NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2)

Moderators: cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid

Who is your current NBA MVP? (listed alphabetically)

Giannis Antetokounmpo
51
13%
Luka Doncic
70
18%
Kevin Durant
19
5%
Joel Embiid
25
6%
Nikola Jokic
167
42%
Donovan Mitchell
2
1%
Ja Morant
2
1%
Jayson Tatum
48
12%
Zion Williamson
5
1%
Other (Booker, Curry, Davis, SGA, etc.)
8
2%
 
Total votes: 397

Bob8
RealGM
Posts: 11,066
And1: 4,645
Joined: Feb 08, 2017

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#801 » by Bob8 » Thu Jan 5, 2023 4:20 pm

CobraCommander wrote:
Bob8 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:Y’all want Luka to be on another level so bad that y’all can’t even see he is just like 6 other guys - no better and no worse (except defensively lol)


I recognize Luka is a great but I also don’t think his 60 pt game was any better than Embiids or Giannis games and it was not as good at Mitchell’s-

Tatum is a much better defender and his team was winning more and he plays for the BOSTON Celtics - that gives him the same boost a laker gets that a Mav or a buck or a nugget doesn’t get -

No one objectively sees Luka as MJ… he is one of many… not the best and not the worse… stop seeing one guy and acknowledge the other great players


Let's compare him to Tatum, your second best player. Stats, you were using to prove your point in the past, show he's better in everything, advanced stats a lot better.

https://stathead.com/tiny/o8hgZ

Jokic is the only player with comparable season to Luka. Anything can change of course. I doubt very much that Luka can play the whole RS with that usage doing what he's doing now. He's the whole system, it's become normal for him to play the whole second half and has to work hard in D too. Mavs are playing RS like it's playoffs already, all games close. His body won't last that kind of stress.

Bob- I’m not saying Tatum is the second best player -

I said he is (or was) second in MVP voting because he is a great two way, on best team in league, previously in finals, had great stats and IS PLAYING in BOSTON. I’m not saying Tatum is second best in world. I think objectively, Giannis is second to Jokic and after that there are a bunch of guys that include Luka that can be considered right below Jokic and Giannis…

Embiid, Luka, Curry, healthy AD, KD… and to to a lesser degree Zion, Ja, Mitchell, Booker, Siakim, butler etc etc etc… the league is stacked-

And Curry, KD and AD healthy are definitely serious threats on any given day to be the best player on earth as proven by them winning rings…

I don’t want you to misunderstand me- i don’t care who wins because there are 5-6 worthy candidates at this point.

It’s a fun debate but I have no damn idea who is going to or even who should win! I think jokic but…


To sum up this debate. You used advanced stats few weeks ago to make a case why Jokic is better than Doncic, but you don't care about those same stats anymore, even if some candidates are light years worse than Luka/Jokic in those same stats? :lol:

My I remind you, that you were 100% sure that Luka is completely out of the race just 10 days ago.
LessEyeTest
Junior
Posts: 485
And1: 651
Joined: Apr 25, 2022

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#802 » by LessEyeTest » Thu Jan 5, 2023 7:50 pm

CobraCommander wrote:
LessEyeTest wrote:Jokic, Luka, Tatum, Giannis (looking past his down season advanced metrics), Durant.

Nobody else deserves to be in the discussion.

Not even Embiid ?

Not a healthy Curry or AD?


Embiid - no, absolutely 0% chance. There’s a better and more valuable center ahead of him who will probably win his 3rd straight MVP.

Curry & AD won’t even play 60 games this year.
CobraCommander
RealGM
Posts: 25,428
And1: 16,525
Joined: May 01, 2014
       

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#803 » by CobraCommander » Thu Jan 5, 2023 8:04 pm

Bob8 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:
Bob8 wrote:
Let's compare him to Tatum, your second best player. Stats, you were using to prove your point in the past, show he's better in everything, advanced stats a lot better.

https://stathead.com/tiny/o8hgZ

Jokic is the only player with comparable season to Luka. Anything can change of course. I doubt very much that Luka can play the whole RS with that usage doing what he's doing now. He's the whole system, it's become normal for him to play the whole second half and has to work hard in D too. Mavs are playing RS like it's playoffs already, all games close. His body won't last that kind of stress.

Bob- I’m not saying Tatum is the second best player -

I said he is (or was) second in MVP voting because he is a great two way, on best team in league, previously in finals, had great stats and IS PLAYING in BOSTON. I’m not saying Tatum is second best in world. I think objectively, Giannis is second to Jokic and after that there are a bunch of guys that include Luka that can be considered right below Jokic and Giannis…

Embiid, Luka, Curry, healthy AD, KD… and to to a lesser degree Zion, Ja, Mitchell, Booker, Siakim, butler etc etc etc… the league is stacked-

And Curry, KD and AD healthy are definitely serious threats on any given day to be the best player on earth as proven by them winning rings…

I don’t want you to misunderstand me- i don’t care who wins because there are 5-6 worthy candidates at this point.

It’s a fun debate but I have no damn idea who is going to or even who should win! I think jokic but…


To sum up this debate. You used advanced stats few weeks ago to make a case why Jokic is better than Doncic, but you don't care about those same stats anymore, even if some candidates are light years worse than Luka/Jokic in those same stats? :lol:

My I remind you, that you were 100% sure that Luka is completely out of the race just 10 days ago.

I never said anyone was out the race....I said...just like the overwhelming majority of the posters and poll takers on this thread that Jokic was the MVP at that time because his stats were the best and his team was in first...just like now honestly

since then Luka has had a crazy run...Giannis has had crazy run...Embiid is on a crazy run...KD is 12 and 1 and playing well. Tatum took a step back...team lost some games and he has fallen back... in 82 game season that happens...

Do you only watch mavs games and you have a specific cam that spotlights Luka?

I know you love Luka but can you acknowledge that he isn’t even doing anything unprecedented and that there are 5 guys doing about the same thing right now...and that the best game this year was Mitchell...

I acknowledged Tatum fell back...but I hate Boston so I’m happy about that...
CobraCommander
RealGM
Posts: 25,428
And1: 16,525
Joined: May 01, 2014
       

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#804 » by CobraCommander » Thu Jan 5, 2023 8:06 pm

LessEyeTest wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:
LessEyeTest wrote:Jokic, Luka, Tatum, Giannis (looking past his down season advanced metrics), Durant.

Nobody else deserves to be in the discussion.

Not even Embiid ?

Not a healthy Curry or AD?


Embiid - no, absolutely 0% chance. There’s a better and more valuable center ahead of him who will probably win his 3rd straight MVP.

Curry & AD won’t even play 60 games this year.

I don’t know if these guys can keep this up for the rest Of the year....Embiid could catch them if they fall back and he keeps up his current pace... I don’t see it but it’s possible
Bob8
RealGM
Posts: 11,066
And1: 4,645
Joined: Feb 08, 2017

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#805 » by Bob8 » Thu Jan 5, 2023 8:49 pm

CobraCommander wrote:
Bob8 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:Bob- I’m not saying Tatum is the second best player -

I said he is (or was) second in MVP voting because he is a great two way, on best team in league, previously in finals, had great stats and IS PLAYING in BOSTON. I’m not saying Tatum is second best in world. I think objectively, Giannis is second to Jokic and after that there are a bunch of guys that include Luka that can be considered right below Jokic and Giannis…

Embiid, Luka, Curry, healthy AD, KD… and to to a lesser degree Zion, Ja, Mitchell, Booker, Siakim, butler etc etc etc… the league is stacked-

And Curry, KD and AD healthy are definitely serious threats on any given day to be the best player on earth as proven by them winning rings…

I don’t want you to misunderstand me- i don’t care who wins because there are 5-6 worthy candidates at this point.

It’s a fun debate but I have no damn idea who is going to or even who should win! I think jokic but…


To sum up this debate. You used advanced stats few weeks ago to make a case why Jokic is better than Doncic, but you don't care about those same stats anymore, even if some candidates are light years worse than Luka/Jokic in those same stats? :lol:

My I remind you, that you were 100% sure that Luka is completely out of the race just 10 days ago.

I never said anyone was out the race....I said...just like the overwhelming majority of the posters and poll takers on this thread that Jokic was the MVP at that time because his stats were the best and his team was in first...just like now honestly

since then Luka has had a crazy run...Giannis has had crazy run...Embiid is on a crazy run...KD is 12 and 1 and playing well. Tatum took a step back...team lost some games and he has fallen back... in 82 game season that happens...

Do you only watch mavs games and you have a specific cam that spotlights Luka?

I know you love Luka but can you acknowledge that he isn’t even doing anything unprecedented and that there are 5 guys doing about the same thing right now...and that the best game this year was Mitchell...

I acknowledged Tatum fell back...but I hate Boston so I’m happy about that...


I give in, everyone are doing the same thing, who cares, if 2 of them have light years better advanced stats and 1 of them the best counting stats. I will just wait for Trae to have a few good games and he will be in that group too. :D

https://www.basketball-reference.com/friv/mvp.html
CobraCommander
RealGM
Posts: 25,428
And1: 16,525
Joined: May 01, 2014
       

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#806 » by CobraCommander » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:07 pm

Bob8 wrote:
CobraCommander wrote:
Bob8 wrote:
To sum up this debate. You used advanced stats few weeks ago to make a case why Jokic is better than Doncic, but you don't care about those same stats anymore, even if some candidates are light years worse than Luka/Jokic in those same stats? :lol:

My I remind you, that you were 100% sure that Luka is completely out of the race just 10 days ago.

I never said anyone was out the race....I said...just like the overwhelming majority of the posters and poll takers on this thread that Jokic was the MVP at that time because his stats were the best and his team was in first...just like now honestly

since then Luka has had a crazy run...Giannis has had crazy run...Embiid is on a crazy run...KD is 12 and 1 and playing well. Tatum took a step back...team lost some games and he has fallen back... in 82 game season that happens...

Do you only watch mavs games and you have a specific cam that spotlights Luka?

I know you love Luka but can you acknowledge that he isn’t even doing anything unprecedented and that there are 5 guys doing about the same thing right now...and that the best game this year was Mitchell...

I acknowledged Tatum fell back...but I hate Boston so I’m happy about that...


I give in, everyone are doing the same thing, who cares, if 2 of them have light years better advanced stats and 1 of them the best counting stats. I will just wait for Trae to have a few good games and he will be in that group too. :D

https://www.basketball-reference.com/friv/mvp.html

I’m not following you - sorry - it’s not everyone -

like everyone else on the thread has mentioned- there are 5 people playing At unprecedented levels.

Not one of them has definitively separated themselves from the pack of those 5.

IMO- Jokic is most likely at the top of the 5- but with the rest of the other 4 guys playing so well any of these guys could win it.
mediocrityrules
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,829
And1: 5,672
Joined: Nov 27, 2013
 

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#807 » by mediocrityrules » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:17 pm

It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.
Circling calendars since 2021
liquidswords
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,256
And1: 1,255
Joined: May 19, 2021
 

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#808 » by liquidswords » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:29 pm

mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


This is exactly why I have Giannis ahead of Tatum and why I elevate Embiid because of all the injuries he's dealt with.

1) Jokic - unprecedented play x1000
2) Luka - unprecedented heater and team is winning
3) Giannis - extraterrestrial #'s despite not having his sidekicks
4) Embiid - extraterrestrial #'s despite not having his sidekicks
5) Tatum - reached another level of play. team is winning (despite last couple weeks)
Bob8
RealGM
Posts: 11,066
And1: 4,645
Joined: Feb 08, 2017

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#809 » by Bob8 » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:33 pm

mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


I believe some stars would have been ecstatic, if their teammates would have been 4/2 without them, like Giannis' teammates are.
Jadoogar
RealGM
Posts: 17,377
And1: 17,019
Joined: May 06, 2010
   

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#810 » by Jadoogar » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:47 pm

mediocrityrules wrote:This is what you call gravity...

Image


ugh and the pass he made here was incredible. FVV shouldn't have helped.
Cubbies2120
Head Coach
Posts: 6,382
And1: 9,296
Joined: Apr 20, 2012
Location: MD
 

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#811 » by Cubbies2120 » Thu Jan 5, 2023 9:55 pm

mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


Jrue has played in 27 games, only 5 less than Giannis.

When he has a full season with no #2 and #3 (or more!) then he'll get pity from me :lol:
Jokic 5x MVP train
Exp0sed
General Manager
Posts: 8,002
And1: 7,431
Joined: Feb 10, 2022

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#812 » by Exp0sed » Thu Jan 5, 2023 10:54 pm

mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


The Bucks have the 3rd best defensive rating in the league
Middelton is def missed and Jrue hasn't been a 100% (still mighty productive when he played, especially on D), that's fine

his "cast" may have been struggling on offense but they are bringing it defensively

so let's not get carried away, defense still exists :P
User avatar
Ron Swanson
RealGM
Posts: 26,037
And1: 30,016
Joined: May 15, 2013

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#813 » by Ron Swanson » Thu Jan 5, 2023 11:29 pm

Exp0sed wrote:
mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


The Bucks have the 3rd best defensive rating in the league
Middelton is def missed and Jrue hasn't been a 100% (still mighty productive when he played, especially on D), that's fine

his "cast" may have been struggling on offense but they are bringing it defensively

so let's not get carried away, defense still exists :P


Yeah I'm sure that a certain former DPOTY winner on that roster isn't a massive reason why their defense is awesome. Has to be the "cast" doing the heavy lifting there.
Bob8
RealGM
Posts: 11,066
And1: 4,645
Joined: Feb 08, 2017

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#814 » by Bob8 » Thu Jan 5, 2023 11:51 pm

Exp0sed wrote:
mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


The Bucks have the 3rd best defensive rating in the league
Middelton is def missed and Jrue hasn't been a 100% (still mighty productive when he played, especially on D), that's fine

his "cast" may have been struggling on offense but they are bringing it defensively

so let's not get carried away, defense still exists :P


Not only D. Bucks are 2/2 without their top 3 players. No problem with load management, if you have roster like that.
Exp0sed
General Manager
Posts: 8,002
And1: 7,431
Joined: Feb 10, 2022

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#815 » by Exp0sed » Thu Jan 5, 2023 11:56 pm

Ron Swanson wrote:
Exp0sed wrote:
mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.


The Bucks have the 3rd best defensive rating in the league
Middelton is def missed and Jrue hasn't been a 100% (still mighty productive when he played, especially on D), that's fine

his "cast" may have been struggling on offense but they are bringing it defensively

so let's not get carried away, defense still exists :P


Yeah I'm sure that a certain former DPOTY winner on that roster isn't a massive reason why their defense is awesome. Has to be the "cast" doing the heavy lifting there.


lol, did it sound like I was trying to imply Giannis doesn't have a major role in the Bucks being this good defensively?

how much is "massive" btw?

in the tiny sample size without Giannis (6 game iirc) the Bucks are only 4 def rating points worse

it's like going from the 3rd best defense this season to the 7th best - how massive is that? :)


Lopez has been a DPOY candidate himself, Carter while being a liability on offense for sure - has been one of the better guard defenders this season. Jrue hasn't been himself but even 50% of Jrue is a plus defender
and so are other players, Bucks have some capable defeneders and not many terrible ones, they have a great defensive team.

yes, Giannis is the best defender in this team :)
so what?
does it mean we need to ignore they are doing a good job collectively?

my post was meant to illustrate than they might seem weak offensively outside of Giannis this season and it's easy to say he had no help etc. but on D he's gotten ALOT of help and that's also part of the game :)

it was by no means at attempt to slight Giannis even tho his insane usage and complete offensive carry job has forced him to play great but not elite defense

he won't be winning DPOY for the first half of this season that's for sure
Exp0sed
General Manager
Posts: 8,002
And1: 7,431
Joined: Feb 10, 2022

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#816 » by Exp0sed » Fri Jan 6, 2023 12:30 am

I think it's for Sabonis to get some love itt
obviously not a top candidate but i have him higher than some players that get mentioned here in the 5-10 range

The kings are 5th in the West, Domas is averaging almost 19 \ 12.5 \ 7 on 68 ts%!
he's got an offensive rating of 135

dude is ballin'
AleksandarN
General Manager
Posts: 9,382
And1: 12,907
Joined: Aug 08, 2002

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#817 » by AleksandarN » Fri Jan 6, 2023 12:36 am

mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.

I would love to have a supporting cast member as abysmal as Lopez
Packbuckman
Veteran
Posts: 2,727
And1: 1,362
Joined: Oct 02, 2019
     

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#818 » by Packbuckman » Fri Jan 6, 2023 2:02 am

AleksandarN wrote:
mediocrityrules wrote:It sucks that Giannis hasn't been able to play with the Bucks 2nd and 3rd best players this season, as the supporting cast has been abysmal, especially lately (yet somehow the Bucks still have the equal 2nd best record in the league). Giannis, Middleton, and Jrue have played a total of 69 minutes together this season.

I would love to have a supporting cast member as abysmal as Lopez


Lopez has been great on D and started out hot from 3 he’s cooled off a bit but still playing pretty good same with Portis. It’s the guard play and sf where we are starting Carter Allen and Pat who are not NBA caliber starters. And Buds refusal to give minutes to rookie Marjon who’s more athletic bigger who’s played well when out there. Our shooting from 3 has been bad and lately just abysmal with them missing almost everything where it falls on Giannis to shoot more and do basically everything to have us still tied with 2nd best record in the league
Statlanta
RealGM
Posts: 13,907
And1: 10,519
Joined: Mar 06, 2016

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#819 » by Statlanta » Fri Jan 6, 2023 2:18 am

Luka sabotaging his goodwill playing sick tonight.
The Greatest of All Time debate in basketball is essentially who has the greatest basketball resume of the player who has the best highlights instead of who is the best player
Cubbies2120
Head Coach
Posts: 6,382
And1: 9,296
Joined: Apr 20, 2012
Location: MD
 

Re: NBA MVP Discussion Thread 2022-23 (pt 2) 

Post#820 » by Cubbies2120 » Fri Jan 6, 2023 2:31 am

Exp0sed wrote:I think it's for Sabonis to get some love itt
obviously not a top candidate but i have him higher than some players that get mentioned here in the 5-10 range

The kings are 5th in the West, Domas is averaging almost 19 \ 12.5 \ 7 on 68 ts%!
he's got an offensive rating of 135

dude is ballin'


He's a mini Jokic - more mobile, looks to get teammates involved & extremely efficient. Love watching him play
Jokic 5x MVP train

Return to The General Board