druggas wrote:Wolveswin wrote:runtmc wrote:
I mean, at the end of the day, you can only play against the people/teams that you play against. Wilt doesnt have control over that. Its like saying a team should have an asterisk on their ring if the other team had injuries during their run or something. You can only play the players/teams put in front of you.
Beyond that, people like to make a big deal about the small size of the league/talent pool, but realize that goes both ways. Yes, there werent as many teams. And yes, some of the guys on the bottom rungs wouldnt play in today's NBA. On the other hand, because of the small size of the league, you ended up playing the elite guys *way* more often too. Wilt played Russell 12 times in the regular season in 61-62 for example -- thats 1 in every 6.5 games basically.
An abbreviated list of some of the big men Wilt played vs: Russell, Walt Bellamy, Bob Pettit, Red Kerr, Dolph Schayes, Jerry Lucas, Nate Thurmond, Wes Unseld, Connie Hawkins, Kareem, Dave Cowens, Willis Reed, Spencer Haywood, Elvin Hayes, and more. And those are just the HOFers.
Like say you graded every player 1-10. Wilt might play some of his games against guys that are 5's, whereas a modern player plays all of his games against a 7-8 or better. But Wilt also played more games against guys that were 10s than a modern player has to. And just as an example, the modern height of today's NBA is about the same as it was when Wilt played -- it was about 6'6 when he played, it's 6'7 today. Average height of a center was 6'10 when he played, today it's 6'11. He wasnt playing against 6'4 centers or something, and its not remotely comparable to Babe Ruth, who was playing in a genuinely different game against guys that werent modern athletes. Nobody threw 90 in Ruths day, let alone 100.
Also, people like to say Wilt's numbers were padded because of era, or pace of play, or lack of competition, and wouldnt have translated. His rebounding is the thing most often cited for this, because he simply owns all the records for rebounding. Whereas other than 62/63, his scoring isnt quite *so* out-of-reach or insane seeming. We've had ~35ppg scoring seasons from guys like Jordan, Kobe, etc. We've never really seen anyone else come close to touching Wilt's rebounding, other than Russell.
But take Kareem for example, generally considered one of the GOAT candidates, played against Magic/Bird, Jordan, etc -- well into the "modern" NBA. Kareem never once had a season with a higher rebounding average than Wilt. Wilt, at 36, was still out-rebounding an in his prime 25 year old Kareem. And Wilt finished 4th in MVP voting that year while playing 43mpg at 36 years old -- while they were in the league together at the same time. By the time Kareem was 36, he was playing 32mpg and averaging 7rpg. Wilt averaged 43mpg and 18rpg at 36.
If Kareem played against the modern NBA and is considered a GOAT candidate, and a washed up 36 year old Wilt was still outrebounding him, still playing more minutes -- can you really say Wilt's rebounding stats were padded, or just a result of lack of competition, or pace of play?
I think people get way too caught up in trying to discredit Wilt's competition, personally. Its not like he played in the 40s or 50s when the game was unrecognizable, by the 60s/70s, it was more or less the modern game, along with modern-level athletes. Not quite the same depth, but the elite guys were every bit as good as the elite guys today.
Also, while people love to take away or discredit Wilt for things he had no control over, they dont give him nearly enough credit for putting up with stuff he had to put up with that no modern player would ever dream of having to go through. Playing as many minutes as he did, playing every game and basically never being injured at his size, or the type of hurdles he had to overcome.
When Wilt played, he was playing in Converse, and there was no such thing as personal chefs, or private planes, personal trainers.. even weight training wasnt really a thing. They rode on buses to their games. Wilt famously loved to eat and drink all sorts of crazy stuff -- tons of beer and fried chicken. Yet somehow, despite being 7'1, was basically only injured once in his career but otherwise played basically every game and had otherworldly stamina. His minutes played records will *never* be broken.
Beyond that though, remember that Wilt literally wasnt allowed to eat at some restaurants or stay at some hotels when he came into the league. Segregation was still legal. Can you imagine the pressure on Wilt, being the most famous black athlete in the world? While constantly being compared to the "perfect" black player/teammate in Russell? What that had to do to him mentally? No matter how much he tried, or what he did, it was always something he was doing wasnt good enough. Even though he won 2 rings and 4 MVPs, its yeah, but he didnt win more, so he's a "loser". Probably no player in history is as unfairly viewed as Wilt.
Thank you for the level headed response.
I think the top end of Wilts era was amazing. Just as much wow and pure athleticism as today. Including Wilt.
But Wilt’s numbers are highly inflated due to lack of competition.
Another gem. I thought you did some research.
When will you respond to my research. How do you explain NBA today having over 125 foreign players - and Wilt having a handful? I mean, even someone trying to be ignorant could try and respond to facts.












