why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
- Vampirate
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,649
- And1: 4,483
- Joined: Dec 04, 2016
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
Rudy imo has maximized his potential probably, Simmons hasn't even really touched his (and refuses to try and push his game).

Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
- Nate505
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,757
- And1: 13,574
- Joined: Oct 29, 2001
- Location: Denver, CO
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,249
- And1: 3,906
- Joined: Jan 18, 2013
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
Spoiler:
Ingles is cooked.
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
- HayKee
- Senior
- Posts: 744
- And1: 1,028
- Joined: Jan 17, 2018
- Location: Toronto
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
SharpyShuffle wrote:HayKee wrote:SharpyShuffle wrote:
Aka the the most impactful thing you can do defensively.
So your also think that Seth Curry is better offensively than LeBron?
I honestly don't know why people bother to post this kind of low - effort illogical guff. 'He's better at the most important thing, therefore he's better overall' is like what you'd expect from a fifth-grader
The original post was about defensive impact. You can straw man all you want and ignore the underlying point. A center that can contest every single drive to/shot around the basket (the most efficient shot in basketball) is more impactful defensively than a switchy wing. That "guff" is backed up by defensive impact metrics, but go ahead and call it low effort.
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
-
- Junior
- Posts: 422
- And1: 581
- Joined: Jun 14, 2021
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
You and I both know that the questions around Gobert's impact in the playoffs when teams can gameplan for him and potentially play five out can't be answered by blithely citing stats.HayKee wrote:SharpyShuffle wrote:HayKee wrote:Aka the the most impactful thing you can do defensively.
So your also think that Seth Curry is better offensively than LeBron?
I honestly don't know why people bother to post this kind of low - effort illogical guff. 'He's better at the most important thing, therefore he's better overall' is like what you'd expect from a fifth-grader
The original post was about defensive impact. You can straw man all you want and ignore the underlying point. A center that can contest every single drive to/shot around the basket (the most efficient shot in basketball) is more impactful defensively than a switchy wing. That "guff" is backed up by defensive impact metrics, but go ahead and call it low effort.
I'm really unsure of what posters like you are even trying to accomplish. Who is your audience when you just lazily say things like 'stats say I'm right' or that ridiculous 'rim protection is the most important thing therefore its the only thing' attempt at a mic-drop? You're not going to convince anyone who's at all educated about the sport or paying attention to the league. And you're certainly not going to win an argument.
Gobert vs Simmons is a legit debate, and actually quite an interesting one: guy who is great at the most important aspect of D, but less flexible and gameplannable vs guy who is great at everything else. Its not a debate you win with these kind of posts.
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,030
- And1: 256
- Joined: Mar 23, 2006
- Location: Lets just say with my wife.
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
-
- Junior
- Posts: 250
- And1: 327
- Joined: Jul 02, 2017
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
- HayKee
- Senior
- Posts: 744
- And1: 1,028
- Joined: Jan 17, 2018
- Location: Toronto
-
Re: why doesnt rudy get the same level of flack as ben simmons offensively?
SharpyShuffle wrote:You and I both know that the questions around Gobert's impact in the playoffs when teams can gameplan for him and potentially play five out can't be answered by blithely citing stats.HayKee wrote:SharpyShuffle wrote:So your also think that Seth Curry is better offensively than LeBron?
I honestly don't know why people bother to post this kind of low - effort illogical guff. 'He's better at the most important thing, therefore he's better overall' is like what you'd expect from a fifth-grader
The original post was about defensive impact. You can straw man all you want and ignore the underlying point. A center that can contest every single drive to/shot around the basket (the most efficient shot in basketball) is more impactful defensively than a switchy wing. That "guff" is backed up by defensive impact metrics, but go ahead and call it low effort.
I'm really unsure of what posters like you are even trying to accomplish. Who is your audience when you just lazily say things like 'stats say I'm right' or that ridiculous 'rim protection is the most important thing therefore its the only thing' attempt at a mic-drop? You're not going to convince anyone who's at all educated about the sport or paying attention to the league. And you're certainly not going to win an argument.
Gobert vs Simmons is a legit debate, and actually quite an interesting one: guy who is great at the most important aspect of D, but less flexible and gameplannable vs guy who is great at everything else. Its not a debate you win with these kind of posts.
I know right? How dare I cite stats in an argument. Once again you're using a straw man because at no point did I say "rim protection is the most important thing therefore its the only thing".
I don't understand why you're soapboxing so much about problems you see on this board when your account is 5 months old. No one cares.