Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world?

Moderators: Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

Was Muggsy the best player in the world?

Poll ended at Sat May 21, 2022 8:20 pm

Yes, he had to be to make it at 5'3
29
39%
No way
41
55%
He was good, but only stayed in the league as a "side show" factor
5
7%
 
Total votes: 75

Lockdown504090
RealGM
Posts: 11,664
And1: 12,611
Joined: Nov 24, 2015
         

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#21 » by Lockdown504090 » Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:10 am

ive been to his camp, hes really that small btw. hes shorter than kevin hart.
User avatar
Michael Jackson
Forum Mod - Bulls
Forum Mod - Bulls
Posts: 29,559
And1: 11,690
Joined: Jun 15, 2001

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#22 » by Michael Jackson » Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:15 am

It's hyperbole calling him the best ever even pound for pound. Still an amazing player. One could argue though say he was 6'3" he wouldn't have developed the skills he did. Part of his development I am sure was because he had to. Also guarding a guy like that is a different challenge because he is a completely different look. Was he better than Boykins? Maybe but he was a crazy athlete too. Nate might take the cake though as far as athlete and skill size etc... but he was taller than Mugsy so that disqualifies him?
User avatar
Michael Jackson
Forum Mod - Bulls
Forum Mod - Bulls
Posts: 29,559
And1: 11,690
Joined: Jun 15, 2001

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#23 » by Michael Jackson » Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:17 am

Lockdown504090 wrote:ive been to his camp, hes really that small btw. hes shorter than kevin hart.



I was at a game with curtsied seats behind the visitors bench, happened to be the Nuggets that night. I'm looking Boykins warm up and I thought it was the ball boy at first, like damn that kid has a stroke! Then I shortly after that felt stupid and figured out who it was.
DCasey91
General Manager
Posts: 9,427
And1: 5,686
Joined: Dec 15, 2020
   

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#24 » by DCasey91 » Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:30 am

nikster wrote:
First Step wrote:I'm the best chess player in the world when you adjust for IQ.

dont think chess is that strongly associated with IQ tho



Sorry to tell you but it’s the opposite. The top 30 grandmasters in the world has by far the highest IQ recorded for any profession. Basically genius level intellect that’s just for raw IQ (IQ is the best indicator we have for career success in fields with high IQs general to the population doctors, lawyers, scientists etc. but I digress).

Makes sense humans have a tipping point on mathematics when taking lines of play. They can stretch it further then everybody else but pales in comparison to a Chess Machine where a 20th line is very simple but for a greatest chess players ever that’s basically a mystery the numbers of lines would fill up a whole post.

One of the most impressive things is when Kasparov beat Deep Blue and Lee Sedol won a game with Alpha Go decades later (very interesting docu on AL learning which is far superior than us). Dubbed the “GOD” move whereby the machine didn’t account for the 1/10,000 move and thus turning the game on its head. In the interview Sedol just said it felt right and didn’t think about it. Up to a point we definelty don’t have the computational power to think that far ahead.

Used to be emulation from an inferior source (us)
Then to machine learning from machine
Now to self learning and vs other game machines
Or machine vs machine with their own biases on learning involved.

Cool part about it is humans now learn from machines and not the other way around. Now lines of play that would make normal humans have migraines and the best in the world make it understandable. They actually do the heavy lifting now on gamestates. I think from memory it’s about six steps mostly covered for after opening play. There’s an unimaginable number of variations but that is also covered well by the machine and historicity on backlogs that leads to essentially similar board states. It’s revolutionary now in Chess because the game is trending towards more “opening kind of play” because a huge X number, and much more lines of play has been accounted for.

Insane part about it is that Magnus Carlsen the GOAT probably remembers most of the lines he’s ever come across and read. He can play 50+ average men blindfolded and would beat everyone one of them pretty comfortably. That’s a genius and then some.

For Muggsy it’ll be more like a less talented Mighty Mouse Johnson being able to contend (no where near being the best) at welterweight which is absurd in of itself.

Physically an anomaly in the NBA probably the rarest case on record but it doesn’t have much to do with IQ but I get the op’s statement.
Li WenWen is the GOAT
bbalnation
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,665
And1: 954
Joined: Jan 24, 2006

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#25 » by bbalnation » Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:37 am

He was definitely one of the craftiest offensive and defensive players of all time. Players were large and fast when Bogues was playing... we're talking about Mike's generation. Not as athletic as today (objectively, that's how human evolution and modern medicine/health work), but still: everyone was 6'2+, and large centers/power forwards were prominent.

5'3?

In pickup basketball, we used to go at my boy who was like 5'4 (he adjusted), and we were all 5'11 tops. Bogues doing what he did at an NBA level, as long as he did, as well as he did, is shake your head worthy of impressive imo.

I dont know if I'd describe it as "best" though. If he had a Steph like jumper I'd have a hard time disagreeing. But without that major basketball skill, its hard for me to see, especially when Steph is doing what hes doing (1 foot taller or not).
Buckeye-NBAFan
General Manager
Posts: 8,092
And1: 4,774
Joined: Jun 25, 2004

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#26 » by Buckeye-NBAFan » Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:41 am

GregOden wrote:Well you would hope the best pound for pound player in the world would be able to shoot a higher career FT% than 82.7...


What does it matter if he can shoot 80% from the field against every other 5'3 player.
User avatar
Sothron
Head Coach
Posts: 6,245
And1: 3,310
Joined: Oct 27, 2001
       

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#27 » by Sothron » Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:53 am

I am 5'9" and started in Division 3 college basketball at PG. I was the shortest guy on the court every game. I can't even imagine how Muggsy did it at 5'3" against the best players in the world. I've always respected him and Spud Webb and other short guys that had long careers in the NBA. I don't think Muggsy was the best player in the world but pound for pound? Yes, I can see that argument.
theforumblue
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,093
And1: 5,281
Joined: Feb 18, 2012

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#28 » by theforumblue » Tue Nov 23, 2021 8:04 pm

Michael Jackson wrote:It's hyperbole calling him the best ever even pound for pound. Still an amazing player. One could argue though say he was 6'3" he wouldn't have developed the skills he did. Part of his development I am sure was because he had to. Also guarding a guy like that is a different challenge because he is a completely different look. Was he better than Boykins? Maybe but he was a crazy athlete too. Nate might take the cake though as far as athlete and skill size etc... but he was taller than Mugsy so that disqualifies him?


nate's 6 inches taller and 45lb heavier. that's a huge difference even if mugsy was 6'3, let alone 5'3.
screw these absolute garbage refs
DCasey91
General Manager
Posts: 9,427
And1: 5,686
Joined: Dec 15, 2020
   

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#29 » by DCasey91 » Tue Nov 23, 2021 8:26 pm

Sothron wrote:I am 5'9" and started in Division 3 college basketball at PG. I was the shortest guy on the court every game. I can't even imagine how Muggsy did it at 5'3" against the best players in the world. I've always respected him and Spud Webb and other short guys that had long careers in the NBA. I don't think Muggsy was the best player in the world but pound for pound? Yes, I can see that argument.


Quick anecdote my oldest brother is best mates with three brothers (set of twins) that are 6”9”, 6”10, 6”11 Straight up they got offered to play for a district team because of their height and none of them ever picked up a basketball lol. They are all batsh*t crazy, the most “behaved” one has a criminal record to paint a picture.

It’s awesome though being with him nice blokes but yeah crazy and basically when your out in the town everybody basically just steps aside.

I’m 5”9” too I definitely know what your talking about. Only thing that helps me is I have bloody chimp knuckle dragging arms and can touch the rim lmao
Li WenWen is the GOAT
NeoDragonKnight
Starter
Posts: 2,394
And1: 2,626
Joined: Aug 12, 2008
     

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#30 » by NeoDragonKnight » Wed Nov 24, 2021 2:58 am

I mean Muggsy also used his size to his advantage being able to dog other PGs constantly up the court, I recall on opencourt Cwebb was saying other PGs hated playing against Muggsy for that reason, and unless you had elite ball handling skills like Mitch Richmond, then he wore you down.
bballfan1three3
Senior
Posts: 600
And1: 854
Joined: Feb 10, 2021

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#31 » by bballfan1three3 » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:20 am

Yes

Legends get no respect

Other thread basketball is 99.99999% genetics, muggsy is the walking exception

Muggsy is the real 1 in a billion athlete. Not some 6 10 guy with a jumper, the 5'3 guy who was an All Star. In the mother friggin NBA. For 10 years!!!!! Everyone in this thread is 5'9-6' talking about how tall people have an advantage. To muggsy, everyone is tall.

Cant believe he isn't talked about more, NBA never talks about him. He set the standard too high, there might not be another muggsy cause now not only do you have to be 5'3 quality NBA player you also have to be a 5'3 10 time all star or else all the haters will be like 'wasnt as good as muggsy' because the NBA is a hater society.
User avatar
Saint Lazarus
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,107
And1: 7,609
Joined: May 20, 2018
Location: Anti-Defamation League
     

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#32 » by Saint Lazarus » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:27 am

Celtics IT > Michael Jordan
dorkestra wrote:Embiid is embarrassing the whole city of Philadelphia. Wake up you little bitch

The Comedian wrote:Saint Lazarus playing 4D chess right now.

This dude legit has other Celtics fans arguing with him :lol:
User avatar
homecourtloss
RealGM
Posts: 11,276
And1: 18,686
Joined: Dec 29, 2012

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#33 » by homecourtloss » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:35 am

nikster wrote:
First Step wrote:I'm the best chess player in the world when you adjust for IQ.

dont think chess is that strongly associated with IQ tho


How and why would one think this? High level chess players are all highly intelligent.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160913124722.htm
lessthanjake wrote:Kyrie was extremely impactful without LeBron, and basically had zero impact whatsoever if LeBron was on the court.

lessthanjake wrote: By playing in a way that prevents Kyrie from getting much impact, LeBron ensures that controlling for Kyrie has limited effect…
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 48,876
And1: 26,304
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#34 » by dhsilv2 » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:49 am

nikster wrote:
First Step wrote:I'm the best chess player in the world when you adjust for IQ.

dont think chess is that strongly associated with IQ tho


Seems a pretty strong correlation though it's certainly not perfect. Both due to IQ test issues, some areas of IQ not really being important here, and of course practice.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160913124722.htm#:~:text=The%20study%20found%20that%20intelligence,at%20lower%20levels%20of%20skill.&text=%22Imagine%20that%20a%20genius%20can,average%20intelligence%20may%20take%20longer.

https://thechessworld.com/articles/healthpsycology/chess-rating-and-iq-score-correlation/
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 48,876
And1: 26,304
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#35 » by dhsilv2 » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:54 am

bballfan1three3 wrote:Yes

Legends get no respect

Other thread basketball is 99.99999% genetics, muggsy is the walking exception

Muggsy is the real 1 in a billion athlete. Not some 6 10 guy with a jumper, the 5'3 guy who was an All Star. In the mother friggin NBA. For 10 years!!!!! Everyone in this thread is 5'9-6' talking about how tall people have an advantage. To muggsy, everyone is tall.

Cant believe he isn't talked about more, NBA never talks about him. He set the standard too high, there might not be another muggsy cause now not only do you have to be 5'3 quality NBA player you also have to be a 5'3 10 time all star or else all the haters will be like 'wasnt as good as muggsy' because the NBA is a hater society.


wasn't an allstar...
User avatar
Sothron
Head Coach
Posts: 6,245
And1: 3,310
Joined: Oct 27, 2001
       

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#36 » by Sothron » Wed Nov 24, 2021 5:54 am

DCasey91 wrote:
Sothron wrote:I am 5'9" and started in Division 3 college basketball at PG. I was the shortest guy on the court every game. I can't even imagine how Muggsy did it at 5'3" against the best players in the world. I've always respected him and Spud Webb and other short guys that had long careers in the NBA. I don't think Muggsy was the best player in the world but pound for pound? Yes, I can see that argument.


Quick anecdote my oldest brother is best mates with three brothers (set of twins) that are 6”9”, 6”10, 6”11 Straight up they got offered to play for a district team because of their height and none of them ever picked up a basketball lol. They are all batsh*t crazy, the most “behaved” one has a criminal record to paint a picture.

It’s awesome though being with him nice blokes but yeah crazy and basically when your out in the town everybody basically just steps aside.

I’m 5”9” too I definitely know what your talking about. Only thing that helps me is I have bloody chimp knuckle dragging arms and can touch the rim lmao


That wingspan can save you. I had great speed and hops. I could dunk on a regulation basket until I tore my hamstring in college. It is crazy how any tall guy can be offered a chance to play basketball just in the hopes of teaching skills but smaller guys get almost no chance to play. Hence why I had to play Div 3 instead of higher but hey, loved every second of my college days.
tbhawksfan1
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,227
And1: 2,629
Joined: May 23, 2015

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#37 » by tbhawksfan1 » Wed Nov 24, 2021 10:25 am

hauntedcomputer wrote:Didn't Smith say "pound for pound, the best player in the world" or something like that?

Would you rather have three Muggsies or one Zion?


Comparing the shortest player in history to the fatest is probably a bad example :lol:
tbhawksfan1
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,227
And1: 2,629
Joined: May 23, 2015

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#38 » by tbhawksfan1 » Wed Nov 24, 2021 10:27 am

tbhawksfan1 wrote:
hauntedcomputer wrote:Didn't Smith say "pound for pound, the best player in the world" or something like that?

Would you rather have three Muggsies or one Zion?


Comparing the shortest player in history to the fatest is probably a bad example :lol:


...and one Zion equals about eight Muggsies :lol:
brutalitops
Head Coach
Posts: 6,257
And1: 7,993
Joined: Feb 20, 2014
Location: Perth, Australia
     

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#39 » by brutalitops » Wed Nov 24, 2021 10:37 am

Nah


Muggsey Bogues 5'3"
Points 6857


Michael Jordan 6'6"
Points 32,292

So is 13 inches a 5 times multiplier?
frica
Pro Prospect
Posts: 935
And1: 485
Joined: May 03, 2018

Re: Was Muggsy Bogues the best player in the world? 

Post#40 » by frica » Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:12 pm

DCasey91 wrote:
nikster wrote:
First Step wrote:I'm the best chess player in the world when you adjust for IQ.

dont think chess is that strongly associated with IQ tho



Sorry to tell you but it’s the opposite. The top 30 grandmasters in the world has by far the highest IQ recorded for any profession. Basically genius level intellect that’s just for raw IQ (IQ is the best indicator we have for career success in fields with high IQs general to the population doctors, lawyers, scientists etc. but I digress).

Makes sense humans have a tipping point on mathematics when taking lines of play. They can stretch it further then everybody else but pales in comparison to a Chess Machine where a 20th line is very simple but for a greatest chess players ever that’s basically a mystery the numbers of lines would fill up a whole post.

One of the most impressive things is when Kasparov beat Deep Blue and Lee Sedol won a game with Alpha Go decades later (very interesting docu on AL learning which is far superior than us). Dubbed the “GOD” move whereby the machine didn’t account for the 1/10,000 move and thus turning the game on its head. In the interview Sedol just said it felt right and didn’t think about it. Up to a point we definelty don’t have the computational power to think that far ahead.

Used to be emulation from an inferior source (us)
Then to machine learning from machine
Now to self learning and vs other game machines
Or machine vs machine with their own biases on learning involved.

Cool part about it is humans now learn from machines and not the other way around. Now lines of play that would make normal humans have migraines and the best in the world make it understandable. They actually do the heavy lifting now on gamestates. I think from memory it’s about six steps mostly covered for after opening play. There’s an unimaginable number of variations but that is also covered well by the machine and historicity on backlogs that leads to essentially similar board states. It’s revolutionary now in Chess because the game is trending towards more “opening kind of play” because a huge X number, and much more lines of play has been accounted for.

Insane part about it is that Magnus Carlsen the GOAT probably remembers most of the lines he’s ever come across and read. He can play 50+ average men blindfolded and would beat everyone one of them pretty comfortably. That’s a genius and then some.

For Muggsy it’ll be more like a less talented Mighty Mouse Johnson being able to contend (no where near being the best) at welterweight which is absurd in of itself.

Physically an anomaly in the NBA probably the rarest case on record but it doesn’t have much to do with IQ but I get the op’s statement.

Based on what?
I know Nakamura (arguably best blitz player) did a MENSA test, and he scored an extremely average 103... even complained about not having enough time.
That's one of the best chess players alive, and arguably the fastest thinker in the sport.
Bang on average IQ.

Chess =/= IQ

Edit: Nakamura tested 102, not 103.

Return to The General Board