Drax wrote:ShazaamLion wrote:Why would you give a statue to a guy who couldn't win a championship over the one of the most dominant forces in the sports history who won 3 for the franchise? Statues are given for the accomplishments not the amount of years played for the team.
Elgin never won a championship nor the mvp award. I wouldn't have a problem seeing both getting their statues built but picking Elgin over Shaq? That's just reaching.
Banners and retired numbers are for accomplishments, statues should stand for way more than that.
The word accomplishment consists of many things, even the thing like putting the franchise back on the map is considered accomplishment, this is what shaq did, otherwise they would have been that early 00s mavs level team, stacked up but not enough to win it all.
I don't know every detail of the 50 60s 70s era basketball but what did elgin baylor do exactly that was significantly more meaningful to the lakers franchise than what shaq did in those 8 seasons?
Was elgin ballin out there and fighting for the black rights like bill russell or kareem?
By the way it's not that hard to spend the whole career with lakers, first of all its the city, and second that franchise was always good enough to at least make the playoffs and make some noise. Minus the current laker franchise and couple of years from 00s 90s and 70s
They should build a miniature statue for elgin out there with the textwork saying "sorry elgin, them celtics were better"