Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#321 » by JonFromVA » Mon Mar 20, 2023 2:43 am

Zetsword wrote:I'm curious what the Cavs will look like having Mitchell/Garland with three guys that can't hit the three in the lineup in the playoffs. It's gonna be interesting.


Been watching it all season...

... troubling thing is Garland and Mitchell both are dealing with finger problems affecting their shooting, but the bench has been stepping up. Well, except for Dean Wade who's shoulder injury is still bothering him. Many of us felt if healthy, he might have taken over Lauri’s old role on the team or at least Love's.
edededtut
Senior
Posts: 525
And1: 699
Joined: Dec 28, 2019

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#322 » by edededtut » Mon Mar 20, 2023 8:04 am

JonFromVA wrote:As for Lauri's defense, I find it hard to accept a player is anything special on D when his team stinks on D. If you've got some lineups you feel represent Lauri's ability more accurately, feel free to present your counter evidence.


I don't really know what we are discussing here any more, nobody is saying Lauri is special on D, but he is better than what his reputation used to be and to some still is, and better than what you seem to be insinuating with your remarks about playing with Kessler and Utah still having a bad team defensive rating.

If you want to look at numbers, after the all star break Utah is 16th in the defensive ranking stat. While nothing to write home about in itself, they are doing it while being 4th in the pace stat. It's a small sample size, but defense is a team effort and personnel matters. One player can't really do much if everyone around him sucks. Well unless you are a generational defender anchoring the defense (which mobley seems to be becoming).
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#323 » by JonFromVA » Mon Mar 20, 2023 4:14 pm

el_Diablo wrote:
JonFromVA wrote:As for Lauri's defense, I find it hard to accept a player is anything special on D when his team stinks on D. If you've got some lineups you feel represent Lauri's ability more accurately, feel free to present your counter evidence.


I don't really know what we are discussing here any more, nobody is saying Lauri is special on D, but he is better than what his reputation used to be and to some still is, and better than what you seem to be insinuating with your remarks about playing with Kessler and Utah still having a bad team defensive rating.

If you want to look at numbers, after the all star break Utah is 16th in the defensive ranking stat. While nothing to write home about in itself, they are doing it while being 4th in the pace stat. It's a small sample size, but defense is a team effort and personnel matters. One player can't really do much if everyone around him sucks. Well unless you are a generational defender anchoring the defense (which mobley seems to be becoming).


I wasn't trying to "insinuate" anything, I was just stating ground truth. Allen/Mobley can protect Mitchell/Garland defensively. If we're going to remove Mobley and insert Markkanen and someone else (OG, Siakim, etc) we have to understand what's going to happen to the team on both ends of the floor.

And then beyond what's happening on the floor, we have a bunch of other concerns regarding chemistry, personality, salary, and trying to keep a group of players together for more than a couple of years.

I get the temptation people feel to "fix the Cavs" by imposing on them a more modern lineup, but this is just year one for this core making the playoffs, and in spite of trading for Mitchell, they do not accept the idea that they must win now. Beyond that, their klunky lineups have become their identity. Benching and waiving Kevin Love was basically saying they didn't want to compromise their defense anymore, not even for gravity/shooting.
Zetsword
Junior
Posts: 305
And1: 167
Joined: Nov 20, 2020
 

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#324 » by Zetsword » Mon Mar 20, 2023 11:05 pm

JonFromVA wrote:
Zetsword wrote:I'm curious what the Cavs will look like having Mitchell/Garland with three guys that can't hit the three in the lineup in the playoffs. It's gonna be interesting.


Been watching it all season...

... troubling thing is Garland and Mitchell both are dealing with finger problems affecting their shooting, but the bench has been stepping up. Well, except for Dean Wade who's shoulder injury is still bothering him. Many of us felt if healthy, he might have taken over Lauri’s old role on the team or at least Love's.

I meant in the playoffs where your weaknesses are targeted consistently.
User avatar
ijspeelman
Forum Mod - Cavs
Forum Mod - Cavs
Posts: 2,664
And1: 1,223
Joined: Feb 17, 2022
Contact:
   

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#325 » by ijspeelman » Mon Mar 20, 2023 11:20 pm

Zetsword wrote:
JonFromVA wrote:
Zetsword wrote:I'm curious what the Cavs will look like having Mitchell/Garland with three guys that can't hit the three in the lineup in the playoffs. It's gonna be interesting.


Been watching it all season...

... troubling thing is Garland and Mitchell both are dealing with finger problems affecting their shooting, but the bench has been stepping up. Well, except for Dean Wade who's shoulder injury is still bothering him. Many of us felt if healthy, he might have taken over Lauri’s old role on the team or at least Love's.

I meant in the playoffs where your weaknesses are targeted consistently.


We've seen a lot of the contenders (and non-contenders) put us through the ringer by sagging way off our shooters. Its gone both directions.

Garland has been born in spacing hell so he's pretty accustomed to working the paint without space. Mitchell has surprised me by how good he is when everyone collapses or is already in the paint. He can get to the paint and make it look easy. The problem is less with these guys and more that the others need to find ways to score as well.
JJ_PR
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,278
And1: 4,012
Joined: Mar 19, 2015
Location: Puerto Rico
   

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#326 » by JJ_PR » Tue Mar 21, 2023 1:08 am

We traded the right big man, & it isn't even debatable. Mobley could be an MVP candidate one day. Markkanen is a nice player who might get a few all-star selections. But if it came down to Markkanen or Mobley, the Cavs absolutely did the right thing.
User avatar
ocelot17
Veteran
Posts: 2,586
And1: 4,017
Joined: Feb 28, 2010
Location: Houston, Tx
   

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#327 » by ocelot17 » Tue Mar 21, 2023 1:22 am

Wasn’t Markkanen traded to the Jazz as a throw in just to match salaries? That’s too bad for the Cavs, they could’ve been a contender for the next couple of seasons.
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#328 » by JonFromVA » Tue Mar 21, 2023 1:52 am

ocelot17 wrote:Wasn’t Markkanen traded to the Jazz as a throw in just to match salaries? That’s too bad for the Cavs, they could’ve been a contender for the next couple of seasons.


You'd think so from reading RealGM at the time, but he was minimally a starting quality player on a good contract coming off a solid season and a very promising Summer.

If the Jazz only wanted to cash him out, they'd likely have gotten multiple protected firsts.
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#329 » by JonFromVA » Tue Mar 21, 2023 1:59 am

Zetsword wrote:
JonFromVA wrote:
Zetsword wrote:I'm curious what the Cavs will look like having Mitchell/Garland with three guys that can't hit the three in the lineup in the playoffs. It's gonna be interesting.


Been watching it all season...

... troubling thing is Garland and Mitchell both are dealing with finger problems affecting their shooting, but the bench has been stepping up. Well, except for Dean Wade who's shoulder injury is still bothering him. Many of us felt if healthy, he might have taken over Lauri’s old role on the team or at least Love's.

I meant in the playoffs where your weaknesses are targeted consistently.


It's not like teams didn't already realize they could cheat off anyone not named Garland or Mitchell.

The Cavs surprisingly have various ways to overcome it, but it's going to be that much harder if Garland and Mitchell can't knock down 3's.

It helps we don't give up a lot of points.
Wolveswin
General Manager
Posts: 8,139
And1: 2,883
Joined: Aug 22, 2020
 

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#330 » by Wolveswin » Tue Mar 21, 2023 2:37 am

JJ_PR wrote:We traded the right big man, & it isn't even debatable. Mobley could be an MVP candidate one day. Markkanen is a nice player who might get a few all-star selections. But if it came down to Markkanen or Mobley, the Cavs absolutely did the right thing.

Sigh. Do you really think that is what this thread is about? Mobley or Markkanen and ALL things considered equal?

Cavs would have been dumb, like major league dumb, to just have swapped Mobley for Markkanen and said thank you Ainge with their pants at their ankles.

Mobley at time of trade had considerable more value than Markkanen - who as poster said above, was like a “throw in.”

One has to consider with hindsight:

Current version of Markkanen + retaining all Cavs 1sts + maybe Jazz 1st(s)

OR

Just Mobley (trade as it was)
JJ_PR
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,278
And1: 4,012
Joined: Mar 19, 2015
Location: Puerto Rico
   

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#331 » by JJ_PR » Tue Mar 21, 2023 1:55 pm

Wolveswin wrote:Current version of Markkanen + retaining all Cavs 1sts + maybe Jazz 1st(s)


You're just assuming the Jazz were interested in trading Mitchell + picks for Mobley. If that was available, I think the Cavs would've been all over it.

It's pretty simple, the Jazz wanted a rebuilding package for Mitchell. They probably had zero interest in attaching picks next to Donovan to acquire Mobley.

Either way, those picks will all be late firsts. I'm not losing my sleep over those picks any time soon.

We have two decent prospects coming from overseas next season in Luke Travers & Khalifa Diop. It's like we have two draft picks in next years draft basically. We don't need the picks we gave up in the Mitchell trade.
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#332 » by JonFromVA » Tue Mar 21, 2023 2:28 pm

Wolveswin wrote:
JJ_PR wrote:We traded the right big man, & it isn't even debatable. Mobley could be an MVP candidate one day. Markkanen is a nice player who might get a few all-star selections. But if it came down to Markkanen or Mobley, the Cavs absolutely did the right thing.

Sigh. Do you really think that is what this thread is about? Mobley or Markkanen and ALL things considered equal?

Cavs would have been dumb, like major league dumb, to just have swapped Mobley for Markkanen and said thank you Ainge with their pants at their ankles.

Mobley at time of trade had considerable more value than Markkanen - who as poster said above, was like a “throw in.”

One has to consider with hindsight:

Current version of Markkanen + retaining all Cavs 1sts + maybe Jazz 1st(s)

OR

Just Mobley (trade as it was)


With hindsight, Lauri went to a great situation where he could be featured rather than continue to be the 6th option in the Cavs offense.

6th option? Where'd I get that?

Well, technically Lauri averaged fewer shots per game (11.5) than rookie Mobley, Rubio, LeVert, Sexton, and Garland.

Clearly players who initiate the offense in Cleveland were and still are getting the most shots.

Mobley did manage to rise to 3rd option this season (at Allen's and others expense) but even with him taking on a lot of the P&R action in addition to some ISO and post-ups, that's still just 12 field goal attempts per game same as last season.
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#333 » by JonFromVA » Tue Mar 21, 2023 2:53 pm

Maybe this thread should be titled, what's in the water in Utah because Ochai Agbaji just lead the Jazz to a win over the Kings without Markkanen with a 27 pt performance (+18 +/-). Kris Dunn came off the street to add 18 & 10.

The Jazz are now back in the last spot of the play-in and a 1/2 game ahead of the Lakers.
User avatar
FranchisePlayer
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,763
And1: 598
Joined: Oct 25, 2019
 

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#334 » by FranchisePlayer » Thu Mar 23, 2023 7:34 pm

JonFromVA wrote:Maybe this thread should be titled, what's in the water in Utah because Ochai Agbaji just lead the Jazz to a win over the Kings without Markkanen with a 27 pt performance (+18 +/-). Kris Dunn came off the street to add 18 & 10.

The Jazz are now back in the last spot of the play-in and a 1/2 game ahead of the Lakers.


It isn't about Utah, definitely not "everyone can make it there" like you tried to insinuate. Sexton has played exactly like last season after you dumped him.

Kris Dunn was a top prospect when drafted and just like Markkanen, he didn't find his home until now. Good for Ochai to have his 15 minutes but let's be real, he had his chance only when three better scorers were out. In March Markkanen is averaging 30,1 / 8,8 and trending upwards.

But check this out from last night - spectacular finishes and athleticism. Dunks, threes, stepback, alley-oop pass, one-handed alley-oop dunk, multiple drives to the rim...

MrSparkle wrote:I don't see a scenario here or there where Lauri becomes the "7-pick we thought he could be." If you remove his 3P ability, he's worse than Felicio by a mile.

12/2/2022
I like the quote- it makes me chuckle. And it was/is pretty much true.
JonFromVA
RealGM
Posts: 15,153
And1: 5,032
Joined: Dec 08, 2009
     

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#335 » by JonFromVA » Thu Mar 23, 2023 7:54 pm

FranchisePlayer wrote:
JonFromVA wrote:Maybe this thread should be titled, what's in the water in Utah because Ochai Agbaji just lead the Jazz to a win over the Kings without Markkanen with a 27 pt performance (+18 +/-). Kris Dunn came off the street to add 18 & 10.

The Jazz are now back in the last spot of the play-in and a 1/2 game ahead of the Lakers.


It isn't about Utah, definitely not "everyone can make it there" like you tried to insinuate. Sexton has played exactly like last season after you dumped him.

Kris Dunn was a top prospect when drafted and just like Markkanen, he didn't find his home until now. Good for Ochai to have his 15 minutes but let's be real, he had his chance only when three better scorers were out. In March Markkanen is averaging 30,1 / 8,8 and trending upwards.

But check this out from last night - spectacular finishes and athleticism. Dunks, threes, stepback, alley-oop pass, one-handed alley-oop dunk, multiple drives to the rim...



Very impressive game by Lauri ... which just so happened to be in Utah.

Home crowd? 4000ft elevation?

Those home/road splits suggest something's going on.

btw, Collin Sexton was coming off a major injury ... still being something like what he was is an achievement for him; but dude has a 66.2 TS% at home .vs. 57.7 TS% on the road.

When he last played a full season in Cleveland he was 57.5% at home and 57.1% on the road.

The best snarky comments have an element of truth. 8-)
edededtut
Senior
Posts: 525
And1: 699
Joined: Dec 28, 2019

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#336 » by edededtut » Thu Mar 23, 2023 9:24 pm

Ochai has been excellent since he got out of Hardy’s doghouse, early in the season he got DNP-CDs quite often. Rookies tend to have bad games but mostly he has been really impressive and one of the better jazz players. As pointed out earlier he has got some experience from college but he seems to be a solid 3&D guy at least. And not just standing in the corner type but he can put the ball on the floor and create a bit too.

In comparison to okoro, since we are in a cavs what if thread, agbaji has shown more playmaking and off the dribble potential than him. I haven’t watched the cavs this season though so okoro may have improved from last year.

Last night was disappointing for the Jazz but the biggest problem was the zone defense that wasn’t working. Blazers seemed to get an open shot whenever they wanted..

If you accept that sexton is a scorer and not a pass first point, he is pretty good at what he does. Hopefully he can put the injuries behind him and play more regularly. I’m sure he’ll improve his passing game with more experience. He’ll probably never see all the passing lanes that natural point guards do but that just means he’ll be a different type of player.

And Lauri, he has scored 26 ppg at home and 25.7 ppg on road with a bit worse shooting percentages (49.2-37.1-84.6). Not too bad. I’m willing to bet most players shoot better at home.

Edit: both Garland and Mitchell for example have a similar difference between home and away 3P% as Lauri has.
Mr Loggins
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,160
And1: 2,498
Joined: Jul 22, 2009
Location: Minneapolis, MN

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#337 » by Mr Loggins » Tue Mar 28, 2023 5:45 pm

Warriorfan wrote:
Mr Loggins wrote:
Warriorfan wrote:
Depends warriors drafted Looney and Poole end of 1st.
Ezelli started 80gms b4 injury. Damian Jones still in the League.

Dray Green and Jokic HOF level 2nds.

I put Mitchell in the mid 20s. Not an MVP type and think he won't age well as a small SG. He averages 15 missed games.

https://www.cbssports.com/nba/news/nba-top-100-player-rankings-giannis-stephen-curry-kevin-durant-vie-for-no-1-lebron-james-slips/


and the warriors biffed on a bunch of recent top 10 picks, proving the point the draft is a crapshoot, where as Mitchell is a proven star.

I’m glad you have mitchell in the mid 20’s, but your personal opinion aside the consensus os he’s been a top 15 level player this year.

Your point that smaller players age poorly is a good one, which is why the fact the Mitchell is only 26 is salient


Still have time to improve for warrior rookies The recent lottery picks have 4 all stars with multiple chsmpionships and defending the title. I posted support that Mitchell is not as good as you believe.

Point you are missing is Markenen can be considered a top 25 player and more assets were given on top of this.


heh, Mobley is playing with three all stars and looks ok. I stand by my point the warriors recent lotterry picks look more “meh” than anything to get excited about.

Markannan has improved, but a) lets see him do it for more than 75% of one season. His track record would suggest this year is the outlier. b) when Utah starts trying to win games and defence becomes important, some of that shine will come off
User avatar
GrindCityHustle
Veteran
Posts: 2,691
And1: 2,644
Joined: May 05, 2019
 

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#338 » by GrindCityHustle » Wed Mar 29, 2023 12:14 am

So funny how a change of scenery and being in the right system to succeed can really make or break a player.

Lauri is basically this generations pau gasol
Image

nbagenerations.createaforum.com
jazzed77
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,588
And1: 209
Joined: Mar 02, 2006

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#339 » by jazzed77 » Wed Mar 29, 2023 1:34 am

Mr Loggins wrote:
Warriorfan wrote:
Mr Loggins wrote:
and the warriors biffed on a bunch of recent top 10 picks, proving the point the draft is a crapshoot, where as Mitchell is a proven star.

I’m glad you have mitchell in the mid 20’s, but your personal opinion aside the consensus os he’s been a top 15 level player this year.

Your point that smaller players age poorly is a good one, which is why the fact the Mitchell is only 26 is salient


Still have time to improve for warrior rookies The recent lottery picks have 4 all stars with multiple chsmpionships and defending the title. I posted support that Mitchell is not as good as you believe.

Point you are missing is Markenen can be considered a top 25 player and more assets were given on top of this.


heh, Mobley is playing with three all stars and looks ok. I stand by my point the warriors recent lotterry picks look more “meh” than anything to get excited about.

Markannan has improved, but a) lets see him do it for more than 75% of one season. His track record would suggest this year is the outlier. b) when Utah starts trying to win games and defence becomes important, some of that shine will come off


That's an interesting take as Mitchell's hero ball and refusal to play defense were a big part of the jazz playoff failures.
Warriorfan
RealGM
Posts: 15,357
And1: 2,801
Joined: Jun 24, 2001
         

Re: Cavs made a huge mistake and traded the wrong big man 

Post#340 » by Warriorfan » Wed Mar 29, 2023 4:41 pm

jazzed77 wrote:
Mr Loggins wrote:
Warriorfan wrote:
Still have time to improve for warrior rookies The recent lottery picks have 4 all stars with multiple chsmpionships and defending the title. I posted support that Mitchell is not as good as you believe.

Point you are missing is Markenen can be considered a top 25 player and more assets were given on top of this.


heh, Mobley is playing with three all stars and looks ok. I stand by my point the warriors recent lotterry picks look more “meh” than anything to get excited about.

Markannan has improved, but a) lets see him do it for more than 75% of one season. His track record would suggest this year is the outlier. b) when Utah starts trying to win games and defence becomes important, some of that shine will come off


That's an interesting take as Mitchell's hero ball and refusal to play defense were a big part of the jazz playoff failures.



Warriors are evidence of how a team can go from championship game to worst record in a season so picks sent far into the future is a bad gamble especially for a 4th seed team.

What happens with the picks and how much Clev improves will tell but so big overpay.

Would Clev be a 4th 5th seed without Mitchell

Return to The General Board