Cavsfansince84 wrote:Doctor MJ wrote:So, I think we need to be clear what we're discussing here - and honestly it's not like I've done a lot with these measurements.
Your thumb is absolutely critical to palming the ball:

So what you really want is a measure of from the tip of your thumb to the tip of your pinky when stretched out
I had been thinking that that's what's meant by "hand width", with "hand length" being a measure from wrist to finger tip, and so if that's correct than hand width is what matters for these purposes.
Are you or others under the impression that these terms refer to something else? If so, what term would you use for the thumb-to-pinky measure?
What I'd say is you might be right about that but that the measurements as given are a bit of a misrepresentation for comparison purposes in terms of how much benefit they have on a bb court and that it goes beyond just palming a ball. It also has to do with length defensively and how much pressure can be exerted with a hand. So idk which exact measurement would be best but I think something like the corner of the hand at the wrist opposite the thumb to the tip of the pointer finger might be one good measure along with tip of the thumb to pinky finger. Then another thing which is sort of independent of hand/finger size is strength. Because that isn't going to be equal based on size either. So that's another part of it. How much pressure fingers can place on a ball or whatever.
Not sure I'm following here.
Hand length certainly helps with things like shotblocking...but it's already baked in to wingspan-type measures. Shotblocking-wise, how much of your arm length is in the hand compared to the fore arm and upper arm doesn't particularly matter there so much as the total length matters.
I agree with you that how much it helps a player varies a great deal. It's a matter of imagination, training, and in-moment improvisation ability. Simply having the physical characteristics won't necessarily help you that much, but much can be done with it with skill development if you have those raw measures.
Re: strength/pressure. This is of course true, and those with hands large enough for it to matter should do training to max out that strength...but I also think that when your hands are big compared to an object you're able to exert opposing forces much better. Think about having a baseball in your hand and holding it tightly. Is someone really going to be able to knock it out of your hand just by slapping it?
Now realistically, I think the basketball is too big to ever get to that point - I've seen guys slap the ball out of Wilt's hand when he uses this sort of move, for example - but what you really want is to have enough grip so that you can maneuver the ball however you want without losing control simply do to slippage.