BodieB wrote:mccluskey wrote:Slim Charlez wrote:
TD almost won almost as many titles as MJ and was the polar opposite. Was he not competitive? Seems to me like people want to make that as an excuse yet it doesn't hold up since by a lot of accounts he was a dick after his playing days as well. Does he not tip in restaurants because he's so competitive?
Seems like the majority of people who laud MJ's personality are for the most part people that never met him ( and Ahmad Rashad).
Duncan was an alltime great player for sure, and I agree with you that no question Jordan was a massive dick to his teammates because of what he saw as his way of motivating and pushing them to be better. Could he have done it a different, kinder, gentler way and still be considered the GOAT? Maybe - maybe not. It's not my leadership style for sure, nor is it the style that I (and probably most other people) would prefer to have in a team leader. But like the man said, that's who he was and that's the method that got him and his teammates to the top of the mountain. And the guys that played with him don't seem to mind ending up with all those rings.
and if I had to stake my life on a player to win a basketball game, I'm taking Jordan over anyone else, exactly because of that insanely competitive-to-the-point-of-sociopathy personality. We can dislike the way he did things, but at the end of the day I want him on my team ahead of anyone else in the history of the league.
(also I always heard MJ is a good tipper and treated waiters, bellboys, etc pretty well - Scottie was supposedly the guy that never tipped anybody (No-Tippin' Pippen, etc). But I don't have any first hand knowledge of that so could be wrong.)
The notion that they won because he was an ass is flawed though. Other teams have gotten to that same mountain top without having leadership that bullied their team.
Jordan was the leader of the team and the catalyst to their championships, so I would say that the notion his leadership style didn't help get them to that point is more flawed. They didn't win simply because he was an ass - his teammates got tougher, practiced harder and pushed themselves further because he forced them to do it, and they've been saying that on this documentary.
you can disagree with the man's methods all you want - I'm not a huge fan myself - but if those methods didn't work, the Bulls wouldn't have six banners in the United Center.


















