Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF?

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF?

Yes
24
17%
No, he's in the 11-15 range
34
24%
No, he's in the 16-20 range
41
29%
No, he's in the 21-25 range
21
15%
No, he's in the 26-30 range
6
4%
No, worse than 30
15
11%
 
Total votes: 141

righterwriter
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,835
And1: 5,612
Joined: Apr 30, 2013
     

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#61 » by righterwriter » Thu Oct 28, 2021 5:41 pm

levon wrote:in no order:

KD
Lebron
Middleton
Jimmy
Tatum
Brown
Ingram
Paul George
Kawhi
Bridges
technically Luka because he guards SF

not to mention when you consider how other comparable guys would look playing in GS system with Curry. I mean how good would a guy like OG look on the Warriors

it's safe to say no


Take off Bridges (five games in a run/gun offense doesn't establish him in any way) and Luka (he's a guard).

There's an argument to be made that Kawhi is less valuable because he's never healthy and maybe won't even play this year. Its the same argument as saying Klay Thompson wasn't a top-3 SG last year because he never actually suited up.

So yeah, Wiggins comes in at #9, behind Ingram.

BTW, he gets paid considerably less than all of the guys on the list ahead of him except Ingram who makes $29M/yr and Brown who the Celtics got at a steal of $25M/yr.
Soulyss
General Manager
Posts: 8,262
And1: 3,625
Joined: Feb 21, 2008
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#62 » by Soulyss » Thu Oct 28, 2021 6:20 pm

He's a decent starting SF, but when you get drafted #1 that's a pretty underwhelming result.
User avatar
FNQ
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 62,963
And1: 20,008
Joined: Jul 16, 2006
Location: EOL 6/23
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#63 » by FNQ » Thu Oct 28, 2021 6:39 pm

Zeitgeister wrote:
FNQ wrote:
Takingbaconback wrote:lol Wiggins is not a better player than DLO


*in fantasy

IRL Wiggins is way better. He can play defense and doesn’t need the ball to be effective. DLo just a volume shooter with no defense.. Wolves doing better in spite of him, not because.


Who are we talking about here? That's the complete opposite of the Wiggins I remember.


You guys had him handling a lot, and being a top scoring option.. he is brutal at both of those things

Defensively he's been great here, but our system is a part of it. That said, was told he was lazy, not a NBA rotation player, etc etc... that wasnt true. He was just greatly miscast
Adopt_Me_Masai
Sophomore
Posts: 207
And1: 306
Joined: Jul 11, 2019
         

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#64 » by Adopt_Me_Masai » Thu Oct 28, 2021 6:40 pm

My biggest takeaway is that so many people on this forum do not know what a small forward is. Lebron and Durant haven't been small forwards in a long time. Neither is Harrison Barnes.
User avatar
FNQ
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 62,963
And1: 20,008
Joined: Jul 16, 2006
Location: EOL 6/23
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#65 » by FNQ » Thu Oct 28, 2021 6:44 pm

DonaldSanders wrote:
Zeitgeister wrote:
FNQ wrote:
*in fantasy

IRL Wiggins is way better. He can play defense and doesn’t need the ball to be effective. DLo just a volume shooter with no defense.. Wolves doing better in spite of him, not because.


Who are we talking about here? That's the complete opposite of the Wiggins I remember.


Wiggins on the Warriors > Wiggins on the Twolves; but not by a ton, people really overrate him at this point. His defensive win shares were a career high last year but a lot of people look better playing with Steph & Dray. He has value here because he fulfills a role we don't have otherwise.

Also, my condolences about DLO.


Neither Steph nor Dray has anything to do with his defensive impact.. Wiggins is a good defender, period. Iso he's great, closing out he's great, rotations are average to above average (theyve been great this year, FWIW). Steph helps mask his below average offensive game, but thats about it.

Playing with better defenders helps public defensive metrics, but those are mostly obsolete at this point - at least for any deep dive on a player's defensive efficacy. They're only really relevant comparing other members of the team, not across teams
User avatar
Zeitgeister
General Manager
Posts: 8,785
And1: 7,584
Joined: Nov 11, 2008
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#66 » by Zeitgeister » Thu Oct 28, 2021 7:02 pm

FNQ wrote:
Zeitgeister wrote:
FNQ wrote:
*in fantasy

IRL Wiggins is way better. He can play defense and doesn’t need the ball to be effective. DLo just a volume shooter with no defense.. Wolves doing better in spite of him, not because.


Who are we talking about here? That's the complete opposite of the Wiggins I remember.


You guys had him handling a lot, and being a top scoring option.. he is brutal at both of those things

Defensively he's been great here, but our system is a part of it. That said, was told he was lazy, not a NBA rotation player, etc etc... that wasnt true. He was just greatly miscast


We didn't always want him as a top scoring option, he just didn't know how to do anything else but shoot the ball when it met his hands, often to mediocre effect. Also, the concerns about laziness go back to high school, scouts were worried about it, and for legitimate reasons, because he's often played lazy. We're talking about a guy who is 6'8, great physical tools, that has had several years grabbing less than 3 defensive rebounds a game. There were many games where the TImberwolves were losing (shocker) and Wiggins would just disappear for quarters, you hardly knew he was playing. Glen Taylor made Wiggins give him a handshake and promise that he'd try hard to continue to improve, that's not something that typically happens unless there are concerns of laziness.

As for not being an NBA rotation player, I've never heard anyone say that, that's a bit ridiculous. I've often thought he was better suited to a bench role but if he can be more of a roleplayer in the starting lineup that is good too.
Lenin wrote: All over the world, wherever there are capitalists, freedom of the press means freedom to buy up newspapers, to buy writers, to bribe, buy and fake "public opinion" for the benefit of the bourgeoisie.
DonaldSanders
Head Coach
Posts: 7,237
And1: 9,322
Joined: Jan 22, 2012
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#67 » by DonaldSanders » Thu Oct 28, 2021 7:14 pm

FNQ wrote:
DonaldSanders wrote:
Zeitgeister wrote:
Who are we talking about here? That's the complete opposite of the Wiggins I remember.


Wiggins on the Warriors > Wiggins on the Twolves; but not by a ton, people really overrate him at this point. His defensive win shares were a career high last year but a lot of people look better playing with Steph & Dray. He has value here because he fulfills a role we don't have otherwise.

Also, my condolences about DLO.


Neither Steph nor Dray has anything to do with his defensive impact.. Wiggins is a good defender, period. Iso he's great, closing out he's great, rotations are average to above average (theyve been great this year, FWIW). Steph helps mask his below average offensive game, but thats about it.

Playing with better defenders helps public defensive metrics, but those are mostly obsolete at this point - at least for any deep dive on a player's defensive efficacy. They're only really relevant comparing other members of the team, not across teams


What you are missing in this analysis is effort. He is putting more effort on the Warriors because he's involved in a winning culture.
User avatar
FNQ
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 62,963
And1: 20,008
Joined: Jul 16, 2006
Location: EOL 6/23
   

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#68 » by FNQ » Thu Oct 28, 2021 7:17 pm

Zeitgeister wrote:
FNQ wrote:
Zeitgeister wrote:
Who are we talking about here? That's the complete opposite of the Wiggins I remember.


You guys had him handling a lot, and being a top scoring option.. he is brutal at both of those things

Defensively he's been great here, but our system is a part of it. That said, was told he was lazy, not a NBA rotation player, etc etc... that wasnt true. He was just greatly miscast


We didn't always want him as a top scoring option, he just didn't know how to do anything else but shoot the ball when it met his hands, often to mediocre effect. Also, the concerns about laziness go back to high school, scouts were worried about it, and for legitimate reasons, because he's often played lazy. We're talking about a guy who is 6'8, great physical tools, that has had several years grabbing less than 3 defensive rebounds a game. There were many games where the TImberwolves were losing (shocker) and Wiggins would just disappear for quarters, you hardly knew he was playing. Glen Taylor made Wiggins give him a handshake and promise that he'd try hard to continue to improve, that's not something that typically happens unless there are concerns of laziness.

As for not being an NBA rotation player, I've never heard anyone say that, that's a bit ridiculous. I've often thought he was better suited to a bench role but if he can be more of a roleplayer in the starting lineup that is good too.


I can imagine. I remember seeing him there and thinking he was godawful, but it was just explained to me that he handled too much and couldnt play defense. But the defense thing, I think that's a systemic problem in MIN, because he's fit right in here in a role that's pretty tough (same one weve given to Barnes, Iguodala, Durant, and even gave to Oubre until he proved he couldnt handle it - it requires BBIQ). Offensively though I dont see any potential to develop. His shot form is consistent, but he shoots flat and generally inaccurate. He picks the worst times to ISO. And while he's pretty good at driving, that seems to be a last resort for him more than first option.

Basically, I think we're seeing his peak and its pretty average. But the defense is definitely legit and havent seen much of, if any, of the laziness. Dray might help with that, or it just might be that his body language sucks. He covered the most ground of any Ws player last year per minute (save GP2) and always took the toughest assignment. Considering the trade cost, I'd be estatic if we just swapped him for DLo straight up
User avatar
WESCO
Head Coach
Posts: 6,396
And1: 996
Joined: Jan 06, 2006
Location: Face Palm

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#69 » by WESCO » Thu Oct 28, 2021 7:17 pm

I voted 16-20.

There's a lot better and there's a lot worst.

For warriors he's been a great fit and I think he's found his role for the rest of his career. 2b or 3a offensive weapon. On defense he can gaurd the main point of attack on the wing

Definitely has lapses on offense however on defense he doesn't take plays off (since becoming a warrior)
Wolveswin
General Manager
Posts: 8,106
And1: 2,869
Joined: Aug 22, 2020
 

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#70 » by Wolveswin » Thu Oct 28, 2021 7:53 pm

Adopt_Me_Masai wrote:My biggest takeaway is that so many people on this forum do not know what a small forward is. Lebron and Durant haven't been small forwards in a long time. Neither is Harrison Barnes.

Funny thing is, use of SG or PG or SF or PF is out dated and shouldn’t be used. They are silly terms used for the layman fan.
Adopt_Me_Masai
Sophomore
Posts: 207
And1: 306
Joined: Jul 11, 2019
         

Re: Is Andrew Wiggins currently a top 10 SF? 

Post#71 » by Adopt_Me_Masai » Fri Oct 29, 2021 2:18 am

Wolveswin wrote:
Adopt_Me_Masai wrote:My biggest takeaway is that so many people on this forum do not know what a small forward is. Lebron and Durant haven't been small forwards in a long time. Neither is Harrison Barnes.

Funny thing is, use of SG or PG or SF or PF is out dated and shouldn’t be used. They are silly terms used for the layman fan.


True, it's pretty much guard/wing/big now instead of PG, SG, SF, PF and C.

Return to The General Board