JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
- Celts17Pride
- RealGM
- Posts: 68,458
- And1: 70,235
- Joined: Nov 27, 2005
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
reddyplayerone
- Pro Prospect
- Posts: 899
- And1: 902
- Joined: Jan 06, 2024
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Smart Lakers fans have been trying to tell everyone since 2020.
The coaching isn't the problem.
The coaching isn't the problem.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Sixers in 4
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,320
- And1: 2,718
- Joined: Apr 22, 2022
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
I don't really care about the overall record. I care about process and the process was a joke. We all know JJ was probably the least qualified HC hire of the last 20 years
He'll get all the credit and all the blame but whose really doing the work?
He'll get all the credit and all the blame but whose really doing the work?
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
perempe20
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,976
- And1: 995
- Joined: Aug 20, 2015
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
I can't believe they lost to the Pistons. LeBron was blocked by a nobody.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
bstein14
- RealGM
- Posts: 32,855
- And1: 9,688
- Joined: Jun 22, 2001
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
perempe20 wrote:I can't believe they lost to the Pistons. LeBron was blocked by a nobody.
LeBron, JJ and the Lakers all went to the locker room immediately after the loss didn't say one word to and Piston player or coach on the way out. Luke Walton (Pistons assistant) started to walk that direction but they all quickly bolted to get out of there.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
ShootersShoot
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,751
- And1: 1,897
- Joined: Aug 30, 2021
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Another OP making threads based on a very tiny sample size..when will people learn
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Lo Wang
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,155
- And1: 620
- Joined: Jan 07, 2024
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
ShootersShoot wrote:Another OP making threads based on a very tiny sample size..when will people learn
I think we're all guilty of being excited about our team. If we play the smart route and wait and see, what are we going to talk about the rest of 2024?
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Jazz9
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,213
- And1: 7,468
- Joined: Mar 29, 2009
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
They started out well but they're still the same team
Only team in the top 10 of the conference with a negative point differential
They're just not that good
Only team in the top 10 of the conference with a negative point differential
They're just not that good
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Lo Wang
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,155
- And1: 620
- Joined: Jan 07, 2024
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
uncleduck13 wrote:Definitely the honeymoon period is over. Back to realityPeople so desperately want JJ to succeed. He’s the likable, charismatic ‘cool’ guy, who comes off ‘intelligent’ to many. The Joe Rogan of the NBA community. And because of this, he won’t be criticized or scapegoated like Ham / Vogel. But the fact is he’s no better than either of them. One is a champion and the other led a team to the WCF their first year.
Only thing I give him credit for is utilizing AD as the true first option. Something that should’ve BEEN done since the acquisition.
Ya JJ treating his players like children because he's "mad" they lost won't bold well with a bunch of egotistical stars. The genius of Phil is his ability to massage and work around the egos of his star.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
ShootersShoot
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,751
- And1: 1,897
- Joined: Aug 30, 2021
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Lo Wang wrote:ShootersShoot wrote:Another OP making threads based on a very tiny sample size..when will people learn
I think we're all guilty of being excited about our team. If we play the smart route and wait and see, what are we going to talk about the rest of the 2024?
My rule of thumb is about a quarter of a season before claiming a coach should be coy, or x player should be mvp or something like that. Still a small sample size at that point but at least then we have an idea on how consistent a player, coach, or team has been. Also at that point, one extremely good or bad performance is not going to skew the stats as much. Nothing wrong with being excited for a team but its obvious one or two games is not enough to make a claim on a season long award. One or two games could be an outlier. 5-7 games could be a hot or cold streak. Its statistics 101 to take into consideration sample size when coming to a determination.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
- boomershadow
- Forum Mod - Pacers

- Posts: 6,003
- And1: 7,504
- Joined: Jul 14, 2014
- Location: Naptown
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
ShootersShoot wrote:My rule of thumb is about a quarter of a season before claiming a coach should be coy, or x player should be mvp or something like that. Still a small sample size at that point but at least then we have an idea on how consistent a player, coach, or team has been. Also at that point, one extremely good or bad performance is not going to skew the stats as much. Nothing wrong with being excited for a team but its obvious one or two games is not enough to make a claim on a season long award. One or two games could be an outlier. 5-7 games could be a hot or cold streak. Its statistics 101 to take into consideration sample size when coming to a determination.
It is First Take 101 to overreact strongly to every small thing that happens.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
- 10DayContract
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,040
- And1: 2,981
- Joined: Apr 23, 2007
- Location: Los Angeles, CA
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Look at how long I've been a part of this board, Kobe and the Lakers did that. The Lakers are my FIRST Love as a sports team. Born and raised in SoCal. I can't support all this BS the last 10 years though. We're cycling through coaches like the Knicks or the Raiders. We're a laughing stock. JJ Reddick isn't going to solve anything. We're starting a 40 year old and DLo. That's not a serious team. Coaching has never been the issue.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
tamaraw08
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,711
- And1: 2,119
- Joined: Feb 13, 2019
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
ShootersShoot wrote:Lo Wang wrote:ShootersShoot wrote:Another OP making threads based on a very tiny sample size..when will people learn
I think we're all guilty of being excited about our team. If we play the smart route and wait and see, what are we going to talk about the rest of the 2024?
My rule of thumb is about a quarter of a season before claiming a coach should be coy, or x player should be mvp or something like that. Still a small sample size at that point but at least then we have an idea on how consistent a player, coach, or team has been. Also at that point, one extremely good or bad performance is not going to skew the stats as much. Nothing wrong with being excited for a team but its obvious one or two games is not enough to make a claim on a season long award. One or two games could be an outlier. 5-7 games could be a hot or cold streak. Its statistics 101 to take into consideration sample size when coming to a determination.
It's hard to think positive when they got clobbered by a bad team with your top 5 players are playing.
Can you call it a streak if players have not played good at all for most of last season with a different coach, then a new coach showing a lot of promise has like 3 months to analyze and draw plans on how to maximize these players strengths and mask their weaknesses?
Freaking Gabe Vincent, Max Christie, Cam Reddish had had like 4 months to work on their game with trainers, sit with the coaching staff to find the best scoring spots for them to practice etc and they have shown nothing after training camp and 7 games?
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Revived
- RealGM
- Posts: 37,456
- And1: 22,236
- Joined: Feb 17, 2011
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
He may be in the running but I still think it will be Atkinson’s award if Cavs keep this up.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
FarBeyondDriven
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,357
- And1: 2,595
- Joined: Aug 11, 2021
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
uncleduck13 wrote:Definitely the honeymoon period is over. Back to realityPeople so desperately want JJ to succeed. He’s the likable, charismatic ‘cool’ guy, who comes off ‘intelligent’ to many. The Joe Rogan of the NBA community. And because of this, he won’t be criticized or scapegoated like Ham / Vogel. But the fact is he’s no better than either of them. One is a champion and the other led a team to the WCF their first year.
Only thing I give him credit for is utilizing AD as the true first option. Something that should’ve BEEN done since the acquisition.
nothing likable, charismatic or cool about JJ.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Scoots1994
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,277
- And1: 1,125
- Joined: Jun 24, 2018
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
reddyplayerone wrote:Smart Lakers fans have been trying to tell everyone since 2020.
The coaching isn't the problem.
The coaching isn't the ONLY problem.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Ruma85
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,484
- And1: 1,936
- Joined: Sep 09, 2021
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Scoots1994 wrote:reddyplayerone wrote:Smart Lakers fans have been trying to tell everyone since 2020.
The coaching isn't the problem.
The coaching isn't the ONLY problem.
Correct but expecting us to win with Hayes as the only big, is a recipe for disaster.
Life is beautiful...
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Tottery
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,840
- And1: 1,758
- Joined: Jul 29, 2019
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
JJ isn't the problem. The roster is terrible tbh. They went all in for Westbrook and will be hurting from that for a long time.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
Scoots1994
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,277
- And1: 1,125
- Joined: Jun 24, 2018
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
Tottery wrote:JJ isn't the problem. The roster is terrible tbh. They went all in for Westbrook and will be hurting from that for a long time.
If only someone could have known that at the time.
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
-
JustBuzzin
- RealGM
- Posts: 16,160
- And1: 13,686
- Joined: Jun 10, 2023
-
Re: JJ Redick will be in the running for COY
This thread got GOAT potential.
Please leave it up all season lol
Please leave it up all season lol


