Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated (NOW YOU CAN CHANGE VOTES)

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

Has Jokic been overrated?

Yes
118
18%
No
547
82%
 
Total votes: 665

Jabroni Lames
Analyst
Posts: 3,746
And1: 4,284
Joined: Apr 08, 2018

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#561 » by Jabroni Lames » Wed May 15, 2024 2:13 am

Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


Oliver Miller. Lmao. /end thread
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 93,130
And1: 32,570
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#562 » by tsherkin » Wed May 15, 2024 2:18 am

Special_Puppy wrote:Top 10 all time is an insanely hard bar to reach. You basically have to be near Magic Johnson in career value to break into the top 10. LeBron might be the only active player who will end up clearing that bar! Top 20 is a more realistic bar for players we are excited about and is effectively the new top 10 given how old the NBA is now


Top 10 is a very hard bar to reach, for sure. The best of the best, but also with appropriate luck on their side. It takes a ton to get there.

Jokic has one title, but will need more to be accepted into the top 10, even if his production is certainly on the level. He has joined Kareem, Wilt, Lebron, Magic, Jordan, Bird, Moses Malone and Bill Russell in the 3+ MVP category, though.
Infinite Llamas
RealGM
Posts: 10,698
And1: 24,326
Joined: Jul 22, 2006
Location: Land of Llamas
   

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#563 » by Infinite Llamas » Wed May 15, 2024 2:29 am

DimesandKnicks wrote:
Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


The 90s encapsule an entire decade, not just one year. And a lot of the PF’s in the 90s would be playing Center today which would deepen that pool


And for every Dale Davis/Karl Malone/Rodman you had Danny Ferry/Laettner/Juwan Howard at PF slots.

I picked a random year because it encapsulates most of the 90’s guys and by the time you have Duncan and KG emerging, guys like Ewing/Dream/Admiral/Smits are declining. So yea, there were a lot of great 90’s centers but not all were great at the same moment in time.
Gerald Green Loves LLamas!
greekman
Rookie
Posts: 1,171
And1: 562
Joined: Nov 06, 2021

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#564 » by greekman » Wed May 15, 2024 2:37 am

irving is overrated, murray is underrated. only diff between doncic and jokic
DimesandKnicks
Head Coach
Posts: 6,566
And1: 4,103
Joined: Jun 11, 2009

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#565 » by DimesandKnicks » Wed May 15, 2024 2:38 am

Infinite Llamas wrote:
DimesandKnicks wrote:
Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


The 90s encapsule an entire decade, not just one year. And a lot of the PF’s in the 90s would be playing Center today which would deepen that pool


And for every Dale Davis/Karl Malone/Rodman you had Danny Ferry/Laettner/Juwan Howard at PF slots.

I picked a random year because it encapsulates most of the 90’s guys and by the time you have Duncan and KG emerging, guys like Ewing/Dream/Admiral/Smits are declining. So yea, there were a lot of great 90’s centers but not all were great at the same moment in time.


Now pick a year in the 2020’s
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 93,130
And1: 32,570
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#566 » by tsherkin » Wed May 15, 2024 2:41 am

greekman wrote:irving is overrated, murray is underrated. only diff between doncic and jokic


That is very definitely not the case.
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 50,861
And1: 27,427
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#567 » by dhsilv2 » Wed May 15, 2024 2:57 am

CobraCommander wrote:
dhsilv2 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:Then and only then will they give him his due -

But Edward knows what Lebron knows what curry knows what Embiid knows - this is the best guy on earth - and is going to be in the top 15 guaranteed and he is the only one truely trending that way in the nba under 30 -

Giannis on cusp but we need more… sorry


Giannis is a top 10 all time talent...but dude's gotta stay healthy! That said Luka is certainly trending that way, but he's got a lot of years left before 30.

Luka not trending top 10 all time- Luka is tending more like harden - He begging for FOuls and coming in out of shape -

The top 10- top 20 guys win rings and MVPs and make winning happen. -

Jokic is the only one younger than 30 really trending top 10- Luka 25… he has a great team- he has to be better - Luka clearly behind SGA right now and SGA ain’t top 10 or 20 right now


For starters, Luka is younger than harden when he started getting MVP talk by a LOT. He's also not showing issues adapting to the playoffs unlike Harden. in his age 24 year he's already got 38 playoff games and has been his team's best player for everyone of them. They have similarities in style for sure, but they're very different players.
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 50,861
And1: 27,427
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#568 » by dhsilv2 » Wed May 15, 2024 2:58 am

Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


Wanted to do post something very similar. Thanks for this. This 90's center talk sometimes just gets wild. For as many greats as we had, we had so many turds.
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 50,861
And1: 27,427
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#569 » by dhsilv2 » Wed May 15, 2024 3:00 am

DimesandKnicks wrote:
Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


The 90s encapsule an entire decade, not just one year. And a lot of the PF’s in the 90s would be playing Center today which would deepen that pool


Which also means a lot of C/PF's playing back then...like half of them. Wouldn't make the league today...
User avatar
Black Jack
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,742
And1: 7,258
Joined: Jan 24, 2013
Location: In the stands kicking ass
     

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#570 » by Black Jack » Wed May 15, 2024 3:07 am

Jokic is clearly the best in the world, probably until he declines and Wemby hits his prime.
Rest in peace Kobe & Gianna

my response to KD critics: https://tinyurl.com/tlgc6bf
DimesandKnicks
Head Coach
Posts: 6,566
And1: 4,103
Joined: Jun 11, 2009

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#571 » by DimesandKnicks » Wed May 15, 2024 3:08 am

dhsilv2 wrote:
DimesandKnicks wrote:
Infinite Llamas wrote:Starting centers in 1995-96

Atl Andrew Lang
Bos Eric Montross
Cha Matt Geiger/Robert Parish
Chi Luc Longley
Cle Michael Cage
Dal Lorenzo Williams
Den Dikembe Mutombo
Det Otis Thorpe
Gs Rony Seikaly
Hou Hakeem Olajuwon
Ind Rik Smits
Lac Brian Williams
Lal Vlade Divac
Mia Alonzo Mourning
Mil Benoit Benjamin
Min Tom Gugliotta?
NJ Shawn Bradley
NY Patrick Ewing
Orl Shaquille O’Neal
Phi Derrick Alston/Sharone Wright
Pho Hot Rod Williams
Por Chris Dudley
Sac Olden Polynice
SA David Robinson
Sea Ervin Johnson
Tor Oliver Miller
Utah Felton Spencer
Van Bryant Reeves
Was Georghe Muresan

So yeah. A lot of really talented guys at the top and some guys that would be hard pressed to make rosters today. Jokic would have been just fine in the 90’s.


The 90s encapsule an entire decade, not just one year. And a lot of the PF’s in the 90s would be playing Center today which would deepen that pool


Which also means a lot of C/PF's playing back then...like half of them. Wouldn't make the league today...


Very true, the ones at the bottom tier of this list. All in all their are probably 30 bigs that played in the 90s that would be high level C’s in the 2020s
Letsgokings
Senior
Posts: 626
And1: 796
Joined: Aug 07, 2020
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#572 » by Letsgokings » Wed May 15, 2024 3:13 am

He's a big dumb ugly oaf but seems to be good at basketball somehow.
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 50,861
And1: 27,427
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#573 » by dhsilv2 » Wed May 15, 2024 3:18 am

DimesandKnicks wrote:
dhsilv2 wrote:
DimesandKnicks wrote:
The 90s encapsule an entire decade, not just one year. And a lot of the PF’s in the 90s would be playing Center today which would deepen that pool


Which also means a lot of C/PF's playing back then...like half of them. Wouldn't make the league today...


Very true, the ones at the bottom tier of this list. All in all their are probably 30 bigs that played in the 90s that would be high level C’s in the 2020s


Which means about 10 would be high level in any given season. And that...that isn't insane.
CobraCommander
RealGM
Posts: 25,494
And1: 16,599
Joined: May 01, 2014
       

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#574 » by CobraCommander » Wed May 15, 2024 3:24 am

dhsilv2 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:
dhsilv2 wrote:
Giannis is a top 10 all time talent...but dude's gotta stay healthy! That said Luka is certainly trending that way, but he's got a lot of years left before 30.

Luka not trending top 10 all time- Luka is tending more like harden - He begging for FOuls and coming in out of shape -

The top 10- top 20 guys win rings and MVPs and make winning happen. -

Jokic is the only one younger than 30 really trending top 10- Luka 25… he has a great team- he has to be better - Luka clearly behind SGA right now and SGA ain’t top 10 or 20 right now


For starters, Luka is younger than harden when he started getting MVP talk by a LOT. He's also not showing issues adapting to the playoffs unlike Harden. in his age 24 year he's already got 38 playoff games and has been his team's best player for everyone of them. They have similarities in style for sure, but they're very different players.

Different but the same in regards that when they don’t have the ball they are a net negative on offense. Off the ball they don’t contribute. Either way - 5 or 6 years in we need to see conditioning and improvement off the ball. No more talking about he needs help. His team is infinitely better than SGAs and he didn’t come through like harden - he is your but he is definitely not improving like jokic did -

Actually no one has in my memory-

Went from where he was to who jokic is now -
CobraCommander
RealGM
Posts: 25,494
And1: 16,599
Joined: May 01, 2014
       

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#575 » by CobraCommander » Wed May 15, 2024 3:31 am

Letsgokings wrote:He's a big dumb ugly oaf but seems to be good at basketball somehow.

Maybe not so dumb and a lot better than Good -

I cant judge his physical beauty but damn his game is gorgeous
User avatar
Kawaii Leonard
Pro Prospect
Posts: 996
And1: 1,274
Joined: Jun 08, 2012
Location: raps in 6ix
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#576 » by Kawaii Leonard » Wed May 15, 2024 3:43 am

He’s not a system player. He is the system. What are y’all yapping about. Jesus. Even Curry as the most system player of all time deserves all his mvps and flowers. It’s really not a negative if it works.
WarriorGM wrote:Steph is the greatest playmaker of all-time.
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 93,130
And1: 32,570
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#577 » by tsherkin » Wed May 15, 2024 3:48 am

Kawaii Leonard wrote:He’s not a system player. He is the system. What are y’all yapping about. Jesus. Even Curry as the most system player of all time deserves all his mvps and flowers. It’s really not a negative if it works.


Steph isn't a system player either. He enables others to work off of him. He IS the system. And he was a 24 ppg, 8.5 apg player before Kerr ever got there.

"System player" rarely describes focal players. It's usually a daft phrase designed to undercut the value of a given player for no good reason. Every focal player on a well-coached team has the offense built around them to maximize their skillset and impact, that's... literally the point of coaching. But "system player" describes guys who can only operate inside the system. Roleplayers who go someplace after not being that good, and thriving inside of a simpler, and more well-defined role.
WentzerWuver
Veteran
Posts: 2,814
And1: 713
Joined: Jul 25, 2023

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#578 » by WentzerWuver » Wed May 15, 2024 3:51 am

Braun is more like AR on the Lakers but in big games to break a tie series, he delivers while getting his big guy involved like LeBron does for AD!

I never gave up on the Nuggets and bet big in game 3 when most everyone was scared Lol
DimesandKnicks
Head Coach
Posts: 6,566
And1: 4,103
Joined: Jun 11, 2009

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#579 » by DimesandKnicks » Wed May 15, 2024 3:52 am

dhsilv2 wrote:
DimesandKnicks wrote:
dhsilv2 wrote:
Which also means a lot of C/PF's playing back then...like half of them. Wouldn't make the league today...


Very true, the ones at the bottom tier of this list. All in all their are probably 30 bigs that played in the 90s that would be high level C’s in the 2020s


Which means about 10 would be high level in any given season. And that...that isn't insane.


There are at least a dozen on the list above that are high level. You add PF’s that could play C and you’d easily have 20; more then half of which are all-stars/all nba/all nba D at worst and HOF at best
User avatar
Kawaii Leonard
Pro Prospect
Posts: 996
And1: 1,274
Joined: Jun 08, 2012
Location: raps in 6ix
 

Re: Jokic is not the best in the world, and has been heavily overrated 

Post#580 » by Kawaii Leonard » Wed May 15, 2024 3:57 am

tsherkin wrote:
Kawaii Leonard wrote:He’s not a system player. He is the system. What are y’all yapping about. Jesus. Even Curry as the most system player of all time deserves all his mvps and flowers. It’s really not a negative if it works.


Steph isn't a system player either. He enables others to work off of him. He IS the system. And he was a 24 ppg, 8.5 apg player before Kerr ever got there.

"System player" rarely describes focal players. It's usually a daft phrase designed to undercut the value of a given player for no good reason. Every focal player on a well-coached team has the offense built around them to maximize their skillset and impact, that's... literally the point of coaching. But "system player" describes guys who can only operate inside the system. Roleplayers who go someplace after not being that good, and thriving inside of a simpler, and more well-defined role.


His gravitational pull as people call it certainly creates undocumented offence but that is not a system. Even for that to exist, Kerr had to step in to cater to his strengths (goat shooter/offball movement). A system influenced by the 7sol suns and next man open Popovich’s spurs. Curry is most obviously a system player, perhaps the best to benefit what was set for him. The moving Draymond screens cemented it even further.

Obviously Curry isn’t the run of the mill system role player but he is the most outlier when it comes to what he does best. He’s very hard to rank and put labels on because of how unique his impact is but I never once considered him to be a system by his lonesome self. I mean is he even a pg?
WarriorGM wrote:Steph is the greatest playmaker of all-time.

Return to The General Board