levon wrote:For readers of my post, please try to read the following by at least briefly suspending the "well they're millionaires, they should suck it up and do their jobs" thoughts and give it a chance.
A bunch of predominantly black men being restricted to staying in Disney World to play basketball amidst the state of the nation and the world sounds absurd. What's even more absurd is an employer restricting pay of employees if they decide to leave a confined area, or suspending them. And if you want to leave, you'll be subject to all sorts of questioning by your employer. Do employers have the right to do this, is not an illegitimate question to ask.
I know that all jobs are different, and some work agreements call for extreme conditions. But NBA players didn't sign up for this in their contracts. This is a revision that they either have to agree to or lose money, so the fact that there's significant concern here isn't surprising.
If it was up to me, I'd love basketball to be back and I'd want everyone to be safe on their own accord, not by mandate from the league, but we know that's too idealistic. There's just a lot of subtleties involved here, and more of them keep popping up the more you think about it.
In this case, yes the employer would have the right to do that, because it's a collectively bargained thing. Under normal labor laws probably not. But nothing normal and rules are being altered everywhere. Like for example, we as Americans have the right to work in and eat at a Damn restaurant if we choose to. We know the risk factor, and it should be our right to decide whether or not we want to take the chance. Just like all the protesters and rioters did when they threw social distancing and safety out the window. We have been stripped of those basic rights by our governor's.
But as for players choosing not to participate, more power to them. It should be their choice on whether or not to take that risk, and if they don't want to nobody should hold that against them (though I'm sure some will because haters gonna hate). But, they shouldn't have a Larry O'Brien trophy this year. Things are too out of whack. Just call it the Covid cup or something. This year's championship is going to have asterisks all over it