RealGM

Possibly my last thread b4 the season starts, we shall see - another one in mind
All is healthy and all in prime

No right or wrong answer? Just who would you rather have, using today's game
and style what not.

Chris Webber

- Career Year
27.1, 11.1, 4.2?



Glen BIG DOG Robinson

- Career Year
23.4, 5.5, 3.1?

;t=63s

Shawn Kemp

Career Year
-20.5, 9.5, 2.4?

SlimShady83 wrote:Possibly my last thread b4 the season starts, we shall see - another one in mind
All is healthy and all in prime

No right or wrong answer? Just who would you rather have, using today's game
and style what not.

Chris Webber

- Career Year
20.7, 9.8, 4.2 ?

Watch on YouTube

Glen BIG DOG Robinson

- Career Year
23.4, 5.5, 3.1?

Watch on YouTube

;t=63s

Shawn Kemp

Career Year
-20.5, 9.5, 2.4?

Watch on YouTube

But why for C-Webb you posted his career averages vs the best year for the other two?
Also, going for career stats, C-Webb played the longest here, potentially taking a bigger hit to his stats, thus making his career stats even more impressive.

So the winner for me is C-Webb - I know he wasn't a pioneer in anything, but for my generation his combination of scoring AND facilitating was jaw dropping. And yes, Sabonis existed, but he was in his downhill years already, and wasn't as featured in Blazers offense as C-Webb in Kings'.

BruttoNostra wrote:But why for C-Webb you posted his career averages vs the best year for the other two?
Also, going for career stats, C-Webb played the longest here, potentially taking a bigger hit to his stats, thus making his career stats even more impressive.

Yeh I noticed after posting, my bad. Hopefully fixed with right year

Kemp is the best defender here. Pair him with a playmaker and you're off to the races. He gives you big time rim pressure in the half court and in transition.

Webber can do his own playmaking, but I'm honestly not a fan of his offense overall. He took too many ugly, tough shots, and his passing is a little overrated because he looked so slick doing it. C-Webb couldn't really pass on the move, and when you watch his passing highlights, he's mostly just standing there in the high post waiting for guys to cut. Webber piled up some impressive stats, but we're talking about a negative efficiency scorer.

Both these guys turn into pumpkins by age 30.

Big Dogg Robinson is a very different kind of player who played a different position. I don't think he's quite on their level either way.

I am going with Kemp during his early years
Webber for his Prime
Hypothetical Big Dog at age 32 bringing up a championship on a Khris Middleton type finals run.

I'm going with Kemp. He provides the most two-way ability in my opinion. A lot of people seem to forget or just don't realize how great he was as a defender and rebounder. At his peak (1995-96) he was 2nd in the league in defensive rating, 4th in defensive win shares, and 3rd in total rebounds. And after he left Seattle they dropped from 6th to 10th in overall team defensive rating while Cleveland instantly became the #1 rated defensive unit in the league during his first year with the Cavs. In hindsight, it's pretty egregious that he was never selected for an All-Defensive Team.

prime shawn kemp was fun to watch

Webber. Didn't have to think about it. Different level of player.

<-------

No right or wrong answer but if you didnt pick Webber, youre wrong.

Webber
Kemp



Big dog

None.

They are all in their 50s.

JRoy wrote:None.

They are all in their 50s.

hehe nice try, that's why I said "all is healthy and all in prime"

The Reignman because he has the best dunks with a taunt.

big dogs shot was too pure. guy would be like middleton on roids

Lockdown504090 wrote:big dogs shot was too pure. guy would be like middleton on roids

I went with Glen BIG DOG Robinson, but only because I've always like saying Big Dog, it's like a crime if you never said it lol

Big Dog is the wrong answer.

I chose Webber, but damn Kemp was fun to watch. he may well be a good choice here.

JRoy wrote:None.

They are all in their 50s.

Okay but apparently Kemp can still shoot pretty well

Chris Webber comfortably.

Easily Webber. Passing, defense, scoring, team chemistry.

Kemp was more exciting but not as versatile. Robinson was solid but not a guy that really took his team to new levels.