2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks (NYK leads 1-0)

Moderators: cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, ken6199, Domejandro, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid

Who wins and goes to the ECFs?

Poll ended at Thu May 8, 2025 2:36 am

Celtics in 4
27
10%
Celtics in 5
111
42%
Celtics in 6
58
22%
Celtics in 7
12
4%
Knicks in 4
9
3%
Knicks in 5
5
2%
Knicks in 6
15
6%
Knicks in 7
30
11%
 
Total votes: 267

User avatar
KamikazeK
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,559
And1: 7,214
Joined: Nov 17, 2012
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#181 » by KamikazeK » Sun May 4, 2025 1:42 am

Caneman786 wrote:Knicks in 5 let's go Knicks.

Someone needs to eliminate the most fraudulent "champions" in the history of the game.

In reality I don't think the Knicks have it in them, but you never know.

I'm probably never gonna see you again after we repeat, so i just wanted to say that I hope you enjoy the rest of your life and experience great happiness.
Image
The Corey's
RealGM
Posts: 12,691
And1: 8,482
Joined: Jan 29, 2006

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#182 » by The Corey's » Sun May 4, 2025 2:03 am

LFGK wrote:
cgf wrote:
iggymcfrack wrote:
They have a worse SRS than any of those teams except for Indiana and the Pacers have been much better in the second half of the season with Nembhard healthy. In Round 1, the Knicks played a team that was much worse than any of those teams and they outscored them by 1.3 PPG. Pacers out scored a similar opponent by 7.3 PPG in the first round. It’s indexing ridiculously hard on vibes to take the Knicks over the Clippers with Kawhi, the Warriors with Butler, or the Nuggets with Jokic.


When games start being decided by srs, we can talk about that instead of the results on the court. Until then Denver doesn’t have enough around Jokic to hang with us and GSW is just too small to beat us with Towns & Brunson healthy. Clippers have the size & supporting cast, but in 2025 I’m taking Brunson over Kawhi in crunchtime :dontknow:

And Milwaukee was much worse than Detroit or Orlando this season, that’s why everyone in the east except Cleveland wanted to play them in round one. People pay too much attention to past accomplishments with teams that have a big name. Giannis is awesome but I was begging to play the Bucks over the Pistons before the seedings were set.

PS what did srs have to say about LA - MIN? Cause that seemed like an obvious win for the wolves that a lot of folks got wrong because they ignored how the two teams would actually matchup.


Brother why u arguing with this clown? Let him talk and they will see in a couple days


See what? How many times the Celtics gotta beat the Knicks before y'all start giving the flowers.
LFGK
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,840
And1: 1,479
Joined: Apr 24, 2024
       

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#183 » by LFGK » Sun May 4, 2025 3:02 am

The Corey's wrote:
LFGK wrote:
cgf wrote:
When games start being decided by srs, we can talk about that instead of the results on the court. Until then Denver doesn’t have enough around Jokic to hang with us and GSW is just too small to beat us with Towns & Brunson healthy. Clippers have the size & supporting cast, but in 2025 I’m taking Brunson over Kawhi in crunchtime :dontknow:

And Milwaukee was much worse than Detroit or Orlando this season, that’s why everyone in the east except Cleveland wanted to play them in round one. People pay too much attention to past accomplishments with teams that have a big name. Giannis is awesome but I was begging to play the Bucks over the Pistons before the seedings were set.

PS what did srs have to say about LA - MIN? Cause that seemed like an obvious win for the wolves that a lot of folks got wrong because they ignored how the two teams would actually matchup.


Brother why u arguing with this clown? Let him talk and they will see in a couple days


See what? How many times the Celtics gotta beat the Knicks before y'all start giving the flowers.


Sounds good big dawg we'll talk
About this in the upcoming week
The Corey's
RealGM
Posts: 12,691
And1: 8,482
Joined: Jan 29, 2006

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#184 » by The Corey's » Sun May 4, 2025 3:31 am

LFGK wrote:
The Corey's wrote:
LFGK wrote:
Brother why u arguing with this clown? Let him talk and they will see in a couple days


See what? How many times the Celtics gotta beat the Knicks before y'all start giving the flowers.


Sounds good big dawg we'll talk
About this in the upcoming week


There's nothing to talk about lol.

When the Celtics rip apart the Knicks the only thing we're gonna hear is how hurt the Knicks are and how the Celtics are once again on the easiert route to a championship ever.


It's deja Vu here. The Celtics disrespect is strong.
User avatar
ITGM
RealGM
Posts: 19,896
And1: 9,216
Joined: Jan 16, 2008

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#185 » by ITGM » Sun May 4, 2025 3:41 am

ryan in Maine wrote:Jalen Brunson and what army


Image
cgf
RealGM
Posts: 34,918
And1: 14,369
Joined: Jul 01, 2008
   

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#186 » by cgf » Sun May 4, 2025 2:41 pm

robbie84 wrote:
cgf wrote:
robbie84 wrote:
The Knicks are thoroughly outmatched in every single category. And the Celtics will get Holiday back. It's just a really good, really deep Celtics team that just won a championship.
Basically the Celtics, Cavs and obviously the Thunder are in their own tier this season.


I think you’ll be surprised.


Where do you think the Knicks could find an advantage? Anything in particular that Thibs will focus on?


Outright advantages? Probably just physicality / rebounding now that Robinson is back & our wings can be more aggressive. But Brunson - Tatum as closers could go either way if the games are close enough to be decided at the end…especially since we both have absolutely elite defensive counters to one another’s top star (White & OG).

Towns impact is a big question mark, if he can play more like he did in that last matchup than the first two, then I’ll feel confident about it being a long series…nevermind if he can continue defending the way he was against the pistons in crunchtime; didn’t have that on my bingo card at all lol.

And Bridges feels like he could be a real x-factor for us in this, especially if Jrue is at all limited…assuming Brown will defend OG and Tatum will defend Towns again.

I’m not saying I think you’ll be surprised because we’ll crush the Celtics, just that it should be a closer & more entertaining series than some folks expect.
Capn'O wrote:We're the recovering meth addict older brother. And we've been clean for a few years now, thank you very much. Very uncouth to bring it up.

Brunson: So what are you paid to do?
Hart: Run around like an idiot during the game and f*** s*** up!
Blazing_royale
General Manager
Posts: 9,594
And1: 2,596
Joined: Jul 03, 2006

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#187 » by Blazing_royale » Sun May 4, 2025 2:42 pm

I'm hyped for this series. Realgm server gonna crash. 2 historic and large fanbase clash!
Image
Any Pokémon fans out there? Check out my Youtube channel jchucollection
LFGK
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,840
And1: 1,479
Joined: Apr 24, 2024
       

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#188 » by LFGK » Sun May 4, 2025 2:52 pm

The Corey's wrote:
LFGK wrote:
The Corey's wrote:
See what? How many times the Celtics gotta beat the Knicks before y'all start giving the flowers.


Sounds good big dawg we'll talk
About this in the upcoming week


There's nothing to talk about lol.

When the Celtics rip apart the Knicks the only thing we're gonna hear is how hurt the Knicks are and how the Celtics are once again on the easiert route to a championship ever.


It's deja Vu here. The Celtics disrespect is strong.


Sounds good
User avatar
RHODEY
RealGM
Posts: 24,836
And1: 22,410
Joined: May 18, 2007
Location: Straight out of a comic book

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#189 » by RHODEY » Sun May 4, 2025 3:53 pm

Knicks in six, the Celts looked very beatable versus Orlando.
User avatar
Capn'O
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 89,014
And1: 108,057
Joined: Dec 16, 2005
Location: Bone Goal
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#190 » by Capn'O » Sun May 4, 2025 4:03 pm

bisme37 wrote:Celtics health updates... Jrue has gone through full practice and the hammy feels good. Brown says his knee is tending toward 100% by start of the series. And Tatum's wrist is fine (he's actually been shooting better since the injury lol). Seems like the C's will be good to go.


Bisme out here like:

Image

Brunson will find the weak point!
BAF Clippers: Great Team. No Future.
PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe

Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry


:beer:
User avatar
Capn'O
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 89,014
And1: 108,057
Joined: Dec 16, 2005
Location: Bone Goal
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#191 » by Capn'O » Sun May 4, 2025 4:14 pm

The Corey's wrote:
LFGK wrote:
The Corey's wrote:
See what? How many times the Celtics gotta beat the Knicks before y'all start giving the flowers.


Sounds good big dawg we'll talk
About this in the upcoming week


There's nothing to talk about lol.

When the Celtics rip apart the Knicks the only thing we're gonna hear is how hurt the Knicks are and how the Celtics are once again on the easiert route to a championship ever.


It's deja Vu here. The Celtics disrespect is strong.


If we lose 4 rotation players for the bulk of the series then, yeah, you'll probably hear about how we lost 4 rotation players for the bulk of the series.

Right now we're pretty healthy which is why you're not hearing that.
BAF Clippers: Great Team. No Future.
PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe

Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry


:beer:
LFGK
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,840
And1: 1,479
Joined: Apr 24, 2024
       

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#192 » by LFGK » Sun May 4, 2025 4:55 pm

Capn'O wrote:
The Corey's wrote:
LFGK wrote:
Sounds good big dawg we'll talk
About this in the upcoming week


There's nothing to talk about lol.

When the Celtics rip apart the Knicks the only thing we're gonna hear is how hurt the Knicks are and how the Celtics are once again on the easiert route to a championship ever.


It's deja Vu here. The Celtics disrespect is strong.


If we lose 4 rotation players for the bulk of the series then, yeah, you'll probably hear about how we lost 4 rotation players for the bulk of the series.

Right now we're pretty healthy which is why you're not hearing that.


Nostradamus said there's nothing to talk about about, he knows how every series is going to go.
iggymcfrack
RealGM
Posts: 11,599
And1: 9,109
Joined: Sep 26, 2017

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#193 » by iggymcfrack » Sun May 4, 2025 5:02 pm

bronxknicksfan1 wrote:
iggymcfrack wrote:
bronxknicksfan1 wrote:
You know Brunson missed 15 games towards the end of the season, right? Before he went down, the Knicks were top 6 in net rating and a top 5 record in the league. Saying they’re on par or better than a majority of playoff teams not named the Thunder/Celtics/Cavs is not ridiculous.


The Knicks had a point differential of +72 in the 16 games Brunson missed for an average of +4.5 per game. That’s actually slightly better than their season average of +4.1. Other teams have had more impactful injuries.


More impactful than the best player on the team going down? Nembhard, the Pacers 4th best player, makes the Pacers much better but losing Brunson doesn’t make the Knicks much worse? Trying to understand the logic of that one.


I mean I was simplifying; it was Nembhard and Nesmith and also Haliburton was banged up and playing nowhere near his level early in the year. Also you know nothing about the Pacers if you think Nembhard’s their 4th best player. His defense is massive. Hes easily their 3rd best player.

Pacers record without Nembhard (Nesmith also missed all these games): 6-11

Knicks record without Brunson: 11-6
iggymcfrack
RealGM
Posts: 11,599
And1: 9,109
Joined: Sep 26, 2017

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#194 » by iggymcfrack » Sun May 4, 2025 5:04 pm

RHODEY wrote:Knicks in six, the Celts looked very beatable versus Orlando.


I mean Detroit’s not that much better than Orlando. Knicks beat Detroit by 1 point per game. Celtics beat Magic by 11 points per game without really trying.
User avatar
bisme37
Forum Mod - Celtics
Forum Mod - Celtics
Posts: 24,328
And1: 70,988
Joined: May 24, 2014
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#195 » by bisme37 » Sun May 4, 2025 5:09 pm

iggymcfrack wrote:
RHODEY wrote:Knicks in six, the Celts looked very beatable versus Orlando.


I mean Detroit’s not that much better than Orlando. Knicks beat Detroit by 1 point per game. Celtics beat Magic by 11 points per game without really trying.


Magic are the best team at guarding the 3pt line. Knicks are the worst team at guarding the 3pt line. It's a completely different series for Boston.

I thought the Celts looked great last series considering the injuries and the fact that they had to play a much different style than usual. It was hard to get the 3pt barrage going and the C's had to iso more, play in the midrange a lot, and score tough baskets over good defenders. And still won by an average of 11 points per game as you said.
Gonna miss KP but he's no Georges Niang.
User avatar
RHODEY
RealGM
Posts: 24,836
And1: 22,410
Joined: May 18, 2007
Location: Straight out of a comic book

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#196 » by RHODEY » Sun May 4, 2025 5:39 pm

iggymcfrack wrote:
RHODEY wrote:Knicks in six, the Celts looked very beatable versus Orlando.


I mean Detroit’s not that much better than Orlando. Knicks beat Detroit by 1 point per game. Celtics beat Magic by 11 points per game without really trying.


Orlando consisted of 2 goo forwards and not much else. IMO that healthy Pistons is a lot better than the ORL team the Celtics faced.
User avatar
Capn'O
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 89,014
And1: 108,057
Joined: Dec 16, 2005
Location: Bone Goal
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#197 » by Capn'O » Sun May 4, 2025 5:46 pm

Brunson treated the regular season like preseason this year. He's been a different beast in the playoffs. More like the impact darling he was last year. Somewhat inexplicably, Thibs has gone away from Delon Wright, who started in Brunson's place when he was out and filled in admirably.

I've always liked Wright. Solid, two way backup who can fill in in a pinch. He's a much better lead guard than Payne too.
BAF Clippers: Great Team. No Future.
PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe

Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry


:beer:
LFGK
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,840
And1: 1,479
Joined: Apr 24, 2024
       

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#198 » by LFGK » Sun May 4, 2025 5:50 pm

bisme37 wrote:
iggymcfrack wrote:
RHODEY wrote:Knicks in six, the Celts looked very beatable versus Orlando.


I mean Detroit’s not that much better than Orlando. Knicks beat Detroit by 1 point per game. Celtics beat Magic by 11 points per game without really trying.


Magic are the best team at guarding the 3pt line. Knicks are the worst team at guarding the 3pt line. It's a completely different series for Boston.

I thought the Celts looked great last series considering the injuries and the fact that they had to play a much different style than usual. It was hard to get the 3pt barrage going and the C's had to iso more, play in the midrange a lot, and score tough baskets over good defenders. And still won by an average of 11 points per game as you said.


The Knicks are towards the top of the teams in the playoffs for 3PT%, held Detroit 4-5% less then their reg season avg. Celtic fans gonna be in for a rude awakening man they think they have a cakewalk but this series is going to be a battle.
User avatar
Raps in 4
RealGM
Posts: 65,950
And1: 60,719
Joined: Nov 01, 2008
Location: Toronto
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#199 » by Raps in 4 » Sun May 4, 2025 6:00 pm

My two most hated sports cities. Oddly though, I don't hate either team (in terms of their rosters). I think Boston wins this easily, but I'll be pulling for the upset.
User avatar
bisme37
Forum Mod - Celtics
Forum Mod - Celtics
Posts: 24,328
And1: 70,988
Joined: May 24, 2014
 

Re: 2025 NBA PLAYOFFS East Semifinals: #2 Boston Celtics vs #3 New York Knicks 

Post#200 » by bisme37 » Sun May 4, 2025 6:05 pm

LFGK wrote:
bisme37 wrote:
iggymcfrack wrote:
I mean Detroit’s not that much better than Orlando. Knicks beat Detroit by 1 point per game. Celtics beat Magic by 11 points per game without really trying.


Magic are the best team at guarding the 3pt line. Knicks are the worst team at guarding the 3pt line. It's a completely different series for Boston.

I thought the Celts looked great last series considering the injuries and the fact that they had to play a much different style than usual. It was hard to get the 3pt barrage going and the C's had to iso more, play in the midrange a lot, and score tough baskets over good defenders. And still won by an average of 11 points per game as you said.


The Knicks are towards the top of the teams in the playoffs for 3PT%, held Detroit 4-5% less then their reg season avg. Celtic fans gonna be in for a rude awakening man they think they have a cakewalk but this series is going to be a battle.


I'm not expecting a cake walk. I'm expecting to win a tough series. I think it will be easier for the Celtics to score in this series than our last one, but the Knicks are much better than Orlando offensively, and your Clutch Player of the Year will def give me stress down the stretch of close games.
Gonna miss KP but he's no Georges Niang.

Return to The General Board