Winsome Gerbil wrote:trlp1712 wrote:Winsome Gerbil wrote:I don't think so.
For comparison, I consider Cousins and Davis to be franchise level bigs, and think its highly likely Embiid and KAT will join them.
I think Blake is a borderline case, who might be able to be one in different circumstances, but would need defensive help.
I don't consider Marc Gasol productive enough to be one, and it was very borderline whether his brother ever truly was either.
I think Jokic has a shot to be like a 3rd Gasol brother. I don't think he's ever going to be a dominant enough scorer, or a strong enough defender, to truly be "the franchise", but he's got a chance to be a strong #2/borderline All Star guy every year.
How is Cousins a franchise level big, but beither Gasol was? Hell, how is Marc Gasol not productive enough?
What reasoning did you use to reach this conclusion?
Sigh. Ok, look, RGM is touchy about too much comparative stuff being done out here on the general board instead of the Player Comparisons board. Nonetheless, the widespread Boogie ignorance on RGM has long been a sore spot with me, so I'm going to do this quickly.
Marc:The single most productive NBA season Marc Gasol has ever had is this one so far, and he's produced:
33.9min 19.9pts 6.2reb 4.3ast 1.0stl 1.5blk
Which puts him 35th in the league in scoring, and 61st in the league in rebounding.
His best full season was 2 years ago when he produced:
33.2min 17.4pts 7.8reb 3.8ast 0.9stl 1.6blk
Those are, none of them, franchise player level numbers. That's a star, not a superstar.
Pau:The single best season Pau ever put up tyring to carry Memphis on his own was:
36.2min 20.8pts 9.8reb 3.4ast 0.5stl 2.1blk
That's getting close to franchise level. Unfortunately it was one of only two years he ever broke 20ppg in a 15 year career. He was built to be a #2.
His best year as a #2 to Kobe was:
37.0min 18.3pts 11.3reb 3.4ast 0.6stl 1.7blk
Cousins:Now let me demonstrate the gap between a skilled 18-20ppg star player, and a carry you every night franchise player. Cousins the last 4 years:
32.4min 22.7pts 11.7reb 2.9ast 1.5stl 1.3blk
34.1min 24.1pts 12.7reb 3.6ast 1.5stl 1.7blk
34.6min 26.9pts 11.5reb 3.3ast 1.6stl 1.4blk
34.7min 29.1pts 10.4reb 3.5ast 1.3stl 1.5blk
Conclusion:So to review:
Franchise player: 34.1min 24.1pts 12.7reb 3.6ast 1.5stl 1.7blk
Not franchise player: 33.2min 17.4pts 7.8reb 3.8ast 0.9stl 1.6blk
Franchise player: 34.7min 29.1pts 10.4reb 3.5ast 1.3stl 1.5blk
Not franchise player: 36.2min 20.8pts 9.8reb 3.4ast 0.5stl 2.1blk
Having better teammates has never been a franchise player qualification. And if it is, Jokic is in trouble anyway. marc has made 2 All Star games in 9 years. Pay made 6 in 16, although only 1 as the main guy in Memphis (then 3 as Kobe's caddy, and 2 more dubious ones in Chicago). All Star caliber bigs, borderline All Star bigs. I can see Jokic reaching that level.
Jokic:And to bring that all back to Jokic, his per36 right now is 17.7pts 11.1reb 5.3ast 0.9stl 1.0blk. Last year it was 16.5pts 11.6reb 3.9ast 1.6stl 1.0blk. That looks to me to be a guy headed much more down the Gasol path than the Boogie/KAT/Embiid 25-10 massive production path.