SpurNani wrote:realball wrote:SpurNani wrote:
I think there's 4 players - Jokic, Shai, Luka, Giannis who can all hold claim to being called the best player in the world.
I dont think Jokic has done enough or accomplished enough to be considered the unquestioned best. His playoff resume is thin outside of a historically weak 2023 NBA playoff field.
Why would you put Giannis on this list, considering his playoff resume is weaker? He's hasn't made it out of the first round in years. How is Luka on this list, considering he's never even won a championship? Clearly, you can't have this discussion with any sense of objectivity.
What Luka did in 24 playoffs was far more impressive than what Jokic did in 23 playoffs when you consider the competition faced by both respective teams.
Luka carried his team past 3 50 win teams, including the Timberwolves who took Jokic out in 24 and the OKC Thunder who took Jokic out the following year. Oh and none took him 7 games to do so. He just so happened to run into the Celtics who were one of the greatest teams we've seen this decade.
Contrast that to Jokic in 23, who beat play in Timberwolves who were missing Naz Reid, Jaden McDaniels, hurt Rudy Gobert. They beat the Suns who had KD and Booker and basically nobody else. KD and Booker only played 13 total games together before Jokic faced them in playoffs.
And they beat 43 win play in Lakers with 39 year old Lebron and Anthony Davis, who isn't a true center. And then they beat the Miami Heat who lost their first play in game. Miami was also without their most dynamic young scorer in Tyler Herro.
Jokic just beat his first 50 win team this this year. Luka beat 3 50 win teams in 24 alone and led the entire playoffs in points, rebounds, assists. Just vastly different levels of competition ill take Luka in 24 over Jokic 23.
Okay, then why is Giannis on your list?
Luka was playing with HOFer Kyrie. You said Murray had the same impact during their championship run... so since he's been no where near that level ever since, it's fair to say that Jokic has had way less support than Doncic, right? Because Luka just got booted in the first round in six games while playing with Lebron James, while Jokic took the eventual champs to seven games, and that's with his second best player, Aaron Gordon, getting hurt during the series. And re-read that, his second best player was
Aaron Gordon. Just goes to show what kind of support Jokic has.
There's just zero consistency in your logic here. Doncic had a mediocre supporting cast in Dallas, but Jokic's supporting cast has just been downright poor. We've seen Jokic carry even worse supporting casts, with Will Barton as the second best player, to the playoffs. We've seen him come back from 3-1 deficits multiple times. And he's done it without any HOF, let alone All-Star teammates. He's a C averaging a near triple double on elite efficiency, no one's going to forget all of this because his team had poor outings in the playoffs.