Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony

Moderators: PockyCandy, Prez, ken6199, bwgood77, Dirk, Domejandro, jamaalstar21, zimpy27, BombsquadSammy, GeorgeMarcus

Whose the better Scorer?

Melo
42
27%
T-Mac
113
73%
 
Total votes: 155

User avatar
XTC
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,714
And1: 2,012
Joined: Nov 09, 2005
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#41 » by XTC » Thu Mar 26, 2020 8:56 pm

SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:Both were very good scorers but T-Mac was a more well rounded scorer. Mac carried a Magic roster with several lemons to the playoffs several times. Melo for almost his whole career had more talent around him (especially in Denver). Buckets can be easier to get with more talent around. T-Mac was supposed to be paired with Grant Hill but he couldnt get healthy for most that time. So I give the edge to McGrady.


Melo never played next a player as great as Yao, yet in his first season in Houston (before the back injuries) a 25 year old TMac shot 43.6% with a TS% of 52.6

And I disagree about your claim that Tracy was a better all around scorer than Melo who could score inside and out with the best of them, and the efficiency difference backs up my claim.


Yao or T-Mac was barely ever healthy during their tenure. They were only on the same roster for three and a half seasons. Stats dont always tell a true story. Melo as a rookie played with Marcus Camby, Andre Miller, Earl Boykins, and Nene. And in his second season he gained Kenyon Martin as a running mate. T-Mac had been in the league 7 years prior; of which the four before Melo (2000-2003) entered the league Mac averaged 39 minutes a game; dragging a lottery level roster to the playoffs. If were being honest here; Melo wasnt ever good enough to take a roster similar to that Magic team to the playoffs.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty

01-02 only added 50 year old Patrick Ewing and Horace Grant to the same roster that still was without Grant Hill. 02-03 The team traded Mike Miller for Drew Gooden and signed Shawn Kemp during his alcohol rehab to play his way back into shape. Grant Hill contributed 29 games. Yet in spite of all this they made the playoffs every year and competed against good teams. Your stats cant dispute that.


You’re really comparing playing with Kenyon Martin, Nene, and Camby to Yao Ming? :lol:

I’m done you win this arguement :lol: :lol: :lol:
User avatar
SmashMouthRod
Rookie
Posts: 1,020
And1: 165
Joined: May 31, 2012
   

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#42 » by SmashMouthRod » Thu Mar 26, 2020 9:18 pm

XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
Melo never played next a player as great as Yao, yet in his first season in Houston (before the back injuries) a 25 year old TMac shot 43.6% with a TS% of 52.6

And I disagree about your claim that Tracy was a better all around scorer than Melo who could score inside and out with the best of them, and the efficiency difference backs up my claim.


Yao or T-Mac was barely ever healthy during their tenure. They were only on the same roster for three and a half seasons. Stats dont always tell a true story. Melo as a rookie played with Marcus Camby, Andre Miller, Earl Boykins, and Nene. And in his second season he gained Kenyon Martin as a running mate. T-Mac had been in the league 7 years prior; of which the four before Melo (2000-2003) entered the league Mac averaged 39 minutes a game; dragging a lottery level roster to the playoffs. If were being honest here; Melo wasnt ever good enough to take a roster similar to that Magic team to the playoffs.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty

01-02 only added 50 year old Patrick Ewing and Horace Grant to the same roster that still was without Grant Hill. 02-03 The team traded Mike Miller for Drew Gooden and signed Shawn Kemp during his alcohol rehab to play his way back into shape. Grant Hill contributed 29 games. Yet in spite of all this they made the playoffs every year and competed against good teams. Your stats cant dispute that.


You’re really comparing playing with Kenyon Martin, Nene, and Camby to Yao Ming? :lol:

I’m done you win this arguement :lol: :lol: :lol:


Add on Iverson, Amare Stoudemire and Chauncey Billups. We can definitely compare Amare to Yao. T-Mac had three years of Yao as a teammate. Melo had most of his career with a good 2nd star/supporting cast.
User avatar
XTC
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,714
And1: 2,012
Joined: Nov 09, 2005
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#43 » by XTC » Thu Mar 26, 2020 9:33 pm

SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:
Yao or T-Mac was barely ever healthy during their tenure. They were only on the same roster for three and a half seasons. Stats dont always tell a true story. Melo as a rookie played with Marcus Camby, Andre Miller, Earl Boykins, and Nene. And in his second season he gained Kenyon Martin as a running mate. T-Mac had been in the league 7 years prior; of which the four before Melo (2000-2003) entered the league Mac averaged 39 minutes a game; dragging a lottery level roster to the playoffs. If were being honest here; Melo wasnt ever good enough to take a roster similar to that Magic team to the playoffs.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty

01-02 only added 50 year old Patrick Ewing and Horace Grant to the same roster that still was without Grant Hill. 02-03 The team traded Mike Miller for Drew Gooden and signed Shawn Kemp during his alcohol rehab to play his way back into shape. Grant Hill contributed 29 games. Yet in spite of all this they made the playoffs every year and competed against good teams. Your stats cant dispute that.


You’re really comparing playing with Kenyon Martin, Nene, and Camby to Yao Ming? :lol:

I’m done you win this arguement :lol: :lol: :lol:


Add on Iverson, Amare Stoudemire and Chauncey Billups. We can definitely compare Amare to Yao. T-Mac had three years of Yao as a teammate. Melo had most of his career with a good 2nd star/supporting cast.


You must be trolling :lol:

Carmelo never played with PHX Amare. He played with an Amare who could barely run up the court. Now we go to TMac who played with Yao who is in the basketball hall of fame. TMac had more than enough help in Houston, but still scored below league efficiency.

We’re comparing TMac and Melo as scorers, and other than ONE season which was an outlier, TMac was not as good as Melo.

Also what does it say about Tmac that when he was replaced by Artest in Houston they finally got out of the first round? Carmelo was one game away from eliminating the Lakers in 09 and advancing to the finals.
Priest24
Senior
Posts: 515
And1: 421
Joined: Aug 11, 2017
     

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#44 » by Priest24 » Thu Mar 26, 2020 10:03 pm

It was Mcgrady. In Orlando it was out of necessity as Grant Hill was constantly injured. In Houston he was still an elite scorer even though Van Gundy used him as the playmaker. Melo never had that responsibility with Iverson,Billups,Miller, or even old Kidd.
User avatar
SmashMouthRod
Rookie
Posts: 1,020
And1: 165
Joined: May 31, 2012
   

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#45 » by SmashMouthRod » Thu Mar 26, 2020 10:18 pm

XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
You’re really comparing playing with Kenyon Martin, Nene, and Camby to Yao Ming? :lol:

I’m done you win this arguement :lol: :lol: :lol:


Add on Iverson, Amare Stoudemire and Chauncey Billups. We can definitely compare Amare to Yao. T-Mac had three years of Yao as a teammate. Melo had most of his career with a good 2nd star/supporting cast.


You must be trolling :lol:

Carmelo never played with PHX Amare. He played with an Amare who could barely run up the court. Now we go to TMac who played with Yao who is in the basketball hall of fame. TMac had more than enough help in Houston, but still scored below league efficiency.

We’re comparing TMac and Melo as scorers, and other than ONE season which was an outlier, TMac was not as good as Melo.

Also what does it say about Tmac that when he was replaced by Artest in Houston they finally got out of the first round? Carmelo was one game away from eliminating the Lakers in 09 and advancing to the finals.


Your only argument is longevity. Melo played a longer healthier more consistent career. Which we cant argue. But longer doesnt mean better overall. Gilbert Arenas was a better player at his peak than Kyle Lowry. Kyle played longer. Most of posters have already established that T-Mac peaked higher. When you put Melos best three years next to T-Macs best three in Orlando it tells the story. And my point stands about T-Mac putting up his production devoid of the type of talent that Melo played with for most of his career. You were the one who mentioned Yao. The degree of difficulty was higher for T-Mac is my argument.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty
User avatar
NUCKER101
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,095
And1: 9,562
Joined: Oct 31, 2013
   

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#46 » by NUCKER101 » Thu Mar 26, 2020 11:31 pm

T-Mac was the better player but I’ll take Melo as the better pure scorer.

Melo really shot himself in the foot leaving the Nuggets. A star player playing out his entire prime with a perennial playoff team definitely helps his legacy even if the player falls short of getting a ring.

I wonder if some of these stars who demand a trade and never really endear themselves to a team’s fanbase end up regretting it once they retire or get close to retiring.
We the Champs
User avatar
XTC
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,714
And1: 2,012
Joined: Nov 09, 2005
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#47 » by XTC » Fri Mar 27, 2020 12:02 am

SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:
Add on Iverson, Amare Stoudemire and Chauncey Billups. We can definitely compare Amare to Yao. T-Mac had three years of Yao as a teammate. Melo had most of his career with a good 2nd star/supporting cast.


You must be trolling :lol:

Carmelo never played with PHX Amare. He played with an Amare who could barely run up the court. Now we go to TMac who played with Yao who is in the basketball hall of fame. TMac had more than enough help in Houston, but still scored below league efficiency.

We’re comparing TMac and Melo as scorers, and other than ONE season which was an outlier, TMac was not as good as Melo.

Also what does it say about Tmac that when he was replaced by Artest in Houston they finally got out of the first round? Carmelo was one game away from eliminating the Lakers in 09 and advancing to the finals.


Your only argument is longevity. Melo played a longer healthier more consistent career. Which we cant argue. But longer doesnt mean better overall. Gilbert Arenas was a better player at his peak than Kyle Lowry. Kyle played longer. Most of posters have already established that T-Mac peaked higher. When you put Melos best three years next to T-Macs best three in Orlando it tells the story. And my point stands about T-Mac putting up his production devoid of the type of talent that Melo played with for most of his career. You were the one who mentioned Yao. The degree of difficulty was higher for T-Mac is my argument.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty


Your ONLY argument is woulda coulda shoulda. Facts are even when Tracy McGrady had a contender around him he failed to get past the first round. When Tracy McGrady was replaced Houston finally made it out of the first round.

Tracy McGrady was better than Carmelo ONE year, other than that give me Melo anyday. For a 6-8 hyper athletic supreme skilled wing player, McGrady sure did have some Iverson-esque efficiency.

Atleast Melo on some bottom dwellers had decent efficiency... but oh wait Amare post 2011 was a legit second option right :lol:
User avatar
Pennebaker
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,121
And1: 3,199
Joined: Nov 02, 2013

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#48 » by Pennebaker » Fri Mar 27, 2020 12:26 am

This is a good question.

Both only have four 50 point games in their career and one 60 point game.
Their career scoring high is identical at 62 points.
TMac has 2 scoring titles while Melo only has 1.
Melo has a higher career scoring average.
Melo has 7 seasons averaging over 25 ppg while TMac only had 5.
Melo has 8,000 more career points.
Melo has a higher career FG%.
Melo's career high FG% is .492 while McGrady's is only .457.

I'm going to say at their peak they were tied.

But obviously over the long term Melo has proven to be the superior scorer.
Image
The_Hater
RealGM
Posts: 73,217
And1: 26,624
Joined: May 23, 2001
     

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#49 » by The_Hater » Fri Mar 27, 2020 12:49 am

Probably Melo, but peak TMac was better at absolutely everything else and made his teammates better.
AthensBucks wrote:Lowry is done.
Nurse is below average at best.
Masai is overrated.
I dont get how so many people believe in the raptors,they have zero to chance to win it all.


April 14th, 2019.
OfficialRef
Pro Prospect
Posts: 859
And1: 1,178
Joined: May 05, 2014
       

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#50 » by OfficialRef » Fri Mar 27, 2020 2:48 am

Some people seem to think this isn't debatable at all oddly.

Peak Melo was a great scorer and considering longevity he is easily one of the best and atops tmac IMO.

Problem was TMAC had the better peak and when you consider everything other than scoring he blows melo out.
User avatar
ballup
Starter
Posts: 2,448
And1: 1,847
Joined: Dec 08, 2013
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#51 » by ballup » Fri Mar 27, 2020 1:59 pm

This isn't a simple question as it's made to look. Obviously people want to question whether this means peak vs career. I think because we are talking about a specific skillset, it's also within reason to take a specific timeframe ala peak.

Now here's something I don't see being asked. If we are to talk about peaks, then you have to decide between Denver Melo and Knicks Melo because both are very different players and you can't combine the two's strengths. The former being a better inside presence while the latter being a better 3 point shooter.

Sent from my Pixel 3a using Tapatalk
User avatar
Scalabrine
RealGM
Posts: 14,308
And1: 4,511
Joined: Jun 02, 2004
Location: NorCal
     

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#52 » by Scalabrine » Fri Mar 27, 2020 3:01 pm

SWYM wrote:Melo started doing in college and was a GOAT level scorer for nearly 20 years. Stop it...

As a whole, TMac and it's not even close bc Melo is terrible defensively


How does him being terrible defensively make his a worse scorer?
Go Knicks!
User avatar
2Mas
Head Coach
Posts: 7,097
And1: 3,797
Joined: Dec 06, 2011
Location: Long Island, NY
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#53 » by 2Mas » Fri Mar 27, 2020 3:05 pm

Seeing these results are very weird to me.

Better scorer ? Melo.

Better player? McGrady

Better peak? McGrady

McGrady at his peak was a better player than Melo. I think rather easily. But I still think melo was a better scorer.
User avatar
2Mas
Head Coach
Posts: 7,097
And1: 3,797
Joined: Dec 06, 2011
Location: Long Island, NY
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#54 » by 2Mas » Fri Mar 27, 2020 3:19 pm

The_Hater wrote:Probably Melo, but peak TMac was better at absolutely everything else and made his teammates better.

Exactly my thoughts.

Good stuff.
Biff
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,751
And1: 396
Joined: Jun 10, 2007
Contact:
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#55 » by Biff » Fri Mar 27, 2020 3:36 pm

T-Mac's achilles heel was health. Had he been healthy his entire career I think this is a no contest in his favor. However, Melo was able to stay healthier throughout his career and was more reliable on that end because of it.
"Now everybody wanna play for the heat and the Lakers? Let's go back to being competitive and going at these peoples!" - Kevin Durant
og15
Forum Mod - Clippers
Forum Mod - Clippers
Posts: 35,123
And1: 14,609
Joined: Jun 23, 2004
Location: NBA Fan
 

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#56 » by og15 » Fri Mar 27, 2020 3:45 pm

SmashMouthRod wrote:
XTC wrote:
SmashMouthRod wrote:Both were very good scorers but T-Mac was a more well rounded scorer. Mac carried a Magic roster with several lemons to the playoffs several times. Melo for almost his whole career had more talent around him (especially in Denver). Buckets can be easier to get with more talent around. T-Mac was supposed to be paired with Grant Hill but he couldnt get healthy for most that time. So I give the edge to McGrady.


Melo never played next a player as great as Yao, yet in his first season in Houston (before the back injuries) a 25 year old TMac shot 43.6% with a TS% of 52.6

And I disagree about your claim that Tracy was a better all around scorer than Melo who could score inside and out with the best of them, and the efficiency difference backs up my claim.


Yao or T-Mac was barely ever healthy during their tenure. They were only on the same roster for three and a half seasons. Stats dont always tell a true story. Melo as a rookie played with Marcus Camby, Andre Miller, Earl Boykins, and Nene. And in his second season he gained Kenyon Martin as a running mate. T-Mac had been in the league 7 years prior; of which the four before Melo (2000-2003) entered the league Mac averaged 39 minutes a game; dragging a lottery level roster to the playoffs. If were being honest here; Melo wasnt ever good enough to take a roster similar to that Magic team to the playoffs.

Magic 2000-01 Roster

Alexander, Cory (Injured)
Amaechi, John
Armstrong, Darrell
Brown, Dee
DeClercq, Andrew
Doleac, Michael
Garrity, Pat
Hill, Grant (Injured Out for the Season)
Hudson, Troy
McGrady, Tracy
Miller, Mike
Outlaw, Bo
Reid, Don
Williams, Monty

01-02 only added 50 year old Patrick Ewing and Horace Grant to the same roster that still was without Grant Hill. 02-03 The team traded Mike Miller for Drew Gooden and signed Shawn Kemp during his alcohol rehab to play his way back into shape. Grant Hill contributed 29 games. Yet in spite of all this they made the playoffs every year and competed against good teams. Your stats cant dispute that.

I agree that Carmelo had better players for winning games earlier in his career than McGrady had in Orlando, but if we're talking about spacing and offensive support, not really. What Denver mainly had was better defensive players. Now not having enough offensive support will make it hard to get past the first round in the West (East at that time was a different situation), but can win you regular season games.

Andre Miller, Camby, Nene, K-Mart don't make your life easier on offense in that sense. Dre Miller helped him because of his passing, especially his ability to throw lobs, but then made it hard on him because of his lack of outside shooting and lack of second or even really third option scoring ability. The Magic yes also did not have any proper second option, but they had playmakers (Armstrong, improved Hudson in 01-02 and Mike Miller vs Dre Miller, Boykins and Watson). Their issue was more with lack of defensive support players, and Grant Hill's contract of course made it difficult for them to do much improvement.

For example with Denver, I remember the 05-06 season, WC teams were salivating to get Denver in the first round. The Clippers just loaded up on Carmelo and didn't care about anyone else because they weren't big enough threats to make you pay.

Here was their starting lineup:
Andre Miller (82 games)
Greg Buckner (73 games)
Carmelo Anthony (80 games)
Kenyon Martin (56 games)
Marcus Camby (56 games)

Bench: Eduardo Najera (64 games), Earl Boykins (60 games), Ruben Patterson, Reggie Evans, Francisco Elson

In the playoffs though, due to Martin injury (2 games off the bench), the starting lineup was:
Andre Miller
Greg Buckner
Carmelo Anthony
Eduardo Najera
Marcus Camby

That playoff starting lineup is not good offensive support. Drew Gooden as a rookie would have been Denver's second best scorer and one of the better shooters in that starting lineup. So that was not good offensive support at all, that's poor spacing, few scorers on the roster outside of Melo, no second option level player. Also when we take into account injuries, that was 21 year old Melo scoring 26.5 ppg on 48% FG and leading them to 44 wins in the West and into the playoffs.

I see this a lot with roster evaluation on the internet in general, not just this forum, but people are always so focused on how many scorers / shooters players have around them, which yes, it is important, but then they don't think about or give credit for how much defenders and rebounders who can score (or even maybe not so much) but aren't very good shooters or high level scorers can help you win more games than above average and/or one way offensive guys. Also offensive rebounders aren't given credit for their help on offense due to that skill.

Very good defensive guys who can give decent offense even if they don't space so well (guys like a Iguodala, Kenyon Martin, etc) are generally going to help you win more games than if you have even someone like Glenn Robinson scoring 20 ppg next to you, but many people in evaluating teams will downplay the value of those guys as a supporting cast because they don't put up 20+ ppg or shoot specifically well from outside, and suggest having the scorer is a better supporting cast situation.

Denver was a better team than Orlando in Carmelo's early years primarily because they defended well, not because they had any impressive group of offensive players. Really it wasn't until 06/07 when AI came on board that we could say he had a "good" offensive supporting cast and that was helped in 07-08 when JR Smith developed into a solid offensive contributor as well as someone like Klieza. The Denver teams from his rookie season until 05-06 were not really impressive on offense, they won also because they defended well.

Spacing and offensive support wise, the 01-02 and 02-03 Magic were better than the Nuggets from 03-04 to 05-06. Mike Miller missed games in 01-02 and had injury problems, but offensively, the combination of Armstrong, Miller and then Garrity who they used a good amount as a stretch 4 was positive for spacing, but 00-01 they didn't have enough depth of solid offensive contribution, though a guy like Bo Outlaw was very nice to have defensively. 01-02, even with Miller missing about 20 games, the spacing and additional ball handlers and playmakers was quite good with Armstrong, Troy Hudson, Mike Miller and then Garrity as a stretch 4. In 02-03 yes, Mike Miller was traded to bring back Giricek and Gooden, but those guys were both good offensive players, it was again defense that was a big lack. They got a measly 29 games from Grant Hill, better than in the past, but not enough. Armstrong was now getting older and Horace Grant who was older, but still decent was waived 5 games in because of his spat with Doc Rivers, so that hurt them.

Having good offensive support is important to contend, but support needed is always relative to competition. McGrady would have had more regular season and playoff success in the East if they had kept Ben Wallace (obviously Grant Hill was a good decision if he didn't get injured) and had a lineup of Armstrong / McGrady / Miller / Grant / Wallace and then Outlaw and then Garrity off the bench as a stretch 4. Offensively Ben Wallace even helps them due to offensive rebounding (another aspect of offensive help that gets neglected).
User avatar
niQ
RealGM
Posts: 12,528
And1: 23,306
Joined: Jun 14, 2011

Re: Better Scorer: Tracy Mcgrady vs Carmelo Anthony 

Post#57 » by niQ » Fri Mar 27, 2020 4:27 pm

T-MAC
Image
Credits Clutch0z24

Return to The General Board