Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13

Moderators: Prez, ken6199, Dirk, Domejandro, zimpy27, bwgood77, BombsquadSammy, Yuri Vaultin, PockyCandy

Who would you rather have for next year

Butler + Shai Gilgeous-Alexander
48
62%
PG13 + Moe Harkless (prolly)
29
38%
 
Total votes: 77

UtahJazzFan88
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,733
And1: 2,545
Joined: Mar 21, 2011
Location: Utah
   

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#21 » by UtahJazzFan88 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 7:00 am

stormi wrote:Paul George is so much better than Jimmy Butler that it's a no brainer for me, and I love Shai


Agreed, plus you never know what kind of attitude or locker room guy Jimmy is.
JN61
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,353
And1: 852
Joined: Jan 07, 2018
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#22 » by JN61 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 7:12 am

George last year was heads and shoulders above any year's versio of Butler. Granted some of it is Westbrook's impact but to me it's George any day. I would be more worried of he had leg injury rather than shoulder. So give me George.

Also Butler's attitude is a problem considering his status as a player. He is borderline all-star (not an all-star in West) having superstar attitude and maintenance while George was having superstar year and he is very low maintenance guy and good for locker room in comparison.
JN61
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,353
And1: 852
Joined: Jan 07, 2018
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#23 » by JN61 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 7:18 am

Prokorov wrote:
Vae Victus wrote:I'm a bit bored and i'm wondering what board consensus would be on this hypothetical scenario.

Lets say if Butler was willing to be 2nd banana to Kawhi and Kawhi is happy with that arrangements and outright signs with LAC.= to begin the team up.

If Butler comes to LAC for cap (or S&T), lets say Gallo + 2 SRPs for pure cap space goes out, SGA stays, and Kawhi signs for cap as well. Rest of the moves plays out similarly.

C - Zubac, Harrell, Kabengle
PF- Green, Harkless? (this likely wouldnt happen unless S&T shenanigans was involved in getting Butler from PHI)
SF- Kawhi, JRobinson, MacGruder
SG- Butler, Lou Will, Shamet
PG- SGA, PatBev, Mann

Kawhi plays some PF if the other team goes small at that spot. Butler can slide to 3 when that happens. Clips are thin at PF, unless Kabengele steps up in a big way, or Zubac + Harrell both can play 30+ mins without hurting spacing.

As you can see it's basically a Butler + SGA vs PG13 + Harkless? situation. I'm not gonna factor in draft picks as that makes picking the Butler + SGA combo too easy, imo. Let's just say, for next season, which move would be better. Which Clipper team would be stronger?


this isnt close. butler alone is much better then PG. then add SGA?

George played better offense and better defense than Butler last year, so not sure about your statement.
User avatar
QRich3
Forum Mod - Clippers
Forum Mod - Clippers
Posts: 5,570
And1: 3,605
Joined: Apr 03, 2011
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#24 » by QRich3 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 8:41 am

When you have the luck to get to the point of being a contender, you're not in the business of gathering assets or winning trades anymore. It's a once in a generation opportunity and you should do everything in your power to bring yourself closer to it. So if you have to pay two 1st round picks for a 34 year old role player that's gonna give you 15MPG (totally made up hypothetical scenario), but that gets you considerably closer to a championship, you do that otherwise horrible trade in a heartbeat.

In that regard, the price for getting George was insane. But George is a clearly better player than Butler and he gets you closer to winning a championship, so that's undeniably the better choice. Not to mention he's gonna be much less of a headache and he's the first (1A 1B with Kawhi) all NBA type of player that's willingly gone out of his way to come here. That gives you a lot more security than committing to pay 34 year old Butler $38M.

Mylie10 wrote:
stormi wrote:Paul George is so much better than Jimmy Butler that it's a no brainer for me, and I love Shai


I like George way better. And I really like the guys they drafted in Kabengele and Mann who I think is a total diamond in the rough.

I watched Mann completely shut down Ja Morant in the Tourney. I'm talking only when he guarded Ja. Nobody else can stop him. But I see Mann as a sg/SF.

Anyhow, I think they are happy how it worked out and I think George fits the locker room better than Butler would.

Mann's looked amazing in summer league too, I worry his offense is way too rough to get playing time in the real NBA, but apparently Jerry West is convinced he'll be a core part of the rotation by year's end. Excited to watch how he evolves.
Vae Victus
Analyst
Posts: 3,030
And1: 1,174
Joined: Jun 09, 2013

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#25 » by Vae Victus » Wed Aug 14, 2019 9:10 am

TheNewEra wrote:
Not Suave Rico wrote:Doesn't seem the Clippers front office wanted anything to do with Butler. I don't believe they even reached out to his people even though he expressed interest in the team just last year.



I really want to find out more about this someday. Butler expressed major interest in the team around the time he was traded so what happen. How did he go from interest to there being no talk at all about him going to the clippers in free agency?

Did the front office give him the cold shoulder and if they did wtf why ? If Presti doesn’t bite we are assed out with no second star but we were ready to give money to Morris?


Yea, i was honestly quite pissed that the LAC FO didnt kick the tires on Butler first, since Kawhi was acting too cute.

IMHO, signing Butler right off the bat (and maybe later on S&T once all the pieces are in place) to use as a lure for Kawhi (or Kyrie, KD, etc) was the safest, smartest, and highest longterm upside move. Adding Butler to last year's squad woulda easily added several wins (48 to 55) turn the squad into a semi contender status, especially with the fall of the GSW dynasty. Then with Butler as a lure, convincing Kawhi to come shoulda been easy. Also keeping all the picks to make more moves for a 3rd star, woulda been the true ideal. If the Clippers had sold out on a 3rd star level player by trading the entire pantry of future unprotected FRPs, then it woulda been 100% worth it. Prolly something along the lines of Lou Will + JRobinson + assloads of picks.

Now if Butler had snubbed LAC, then i can understand. if Butler refused to be a 2nd banana to Kawhi, then fine, it is what it is. But forcing yourself into a corner to grossly overpay for PG13 in order to convince Kawhi to join (stealing him from the Lakers), really just reeks of poor asset management, which they spent years carefully building up.

Butler and Kawhi didnt decide on a team on day 1 of FA, the Clips really shoulda just swooped in on Butler and convinced him to sign before MIA had time to craft a package. MIA without Butler in 2021 is rather meh and coulda yielded a really nice FRP.
User avatar
QRich3
Forum Mod - Clippers
Forum Mod - Clippers
Posts: 5,570
And1: 3,605
Joined: Apr 03, 2011
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#26 » by QRich3 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 9:25 am

I actually think it was really smart on their part to not want anything to do with Butler. They traded away a better player in Griffin because he made too much money and was not good enough. They weren't about to turn around a give more money to a worse player of the same age, who came with attitude problems too.
User avatar
DaddyCool19
Analyst
Posts: 3,447
And1: 3,531
Joined: Jul 28, 2013

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#27 » by DaddyCool19 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 9:36 am

So if the Clippers chooseoption A, they keep their picks right?

I bet they could turn those picks + J Robinson into some useful PF and then roll with it
The_Hater
RealGM
Posts: 70,086
And1: 23,183
Joined: May 23, 2001
     

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#28 » by The_Hater » Wed Aug 14, 2019 11:13 am

Mamba Mentality wrote:Obviously the better scenario is the one in which they retain Shai. Remember this is the same guy that the Clippers weren't willing to trade for AD...amazing what a fear of a Lakers dynasty will make you do.


The ridiculous arrogance and self centred nature of some Laker fans always amazes me.
AthensBucks wrote:Lowry is done.
Nurse is below average at best.
Masai is overrated.
I dont get how so many people believe in the raptors,they have zero to chance to win it all.


April 14th, 2019.
The_Hater
RealGM
Posts: 70,086
And1: 23,183
Joined: May 23, 2001
     

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#29 » by The_Hater » Wed Aug 14, 2019 11:40 am

Prokorov wrote:
Vae Victus wrote:I'm a bit bored and i'm wondering what board consensus would be on this hypothetical scenario.

Lets say if Butler was willing to be 2nd banana to Kawhi and Kawhi is happy with that arrangements and outright signs with LAC.= to begin the team up.

If Butler comes to LAC for cap (or S&T), lets say Gallo + 2 SRPs for pure cap space goes out, SGA stays, and Kawhi signs for cap as well. Rest of the moves plays out similarly.

C - Zubac, Harrell, Kabengle
PF- Green, Harkless? (this likely wouldnt happen unless S&T shenanigans was involved in getting Butler from PHI)
SF- Kawhi, JRobinson, MacGruder
SG- Butler, Lou Will, Shamet
PG- SGA, PatBev, Mann

Kawhi plays some PF if the other team goes small at that spot. Butler can slide to 3 when that happens. Clips are thin at PF, unless Kabengele steps up in a big way, or Zubac + Harrell both can play 30+ mins without hurting spacing.

As you can see it's basically a Butler + SGA vs PG13 + Harkless? situation. I'm not gonna factor in draft picks as that makes picking the Butler + SGA combo too easy, imo. Let's just say, for next season, which move would be better. Which Clipper team would be stronger?


this isnt close. butler alone is much better then PG. then add SGA?


I’m at the the point where I’m convinced that your just a parody account.
AthensBucks wrote:Lowry is done.
Nurse is below average at best.
Masai is overrated.
I dont get how so many people believe in the raptors,they have zero to chance to win it all.


April 14th, 2019.
User avatar
Prokorov
RealGM
Posts: 33,191
And1: 10,296
Joined: Dec 06, 2013
       

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#30 » by Prokorov » Wed Aug 14, 2019 11:54 am

JN61 wrote:
Prokorov wrote:
Vae Victus wrote:I'm a bit bored and i'm wondering what board consensus would be on this hypothetical scenario.

Lets say if Butler was willing to be 2nd banana to Kawhi and Kawhi is happy with that arrangements and outright signs with LAC.= to begin the team up.

If Butler comes to LAC for cap (or S&T), lets say Gallo + 2 SRPs for pure cap space goes out, SGA stays, and Kawhi signs for cap as well. Rest of the moves plays out similarly.

C - Zubac, Harrell, Kabengle
PF- Green, Harkless? (this likely wouldnt happen unless S&T shenanigans was involved in getting Butler from PHI)
SF- Kawhi, JRobinson, MacGruder
SG- Butler, Lou Will, Shamet
PG- SGA, PatBev, Mann

Kawhi plays some PF if the other team goes small at that spot. Butler can slide to 3 when that happens. Clips are thin at PF, unless Kabengele steps up in a big way, or Zubac + Harrell both can play 30+ mins without hurting spacing.

As you can see it's basically a Butler + SGA vs PG13 + Harkless? situation. I'm not gonna factor in draft picks as that makes picking the Butler + SGA combo too easy, imo. Let's just say, for next season, which move would be better. Which Clipper team would be stronger?


this isnt close. butler alone is much better then PG. then add SGA?

George played better offense and better defense than Butler last year, so not sure about your statement.


nope. not close. George is the most empty stats player of our generation. gets everything at the expense of the team and his defense is at best average.
Kswiss wrote:Go watch a D'Angelo Russell highlight tape and tell me with a straight face the kid looks like a NBA prospect. I just can't see him in the league in three years.


Timestamp: July 21, 2017
JN61
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,353
And1: 852
Joined: Jan 07, 2018
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#31 » by JN61 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 12:08 pm

Prokorov wrote:
JN61 wrote:
Prokorov wrote:
this isnt close. butler alone is much better then PG. then add SGA?

George played better offense and better defense than Butler last year, so not sure about your statement.


nope. not close. George is the most empty stats player of our generation. gets everything at the expense of the team and his defense is at best average.

Then I take it you didn't watch a single game of OKC before all-star break. George got big part of his offense from catch and shoot opportunities with Westbrook, thus not disturbing other offense at all, and when Westbrook sat he was a bit more iso heavy but was doing it pretty much at league best rate. On defense he was clearly OKCs best defender while motivating whole team (even Westbrook) to play defense. Before all-star break he was having DPOY type of season.
TheNewEra
RealGM
Posts: 18,771
And1: 5,219
Joined: Aug 28, 2008
Location: Lob City
       

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#32 » by TheNewEra » Wed Aug 14, 2019 12:48 pm

QRich3 wrote:I actually think it was really smart on their part to not want anything to do with Butler. They traded away a better player in Griffin because he made too much money and was not good enough. They weren't about to turn around a give more money to a worse player of the same age, who came with attitude problems too.


You have to have someone of note to lure Kawhi. The team was left scrambling trying to get Beal and Harden when getting the sidekick should of been in the master plan this whole time. You pay whatever big name brings in Kawhi and unless Kawhi said no to Butler I don’t get not pursuing him in free agency.
User avatar
Forte IV
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,013
And1: 4,145
Joined: Jun 12, 2008
Location: Los Angeles/Milwaukee
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#33 » by Forte IV » Wed Aug 14, 2019 12:59 pm

Mamba Mentality wrote:Obviously the better scenario is the one in which they retain Shai. Remember this is the same guy that the Clippers weren't willing to trade for AD...amazing what a fear of a Lakers dynasty will make you do.


You almost made a complete nice comment about the Clippers. Almost.
If you want a good laugh, read this thread: viewtopic.php?f=6&t=1765067
User avatar
Mylie10
RealGM
Posts: 37,140
And1: 8,042
Joined: Sep 16, 2005
Location: * Chokers! *
Contact:
     

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#34 » by Mylie10 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 2:33 pm

QRich3 wrote:When you have the luck to get to the point of being a contender, you're not in the business of gathering assets or winning trades anymore. It's a once in a generation opportunity and you should do everything in your power to bring yourself closer to it. So if you have to pay two 1st round picks for a 34 year old role player that's gonna give you 15MPG (totally made up hypothetical scenario), but that gets you considerably closer to a championship, you do that otherwise horrible trade in a heartbeat.

In that regard, the price for getting George was insane. But George is a clearly better player than Butler and he gets you closer to winning a championship, so that's undeniably the better choice. Not to mention he's gonna be much less of a headache and he's the first (1A 1B with Kawhi) all NBA type of player that's willingly gone out of his way to come here. That gives you a lot more security than committing to pay 34 year old Butler $38M.

Mylie10 wrote:
stormi wrote:Paul George is so much better than Jimmy Butler that it's a no brainer for me, and I love Shai


I like George way better. And I really like the guys they drafted in Kabengele and Mann who I think is a total diamond in the rough.

I watched Mann completely shut down Ja Morant in the Tourney. I'm talking only when he guarded Ja. Nobody else can stop him. But I see Mann as a sg/SF.

Anyhow, I think they are happy how it worked out and I think George fits the locker room better than Butler would.

Mann's looked amazing in summer league too, I worry his offense is way too rough to get playing time in the real NBA, but apparently Jerry West is convinced he'll be a core part of the rotation by year's end. Excited to watch how he evolves.


I see Mann as a glue type of player anyhow. He doesn't need to score to contribute. If he gets some minutes and plays really good reliable defense, then he should carve out a spot.

However based on your depth, he probably spends time in the G league getting playing time. Young guys need to play, and it's not a knock on him to go down there at times.
MoneyTalks41890
RealGM
Posts: 15,626
And1: 7,086
Joined: Oct 13, 2009
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#35 » by MoneyTalks41890 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 2:43 pm

PG is a better player and a better fit. Butler is too ball dominant. Also, the Sixers got J Rich in a sign and trade so Gallo and 2nds would have been unlikely.
playaloc916
Veteran
Posts: 2,594
And1: 270
Joined: Jul 28, 2006
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#36 » by playaloc916 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 4:56 pm

ken6199 wrote:
ClipsFanSince98 wrote:If you want a 5 year title window (or closer to one) PG/Harkless. If you want to be better for the next year or two, maybe Butler and SGA. Good question though. I see PG aging much better than Butler and having less injury problems. If the draft assets were factored I take Butler/SGA in a landslide. Just these 4 players though I take PG/Harkless by a small edge.

Disagree on this. The (assumed) slower decline in PG does not offset the ballhandling of SGA who I see will develop into a really solid, above average starting PG. Butler's alpha dog mentality actually will work pretty well in the current LAC culture.

I don't think Butler's personality would be the best fit with this team. FO has put in a lot of work getting in guys who really buy into the team first, blue collar, workhorse/dog mentality. Butler has the blue collar/workhorse aspect, but the team first part, not sure...
I haven't been following Butler very close, but the impression I get is that he's a bit like Chris Paul, and if you don't fit exactly what he's looking for, he won't get along with you.

To me the center piece of the team is Kawhi. Knowing his soft spoken personality, I'd want to make sure there's nothing on the team that could negatively impact him, and with Butler, although he could get along really well with him, I'd rather go with PG who seems to have a more chill vibe like Kawhi, than to take a chance on Butler.
reflex35
Sophomore
Posts: 182
And1: 72
Joined: Jul 10, 2019

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#37 » by reflex35 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 5:12 pm

Still PG.
Better at everything than Buttler.
Much respect for Jimmy for even becoming such a player that we started comparing him to PG. Who would have guessed that 5-6 years ago?
But PG is just a better talent. All around. And that difference is more important than SGA. Everyone talks about this potential but we had this "potential thing" for hundreds and hundreds times not working out...
I take PG and run because he is the best player in this equation.
Dan Z
Head Coach
Posts: 7,127
And1: 2,405
Joined: Feb 19, 2002
Location: Chicago
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#38 » by Dan Z » Wed Aug 14, 2019 5:15 pm

Mamba Mentality wrote:Obviously the better scenario is the one in which they retain Shai. Remember this is the same guy that the Clippers weren't willing to trade for AD...amazing what a fear of a Lakers dynasty will make you do.


Is that true? It sounds like there's more to that story.
User avatar
Forte IV
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,013
And1: 4,145
Joined: Jun 12, 2008
Location: Los Angeles/Milwaukee
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#39 » by Forte IV » Wed Aug 14, 2019 6:54 pm

It's definitely a hard question. Paul George was arguably the best player in basketball for a few weeks there last year. SGA is gonna be a stud. But 4 year max for Butler makes me pick Paul George every day. PG's game is gonna age way better than Jimmys.
If you want a good laugh, read this thread: viewtopic.php?f=6&t=1765067
User avatar
ClipsFanSince98
RealGM
Posts: 13,809
And1: 13,061
Joined: Sep 19, 2015
 

Re: Offseason LAC What If?: Butler/SGA instead of PG13 

Post#40 » by ClipsFanSince98 » Wed Aug 14, 2019 6:56 pm

Forte IV wrote:It's definitely a hard question. Paul George was arguably the best player in basketball for a few weeks there last year. SGA is gonna be a stud. But 4 year max for Butler makes me pick Paul George every day. PG's game is gonna age way better than Jimmys.


Try like 3 months :D . He had a 3 month stretch of 31/8/5 I believe on stupid efficiency.

Return to The General Board