 and after, if you look at his shot chart his last 3 seasons of 21-22 through 23-34 season he's pretty good, not as elite as CP, but good.
Looking at the league and trying to find players better than Fred today who are NOT downgrades on defense, spacing or offensive management is not easy. I can't think of more than 10 players. Name 30 guys who fit that description and push Fred to the 6th man role in Houston. Again, you may be comparing his situation in Toronto to Houston which doesn't work.
Maybe for certain teams, particularly ones with good rim protection, having a weaker defensive guard for better offensive production would be preferred. Houstons success is built on its defense, and we don't have any rim protection. Fred being an absolute wall as a point of attack defender, with great hands, and good enough lateral quickness, to go with his spacing, low turnover passing /high IQ offensive management is invaluable.
I think theres a real chance that if you were to replace him with a player like Lillard, or Trae, who in a vacuum one would consider better overall players because of their scoring, that we would end up being a worse team for it.
Our offense is mediocre, absolutely, our defense is not, and we're currently the 3rd best team in the league for it. If we we were a worse team I think you'd have a better point. Infusing offense for defense isn't a shoe-in for success here, and again finding equal defender to Fred who can play the PG role is very difficult.