People were interested in these podcasts

Thoughts on Desmond Bane?

Moderators: cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, ken6199, Domejandro, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid

Godymas
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,420
And1: 4,224
Joined: Feb 27, 2016

Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#1 » by Godymas » Wed Jun 11, 2025 12:42 pm

Desmond Bane is one of the more interesting players in the NBA imo, he's a guy that earned a max extension from Memphis and you can kind of say he's lived up to it.

Some go as far to say he's a top 5 SG in the NBA today, although the position is historically weak and pretty much falls off after the big 3 of Ant/Mitchell/Booker.

With that said, he's clearly been a steal at his draft position, selected 30th overall and traded from Boston to Memphis.

He had to earn minutes in Memphis, the team was very much loaded with depth when he got there. He was fighting for minutes with guys like Grayson Allen, Dillon Brooks, DeAnthony Melton, Tyus Jones, etc.

However, Memphis bought in heavily his second year and he grew to be the true MIP that second year.

His game, it's weird because I feel like he takes a ton of bad shots driving to the rim, but his 3 point shooting is undoubtedly elite, but the bigger issue imo, is he is inconsistent. He always kind of starts off with a bit of a shooting slump, and then builds up into being elite by the end of the year. His size and build are obviously unique for what he is, but he stands at a solid 6'5, he's muscular, can't get bullied, but obviously he has those infamous T-Rex arms.

Last year on the injured Grizzlies, he led them in scoring with almost 24 ppg on solid efficiency, but there's just kind of a lack of something in his game, I'm not sure what it is. I feel like he's the optimized version of what "hard work" does. I don't feel like he has talent to be an All NBA level guy. Maybe he makes an All Star team later on.

Is he good enough to be the #2 on a contending Memphis team? He does fit the archetype of the level of player that has been #2 on a contending team, but obviously the #1 for those champions has been generally a top 5 guy in the NBA, and Ja Morant has not been a top 5 guy in the NBA.

His playoff performances, in the recent years where Memphis was expected to contend, have been kind of disappointing lately. He was great from an efficiency standpoint, when Memphis made the 2nd round a few years ago, but it never feels like he's driving them to win, and I think that's the fundamental issue, is that he won't be the reason a team wins, but he is a big part of what could make a team a winner.
SpreeS
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,689
And1: 4,068
Joined: Jul 26, 2012
 

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#2 » by SpreeS » Wed Jun 11, 2025 1:01 pm

He is in the mix with Bridges and White and they aren't second options on contending teams.
Slimjimzv
Senior
Posts: 664
And1: 874
Joined: Dec 20, 2011
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#3 » by Slimjimzv » Wed Jun 11, 2025 1:37 pm

I think his arms are too short.
Kingdibs19
Starter
Posts: 2,362
And1: 4,454
Joined: Aug 30, 2019

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#4 » by Kingdibs19 » Wed Jun 11, 2025 1:50 pm

Built like a dinosaur
KembaWalker wrote:If you think you need a gun to answer the door, you probably shouldn’t answer the door. Call the police


Re: innocent ex military Roger Fortson gunned down by police at his own house
BAMAFREAK
Rookie
Posts: 1,141
And1: 1,599
Joined: Feb 27, 2017
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#5 » by BAMAFREAK » Wed Jun 11, 2025 2:16 pm

He’s really good offensively. Top 5 3 point shooter in the game and can score at all 3 levels.
Defensively is where he gives us headaches. Obviously he has the length issue, but that’s compounded by the fact that he isn’t very twitchy or quick laterally. Therefore, he gives up a ton of penetration and with Ja at his side, that hurts. In theory, that would be ok with a healthy JJJ and Edey behind him…..but, in my estimation, keeping penetration to a minimum is how you win in today’s NBA.
Look at both OKC and Indy, they have athletes 1-3 who can thwart a lot of would be defense collapsing attempts.
This is why I would be ok trading him. We have Ja and JJJ to carry the offense.
He fits some teams like a glove though, if they have a d minded PG and wing defender at the 3. Orlando, Houston(minus FVV), Chicago would be interesting and a few others
User avatar
Liam_Gallagher
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,523
And1: 6,702
Joined: Nov 05, 2019

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#6 » by Liam_Gallagher » Wed Jun 11, 2025 2:24 pm

He's got a GREAT name.
UglyBugBall
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,819
And1: 1,664
Joined: Sep 04, 2022
 

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#7 » by UglyBugBall » Wed Jun 11, 2025 2:34 pm

Bane was a great pick at 30 and he's def earned his extension. He plays hard, shoots the ball well, and does all the little things you want from a high level role player.

But I agree with you he’s probably not a guy who’s going to swing a playoff series. He’s not someone who takes over games or consistently puts pressure on defenses the way a true number two option should. He can score and space the floor, but he doesn’t create a lot on his own or elevate teammates in a big way.

His shooting is legit, and he plays with confidence, but there’s definitely something missing. It might just be that he lacks that extra gear or burst that top guards usually have. He’s solid and valuable, but not someone you build around or rely on to carry a big load in the playoffs.

If Memphis wants to contend, Bane is a great third piece, but they probably still need a true second star behind Ja.
User avatar
Chuck Everett
RealGM
Posts: 18,786
And1: 21,207
Joined: May 28, 2004
Location: Los Angeles
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#8 » by Chuck Everett » Wed Jun 11, 2025 2:53 pm

He's overpaid because of who he plays with. If Ja and Jackson were actually elite when it matters, his value would be seen more easily. Since they aren't, he gets lost in the shuffle. He would be so good next to Paolo and Franz.
"Kill 'em with Grindness."
User avatar
UcanUwill
RealGM
Posts: 31,883
And1: 34,943
Joined: Aug 07, 2011
 

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#9 » by UcanUwill » Wed Jun 11, 2025 2:56 pm

Slimjimzv wrote:I think his arms are too short.


jacked tho.
User avatar
XTC
General Manager
Posts: 8,487
And1: 8,418
Joined: Nov 09, 2005
 

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#10 » by XTC » Wed Jun 11, 2025 4:20 pm

UcanUwill wrote:
Slimjimzv wrote:I think his arms are too short.


jacked tho.


Swollz***
slicedbread2
Analyst
Posts: 3,628
And1: 2,986
Joined: Jan 23, 2014

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#11 » by slicedbread2 » Wed Jun 11, 2025 6:57 pm

BAMAFREAK wrote:He’s really good offensively. Top 5 3 point shooter in the game and can score at all 3 levels.
Defensively is where he gives us headaches. Obviously he has the length issue, but that’s compounded by the fact that he isn’t very twitchy or quick laterally. Therefore, he gives up a ton of penetration and with Ja at his side, that hurts. In theory, that would be ok with a healthy JJJ and Edey behind him…..but, in my estimation, keeping penetration to a minimum is how you win in today’s NBA.
Look at both OKC and Indy, they have athletes 1-3 who can thwart a lot of would be defense collapsing attempts.
This is why I would be ok trading him. We have Ja and JJJ to carry the offense.
He fits some teams like a glove though, if they have a d minded PG and wing defender at the 3. Orlando, Houston(minus FVV), Chicago would be interesting and a few others


If Memphis were to trade Bane, what would be the asking price?

He'd be a great fit in Orlando and they have all their picks.
BAMAFREAK
Rookie
Posts: 1,141
And1: 1,599
Joined: Feb 27, 2017
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#12 » by BAMAFREAK » Wed Jun 11, 2025 7:23 pm

slicedbread2 wrote:
BAMAFREAK wrote:He’s really good offensively. Top 5 3 point shooter in the game and can score at all 3 levels.
Defensively is where he gives us headaches. Obviously he has the length issue, but that’s compounded by the fact that he isn’t very twitchy or quick laterally. Therefore, he gives up a ton of penetration and with Ja at his side, that hurts. In theory, that would be ok with a healthy JJJ and Edey behind him…..but, in my estimation, keeping penetration to a minimum is how you win in today’s NBA.
Look at both OKC and Indy, they have athletes 1-3 who can thwart a lot of would be defense collapsing attempts.
This is why I would be ok trading him. We have Ja and JJJ to carry the offense.
He fits some teams like a glove though, if they have a d minded PG and wing defender at the 3. Orlando, Houston(minus FVV), Chicago would be interesting and a few others


If Memphis were to trade Bane, what would be the asking price?

He'd be a great fit in Orlando and they have all their picks.


I don’t think we’d be looking for picks, at least not as the centerpiece. It would be more so looking for either an immediate, but different type player contributor, or a somewhat established young player with major potential but a wart or two.
Suggs would fit the former and Jalen Green the latter.
Or two high end role guys that can defend the perimeter. It’s really hard to find something that works for both teams as both the grizzly and trading team would be contending
User avatar
The Laker Kid
General Manager
Posts: 9,470
And1: 6,920
Joined: Dec 16, 2006
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#13 » by The Laker Kid » Wed Jun 11, 2025 7:57 pm

XTC wrote:
UcanUwill wrote:
Slimjimzv wrote:I think his arms are too short.


jacked tho.


Swollz***


He's the NBA's Corgi
MaxwellSmart wrote:I hate to say this, but Go Lakers....
User avatar
Hoop Hunter
Starter
Posts: 2,189
And1: 2,931
Joined: Feb 19, 2002
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#14 » by Hoop Hunter » Thu Jun 12, 2025 12:17 am

He's got really, really short arms.

Edit: I just saw that this is already been posted.

Rumor is he hires a guy to tie his shoes and hold his pee pee for him. He's got really short arms.
“He’s not afraid of the moment, he is The Moment!” — Richard Jefferson on Tyrese Haliburton
QMemphis
Pro Prospect
Posts: 917
And1: 552
Joined: May 22, 2018
     

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#15 » by QMemphis » Thu Jun 12, 2025 12:49 am

Doubt we move Bane now much easier to target a few more 3&D wings like Herb and Naji.
Wallace_Wallace
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,750
And1: 7,104
Joined: Jul 28, 2017
       

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#16 » by Wallace_Wallace » Thu Jun 12, 2025 2:33 am

Hoop Hunter wrote:He's got really, really short arms.

Edit: I just saw that this is already been posted.

Rumor is he hires a guy to tie his shoes and hold his pee pee for him. He's got really short arms.


He didn’t have to hire the guy, he holds them hostage at gun point (with his biceps).
Upperclass
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,801
And1: 2,154
Joined: Aug 09, 2005

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#17 » by Upperclass » Thu Jun 12, 2025 3:09 am

Godymas wrote:Desmond Bane is one of the more interesting players in the NBA imo, he's a guy that earned a max extension from Memphis and you can kind of say he's lived up to it.

Some go as far to say he's a top 5 SG in the NBA today, although the position is historically weak and pretty much falls off after the big 3 of Ant/Mitchell/Booker.

With that said, he's clearly been a steal at his draft position, selected 30th overall and traded from Boston to Memphis.

He had to earn minutes in Memphis, the team was very much loaded with depth when he got there. He was fighting for minutes with guys like Grayson Allen, Dillon Brooks, DeAnthony Melton, Tyus Jones, etc.

However, Memphis bought in heavily his second year and he grew to be the true MIP that second year.

His game, it's weird because I feel like he takes a ton of bad shots driving to the rim, but his 3 point shooting is undoubtedly elite, but the bigger issue imo, is he is inconsistent. He always kind of starts off with a bit of a shooting slump, and then builds up into being elite by the end of the year. His size and build are obviously unique for what he is, but he stands at a solid 6'5, he's muscular, can't get bullied, but obviously he has those infamous T-Rex arms.

Last year on the injured Grizzlies, he led them in scoring with almost 24 ppg on solid efficiency, but there's just kind of a lack of something in his game, I'm not sure what it is. I feel like he's the optimized version of what "hard work" does. I don't feel like he has talent to be an All NBA level guy. Maybe he makes an All Star team later on.

Is he good enough to be the #2 on a contending Memphis team? He does fit the archetype of the level of player that has been #2 on a contending team, but obviously the #1 for those champions has been generally a top 5 guy in the NBA, and Ja Morant has not been a top 5 guy in the NBA.

His playoff performances, in the recent years where Memphis was expected to contend, have been kind of disappointing lately. He was great from an efficiency standpoint, when Memphis made the 2nd round a few years ago, but it never feels like he's driving them to win, and I think that's the fundamental issue, is that he won't be the reason a team wins, but he is a big part of what could make a team a winner.


He should be running point next to a big 2 not a small 1
User avatar
Mrakar
Analyst
Posts: 3,066
And1: 3,867
Joined: Sep 01, 2010

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#18 » by Mrakar » Thu Jun 12, 2025 4:50 am

Problem with player similar to Bane and JJJ is that they are just good enough to get the max contract but they are not impactful enough to justify it. In todays NBA/CBA you are not allowed to have overpayed players in order to contend bcs you need not only stars but also deep team. If they both for example earned 10 mils less(and im talking about JJJs next contract not this one) ppl would have different opinion about them.
That is also a case for people like Sabonis, Fox(lets see what happens in San Antonio), Ingram, Murray, Gobert, ...
User avatar
Potential
RealGM
Posts: 20,549
And1: 45,297
Joined: Feb 28, 2015
   

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#19 » by Potential » Thu Jun 12, 2025 5:09 am

Surprised how great of a shooter he is with these big muscles
Image
User avatar
cupcakesnake
Senior Mod- WNBA
Senior Mod- WNBA
Posts: 15,046
And1: 31,085
Joined: Jul 21, 2016
 

Re: Thoughts on Desmond Bane? 

Post#20 » by cupcakesnake » Thu Jun 12, 2025 11:27 am

I think Bane would look better in a bigger backcourt. Ja is pretty tiny by NBA standards, and the Grizzlies are usually playing a pretty small wing at the 3.

Picture him in Houston, Denver, OKC, Minnesota. I feel that mitigates his weaknesses and lets him shine as pure perimeter fire power.
"Being in my home. I was watching pokemon for 5 hours."

Co-hosting with Harry Garris at The Underhand Freethrow Podcast

Return to The General Board