Dooley wrote:Not better than Wade or West but if you think he's the 5th or 6th best SG of all time, having him around 25-40 is reasonable.
For the people who have Reggie out of the top ~60 or so, do you guys think, like, Adrian Dantley was better than him? Vince Carter? Tony Parker? Who do you have over him?
Challenge accepted

If you consider statistics, accolades & achievement, team success, eye test, and overall impact on the game/league then I would say these players are definitely ahead of Reggie:
PG: Magic, Oscar, West, Curry, Stockton, Isiah, Kidd, Nash, Paul, Westbrook, Cousy, Payton, Frazier
SG: Jordan, Kobe, Wade, Drexler, Harden, Iverson, Gervin, Ray Allen, Sam Jones
SF: Lebron, Bird, Erving, Durant, Baylor, Havlicek, Barry, Kawhi, Arizin, Pierce, Wilkins, Pippen
PF: Tim, Pettit, Malone, Dirk, KG, Barkley, Giannis, Hayes, McHale, Schayes, Rodman
C: Russell, Kareem, Wilt, Shaq, Hakeem, Malone, Robinson, Mikan, Ewing, Mutombo, Reed, Unseld, Cowens, Walton, Jokic, Mourning, Johnston
That's 62 players right there. Now, depending on what you value perhaps you could shave off enough players to get him into the top 50. But its going to be extremely difficult to shave off enough players to get him into the 25-40 range.
And thats not even a definite list. I could name another 20 or so players that Reggie would be in competition with. You still got guys like Bob Lanier and Nate Thurmond. Tony Parker. Manu Ginobili. Chauncey. TMac. Vince. Earl the Pearl. James Worthy. The list goes on and on.