Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,251
- And1: 999
- Joined: Mar 30, 2023
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Victor is way better as a rookie than lebron as a rookie. Playing nearly 10 min less than with much lower ball usage a less developed body/frame and a coach that's not even putting him in the best position to succeed and is still better than lebron across the board.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
- Gusto1903
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,967
- And1: 2,550
- Joined: Apr 27, 2021
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Wemby is crazy good. People out here we're panicking and claiming chet was better, after Pop tried out stuff with Wemby.
On the Alperen Sengün hypetrain since 2020
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,547
- And1: 227
- Joined: May 10, 2011
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Chokic wrote:Victor is way better as a rookie than lebron as a rookie. Playing nearly 10 min less than with much lower ball usage a less developed body/frame and a coach that's not even putting him in the best position to succeed and is still better than lebron across the board.
Comparing Wemby to LeBron is weird. They aren't even within the same player archetype. LeBron was a wing that came straight out of HS into the league 20 years ago during the dead ball era, which is one of the worst eras of basketball for offense. LeBron also has never had a coach like Pop in his career. Pop knows what he is doing.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,251
- And1: 999
- Joined: Mar 30, 2023
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Iplaytolose wrote:Chokic wrote:Victor is way better as a rookie than lebron as a rookie. Playing nearly 10 min less than with much lower ball usage a less developed body/frame and a coach that's not even putting him in the best position to succeed and is still better than lebron across the board.
Comparing Wemby to LeBron is weird. They aren't even within the same player archetype. LeBron was a wing that came straight out of HS into the league 20 years ago during the dead ball era, which is one of the worst eras of basketball for offense. LeBron also has never had a coach like Pop in his career. Pop knows what he is doing.
Wemby is a transcendent talent like LeBron not that hard to figure out. Also pop isn't exactly doing wemby any favors for his rookie development. He's making it even harder than it should be. Wemby is playing very well IN SPITE of pops not BC Of pops.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 22,395
- And1: 18,828
- Joined: Mar 08, 2012
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Chokic wrote:Iplaytolose wrote:Chokic wrote:Victor is way better as a rookie than lebron as a rookie. Playing nearly 10 min less than with much lower ball usage a less developed body/frame and a coach that's not even putting him in the best position to succeed and is still better than lebron across the board.
Comparing Wemby to LeBron is weird. They aren't even within the same player archetype. LeBron was a wing that came straight out of HS into the league 20 years ago during the dead ball era, which is one of the worst eras of basketball for offense. LeBron also has never had a coach like Pop in his career. Pop knows what he is doing.
Wemby is a transcendent talent like LeBron not that hard to figure out. Also pop isn't exactly doing wemby any favors for his rookie development. He's making it even harder than it should be. Wemby is playing very well IN SPITE of pops not BC Of pops.
Lebron was younger and started in the most defensive oriented era, Wemby is in the most offensive friendly era.
Wemby scores a bit more Per 36 (22 points to 19) but his efficiency is barely better despite playing in a league where the average TS is like 58%.
Wemby is not really doing any better as a scorer and he obviously not a playmaker. He my very well be better than James due to defense, but you should take into account that Lebron James was basically an all-nba player when he was Wemby's age.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,027
- And1: 688
- Joined: Jun 24, 2018
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
HeartBreakKid wrote:Chokic wrote:Iplaytolose wrote:
Comparing Wemby to LeBron is weird. They aren't even within the same player archetype. LeBron was a wing that came straight out of HS into the league 20 years ago during the dead ball era, which is one of the worst eras of basketball for offense. LeBron also has never had a coach like Pop in his career. Pop knows what he is doing.
Wemby is a transcendent talent like LeBron not that hard to figure out. Also pop isn't exactly doing wemby any favors for his rookie development. He's making it even harder than it should be. Wemby is playing very well IN SPITE of pops not BC Of pops.
Lebron was younger and started in the most defensive oriented era, Wemby is in the most offensive friendly era.
Wemby scores a bit more Per 36 (22 points to 19) but his efficiency is barely better despite playing in a league where the average TS is like 58%.
Wemby is not really doing any better as a scorer and he obviously not a playmaker. He my very well be better than James due to defense, but you should take into account that Lebron James was basically an all-nba player when he was Wemby's age.
Come on man that's historically not true at all! Lebron wasn't all nba at 19, he is months younger than wemby rookie season, he was inefficient in first two seasons. He was a "bad" as many rookies, specially compared to Lebron 2007-2008 when he was 22+. Sure he is scored alot in 2005-2006(his 3rd year!) but he was more of a scorer in a bad team compared to the real Lebron.
41.7 FG% 29%3pt % 2P% 43.8
eFG% 43.8 is Lebron rookie numbers and it jumped barely in his second 20 years old season. Even those numbers was eons away from All NBA level. Just because Lebron became great 3-4 years in doesn't means we should lie, erase his typically bad teenage star years.

Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,170
- And1: 13,700
- Joined: Dec 04, 2013
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
clyde21 wrote:The Master wrote:Castle Black wrote:
Wemby is almost a year older than rookie LeBron, LBJ his age averaged 27-7-7.
That being said, Wembanyama is the best blocker in the NBA + one of the best rebounders (actually first or second in defensive rebound percentage) as a 19yo, he's obviously very fine.
LeBron was 19 as a rookie too
LeBron started his career at 18 years old(his age in the first 21 games) vs 19 for Wemby
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,955
- And1: 13,582
- Joined: Dec 22, 2011
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Can't take anyone that compares stats from 2003 to 2023 seriously
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,027
- And1: 688
- Joined: Jun 24, 2018
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Yeah we shouldn't compare eras advanced stats etc but you can make the comparison 18 year old or 19 year rookie needs patience, the licence to be bad,make mistakes and learn. That is the same truth 2003 or 2023.KembaWalker wrote:Can't take anyone that compares stats from 2003 to 2023 seriously
We shouldn't rewrite history because 2003 was slower offence, different. Very few rookies even the best ever didn't led to helping alot to winning seasons.
Skickat från min SM-N970F via Tapatalk
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
- Roger Murdock
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,479
- And1: 5,860
- Joined: Aug 12, 2008
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
KG Leonard wrote:HeartBreakKid wrote:Chokic wrote:
Wemby is a transcendent talent like LeBron not that hard to figure out. Also pop isn't exactly doing wemby any favors for his rookie development. He's making it even harder than it should be. Wemby is playing very well IN SPITE of pops not BC Of pops.
Lebron was younger and started in the most defensive oriented era, Wemby is in the most offensive friendly era.
Wemby scores a bit more Per 36 (22 points to 19) but his efficiency is barely better despite playing in a league where the average TS is like 58%.
Wemby is not really doing any better as a scorer and he obviously not a playmaker. He my very well be better than James due to defense, but you should take into account that Lebron James was basically an all-nba player when he was Wemby's age.
Come on man that's historically not true at all! Lebron wasn't all nba at 19, he is months younger than wemby rookie season, he was inefficient in first two seasons. He was a "bad" as many rookies, specially compared to Lebron 2007-2008 when he was 22+. Sure he is scored alot in 2005-2006(his 3rd year!) but he was more of a scorer in a bad team compared to the real Lebron.
41.7 FG% 29%3pt % 2P% 43.8
eFG% 43.8 is Lebron rookie numbers and it jumped barely in his second 20 years old season. Even those numbers was eons away from All NBA level. Just because Lebron became great 3-4 years in doesn't means we should lie, erase his typically bad teenage star years.
LeBron was second team all NBA his second season and finished 6th in MVP voting
He was first team all NBA his third season and second in MVP voting. He was also a major +TS% added player by his second season despite mostly creating his own offense
Wemby is on pace to have double the negative TS% add LeBron did as a rookie despite taking 80% of his field goals attempts assisted and playing center which historically is a position that’s +6% league average on TS% whereas SF is about average. Point guards, which was functionally LeBrons role, tend to have a TS% 4-5% worse than league average historically
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,239
- And1: 10,779
- Joined: Dec 02, 2010
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Who cares about the comparisons to LeBron?
This dude is having a great rookie season and defensively especially it’s already obvious he’s something special.
He’s really starting to take off now regardless of his team being absolutely junk
This dude is having a great rookie season and defensively especially it’s already obvious he’s something special.
He’s really starting to take off now regardless of his team being absolutely junk
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 22,395
- And1: 18,828
- Joined: Mar 08, 2012
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
KG Leonard wrote:HeartBreakKid wrote:Chokic wrote:
Wemby is a transcendent talent like LeBron not that hard to figure out. Also pop isn't exactly doing wemby any favors for his rookie development. He's making it even harder than it should be. Wemby is playing very well IN SPITE of pops not BC Of pops.
Lebron was younger and started in the most defensive oriented era, Wemby is in the most offensive friendly era.
Wemby scores a bit more Per 36 (22 points to 19) but his efficiency is barely better despite playing in a league where the average TS is like 58%.
Wemby is not really doing any better as a scorer and he obviously not a playmaker. He my very well be better than James due to defense, but you should take into account that Lebron James was basically an all-nba player when he was Wemby's age.
Come on man that's historically not true at all! Lebron wasn't all nba at 19, he is months younger than wemby rookie season, he was inefficient in first two seasons. He was a "bad" as many rookies, specially compared to Lebron 2007-2008 when he was 22+. Sure he is scored alot in 2005-2006(his 3rd year!) but he was more of a scorer in a bad team compared to the real Lebron.
41.7 FG% 29%3pt % 2P% 43.8
eFG% 43.8 is Lebron rookie numbers and it jumped barely in his second 20 years old season. Even those numbers was eons away from All NBA level. Just because Lebron became great 3-4 years in doesn't means we should lie, erase his typically bad teenage star years.
Lebron James was born in December and Wemby is born in January. They were not the same age at all as rookies. A year difference.
When Lebron James was Wemby's age he was in his 2nd season, and was not a scrub in the slightest. He a top 10-15 player in the league. I think you're a bit confused on the timeline.
Yes, James was inefficient as a rookie, though Wemby is nearly as inefficient and plays in a more efficient era.
I think the point people are trying to make is that you're comparing a straight out of HS rookie to a one and done rookie. Not quite the same.
Lebron James was a borderline top 5 player in 2006. You're comparing James to himself, in 2006 he was nowhere near as good as 08-10 but he was still objectively speaking a first team all nba caliber player. If James never got better than his 06 version he would still be a hall of famer very easily.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
- DwayneSchintzus
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,400
- And1: 1,925
- Joined: Jul 01, 2005
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
i think the point of showing his stats next to LeBron's is not "zomg he's better than lebron" but rather "look how lebron performed early on and what he went on to accomplish"
its not wemby's life goal to be a better 19 year old than lebron james
its not wemby's life goal to be a better 19 year old than lebron james
These are the opinions of one lifelong Spurs fan, nothing more
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
- Roger Murdock
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,479
- And1: 5,860
- Joined: Aug 12, 2008
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
I don’t even understand the point of comparing them
LeBron is a point forward who’s biggest strengths are passing, ball handler, playmaking, positional versatility, and attacking the rim
Wemby is a 7’5” player whose biggest strength is defense and covers an absurd amount of ground.
Wemby will never be close to what LeBron was on offense and he should be a considerably better defensive player.
LeBron is a point forward who’s biggest strengths are passing, ball handler, playmaking, positional versatility, and attacking the rim
Wemby is a 7’5” player whose biggest strength is defense and covers an absurd amount of ground.
Wemby will never be close to what LeBron was on offense and he should be a considerably better defensive player.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,233
- And1: 1,003
- Joined: Apr 24, 2017
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
I'm concerned too. A lanky teenager growing into his body, playing without a PG, in his first 20 games, with 19/10 while leading the league in blocks. What will he do 3/4 years from now?!
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,032
- And1: 2,037
- Joined: Nov 24, 2021
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
It doesn't matter, Wemby's still been better. To be fair he's a year older than Lebron was.. but it's quite an accomplishment.Iplaytolose wrote:Chokic wrote:Victor is way better as a rookie than lebron as a rookie. Playing nearly 10 min less than with much lower ball usage a less developed body/frame and a coach that's not even putting him in the best position to succeed and is still better than lebron across the board.
Comparing Wemby to LeBron is weird. They aren't even within the same player archetype.
hauntedcomputer wrote:Jokic is just a stranger dribbling a basketball. The humility bit could well be a carefully crafted business model for all we know. It's actually getting as tiresome as egotistical bloviating at this point. "Look at me, look how humble I am!!"
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,711
- And1: 4,075
- Joined: Apr 28, 2016
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Lebron was better in his rookie season, like no comparison at all, 20.9 PPG on an era where scoring was much more difficult and pace was much lower, 95 TS+, compared to 19.3 PPG on 91 TS+, this is scoring, then in terms of playmaking it's not even a contest, with Wembanyama having more turnovers than assists with less than 3 APG, compared to Lebron's almost 6 APG with fairly low TOV.
Stop overrating the kid now, he has not been that good, future is bright ok but in this season not that good.
Stop overrating the kid now, he has not been that good, future is bright ok but in this season not that good.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
- Bornstellar
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,628
- And1: 23,009
- Joined: Mar 05, 2018
-
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Bum Adebayo wrote:Lebron was better in his rookie season, like no comparison at all, 20.9 PPG on an era where scoring was much more difficult and pace was much lower, 95 TS+, compared to 19.3 PPG on 91 TS+, this is scoring, then in terms of playmaking it's not even a contest, with Wembanyama having more turnovers than assists with less than 3 APG, compared to Lebron's almost 6 APG with fairly low TOV.
Stop overrating the kid now, he has not been that good, future is bright ok but in this season not that good.
Good points but you're also forgetting rookie LeBron was playing like 40mpg whereas Wemby plays around 30. That's a pretty substantial difference in playing time for those numbers
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,187
- And1: 8,559
- Joined: Apr 15, 2020
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
Bum Adebayo wrote:Lebron was better in his rookie season, like no comparison at all, 20.9 PPG on an era where scoring was much more difficult and pace was much lower, 95 TS+, compared to 19.3 PPG on 91 TS+, this is scoring, then in terms of playmaking it's not even a contest, with Wembanyama having more turnovers than assists with less than 3 APG, compared to Lebron's almost 6 APG with fairly low TOV.
Stop overrating the kid now, he has not been that good, future is bright ok but in this season not that good.
Scoring and passing. What about defense and rebounding? Its levels out a lot.
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,711
- And1: 4,075
- Joined: Apr 28, 2016
Re: Wembanyama. I'm concerned
SNPA wrote:Bum Adebayo wrote:Lebron was better in his rookie season, like no comparison at all, 20.9 PPG on an era where scoring was much more difficult and pace was much lower, 95 TS+, compared to 19.3 PPG on 91 TS+, this is scoring, then in terms of playmaking it's not even a contest, with Wembanyama having more turnovers than assists with less than 3 APG, compared to Lebron's almost 6 APG with fairly low TOV.
Stop overrating the kid now, he has not been that good, future is bright ok but in this season not that good.
Scoring and passing. What about defense and rebounding? Its levels out a lot.
First is more important than the second. Offense > defense. Besides, the gap between their offense was bigger than the gap in defense.