Preliminary RealGM's PC's board All-Time NBA ranking

[Owly]

One thing I will note is that so far glancing at the spreadsheet the "I Thomas" ranked (and so in the graphic) is in at least two instances - and so if not manually adjusted, entirely - the Kings, Suns, Celtics guard.

[Djoker]

A

My Top 30:

1. Bill Russell
2. Michael Jordan
3. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
4. Lebron James
5. Wilt Chamberlain
6. Tim Duncan
7. Magic Johnson
8. Shaquille O'Neal
9. Larry Bird
10. Hakeem Olajuwon
11. Kobe Bryant
12. Stephen Curry
13. Oscar Robertson
14. Jerry West
15. Kevin Durant
16. Karl Malone
17. Moses Malone
18. Julius Erving
19. Kevin Garnett
20. Dirk Nowitzki
21. Dwyane Wade
22. Charles Barkley
23. Bob Pettit
24. David Robinson
25. John Havlicek
26. Steve Nash
27. Isiah Thomas
28. Giannis Antetokounmpo
29. Elgin Baylor
30. Chris Paul

[WestGOAT]

Quick update for those that are curious; included the latest rankings provided in this thread and also from the Google Docsheet, thanks all!

I will make a seperate thread once I figured out a way to also change the marker style per user, like it's been done for colour, so we can distinguish all posters. I was bound to run out of colours, but this is bit more trickier than I expected.

As you might notice some users (G35 and Dino if I recall ) gave LeBron a relatively low rankings, so I provided the rankings based on median or average score below.

Ranking sorted by median score:

Spoiler:

Ranking sorted by average score:

Spoiler:

I don't see my name in the key.

I have to check what happend then, could be a mistake on my side!

Edit: forgot to include , will include in the next update!

One thing I will note is that so far glancing at the spreadsheet the "I Thomas" ranked (and so in the graphic) is in at least two instances - and so if not manually adjusted, entirely - the Kings, Suns, Celtics guard.

Well spotted, now I had to make a manual intervention here.

I was hoping by providing drop-down options in the Google Docsheet that it would prevent spelling mistakes. It definitely did because people for example kept spelling Dwayne Wades name incorrectly, but it couldn't prevent, and here I am making an assumption, that people would mix up the two ITs. I think this it's most likely that the player they had in mind was the 80's and not the most recent one.

[Owly]

One thing I will note is that so far glancing at the spreadsheet the "I Thomas" ranked (and so in the graphic) is in at least two instances - and so if not manually adjusted, entirely - the Kings, Suns, Celtics guard.

Well spotted, now I had to make a manual intervention here.

I was hoping by providing drop-down options in the Google Docsheet that it would prevent spelling mistakes. It definitely did because people for example kept spelling Dwayne Wades name incorrectly, but it couldn't prevent, and here I am making an assumption, that people would mix up the two ITs. I think this it's most likely that the player they had in mind was the 80's and not the most recent one.

That would be my suspicion (hence raising it. If I were confident it were intended there would be nothing to say), though my personal inclination would be not to intervene as

1) at the margins it could be argued that if you do not accurately know the players' names, your expertise is suspect
but mainly
2) like an "innocent until proven guilty" idea, I'd be uncomfortable for an actual intending Isaiah voter to have their intent assumed/interpreted away, for them to have to go back in and say, "No that's what I want" if they want their vote counted (much more than not counting incorrect votes in what transpired to be their intended category). Trying to parse voter intent is a dangerous territory. I might be inclined to think voting LeBron at 23 is unjustifiable, but in a raw master list of votes I couldn't justify assuming it was an error and editing or removing it from the master set of lists.

But that is a personal preference, and this work has been yours.

If voting (options) were not clear enough (and in this instance I think the options provided should be) one option for dropdowns could be to provide their main team in such cases (e.g. Eddie Johnson (Atlanta), Eddie Johnson (KC/Sac, Phoenix, Seattle)[though in that instance position might be clearer) or Clifford Robinson (Portland ...), Cliff Robinson (Cleveland, Washington, Philadelphia) etc).

[dooki667]

See previous topic: viewtopic.php?f=64&t=2260717!

Looking to collect more rankings and will update during the all-star game and also maybe if there is another pre-list topic for the RealGM top 100 thread this year?

Please provide suggestions on the Google Spreadsheet I'm looking to use to collect your rankings:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sWU6bn6R9fd6tFLI_ghiGgOinthUYIJMLXGjdVDff1k/edit?usp=sharing

Also any comments on the visual / discuss the rankings! It seems that Mikan felt like a obliged inclusion for many
Surprised to see Curry so high!



Edit, updated by replacing the missing values with a hypothetical ranking of 32 or lower (since Wade had a vote at #31):

Very late but great work friend. Appreciate the time and effort you put in.