Rank these years: Lebron, Duncan, KG, Shaq, Curry, Wade, CP3

rebirthoftheM · Post #1 » by **rebirthoftheM** » Mon Jun 3, 2024 6:59 am

Rank the below seasons, briefly stating your criteria while doing so.

2008-2009 Lebron
2009-2010 Lebron
2011-2012 Lebron
2012-2013 Lebron
2015-2016 Lebron

2002-2003 KG
2003-2004 KG
2004-2005 KG

2002-2003 Duncan
2004-2005 Duncan

1999-2000 Shaq
2000-2001 Shaq

2015-2016 Curry
2016-2017 Curry

2007-2008 Chris Paul
2008-2009 Wade

Narigo · Post #2 » by **Narigo** » Tue Jun 4, 2024 1:15 pm

2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

dygaction · Post #3 » by **dygaction** » Thu Jun 6, 2024 8:05 am

Narigo wrote:2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

2006 Curry's 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 05 KG's missing playoff season, really? The only hit for Curry that year was they lost the finals.

wafflzgod · Post #4 » by **wafflzgod** » Fri Jun 7, 2024 4:50 pm

13 Lebron
12 Lebron
09 Lebron
10 Lebron
00 Shaq
01 Shaq
16 Lebron
16 Steph
17 Steph
03 Duncan
04 KG
03 KG
09 Wade
08 CP3
05 Duncan
05 KG

OhayoKD · Post #5 » by **OhayoKD** » Sat Jun 8, 2024 2:00 am

Narigo wrote:2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

wafflzgod wrote:13 Lebron
12 Lebron
09 Lebron
10 Lebron
00 Shaq
01 Shaq
16 Lebron
16 Steph
17 Steph
03 Duncan
04 KG
03 KG
09 Wade
08 CP3
05 Duncan
05 KG

I don't really understand how either Shaq is that high unless you ignore the rs in 2001, the playoffs for 2000, and defense for both. He definitely shouldn't be above Duncan who carried in the rs and got better in the playoffs. 2016 Lebron being below is also a stretch if you put any weight in playoff elevation.

Narigo · Post #6 » by **Narigo** » Mon Jun 10, 2024 3:57 pm

dygaction wrote:
Narigo wrote:2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

2006 Curry's 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 05 KG's missing playoff season, really? The only hit for Curry that year was they lost the finals.

I don't think there wasnt much difference between 04 and 05 version of KG.

I don't blame Garnett for missing the playoffs. His supporting cast was weaker than 04

Narigo · Post #7 » by **Narigo** » Mon Jun 10, 2024 4:02 pm

dygaction wrote:
Narigo wrote:2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

2006 Curry's 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 05 KG's missing playoff season, really? The only hit for Curry that year was they lost the finals.

I don't think there wasnt much difference between 04 and 05 version of KG.

I don't blame Garnett for missing the playoffs in a tough Western conference. His supporting cast was weaker than 04

dygaction · Post #8 » by **dygaction** » Mon Jun 10, 2024 4:03 pm

Narigo wrote:
dygaction wrote:
Narigo wrote:2013 LeBron
2012 LeBron
2009 LeBron
2000 Shaq
2001 Shaq
2003 Duncan
2010 LeBron
2004 KG
2016 LeBron
2005 KG
2003 KG
2016 Curry
2017 Curry
2005 Duncan
2009 Wade
2008 Paul

2006 Curry's 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 05 KG's missing playoff season, really? The only hit for Curry that year was they lost the finals.

I don't think there wasnt much difference between 04 and 05 version of KG.

I don't blame Garnett for missing the playoffs. His supporting cast was weaker than 04

You seems to blame Curry for lots of things to put his 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 04 KG.

Narigo · Post #9 » by **Narigo** » Mon Jun 10, 2024 4:23 pm

dygaction wrote:
Narigo wrote:
dygaction wrote:

2006 Curry's 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 05 KG's missing playoff season, really? The only hit for Curry that year was they lost the finals.

I don't think there wasnt much difference between 04 and 05 version of KG.

I don't blame Garnett for missing the playoffs. His supporting cast was weaker than 04

You seems to blame Curry for lots of things to put his 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 04 KG.

Curry PS run wasn't nearly as good as his RS. He struggled a bit in CF and in the Finals.

Plus 2004 Garnett MVP should have been unanimous as well. There was no one close to him that year

dygaction · Post #10 » by **dygaction** » Mon Jun 10, 2024 5:43 pm

Narigo wrote:
dygaction wrote:
Narigo wrote:

I don't think there wasnt much difference between 04 and 05 version of KG.

I don't blame Garnett for missing the playoffs. His supporting cast was weaker than 04

You seems to blame Curry for lots of things to put his 73 win and unanimous MVP season below 04 KG.

Curry PS run wasn't nearly as good as his RS. He struggled a bit in CF and in the Finals.

Plus 2004 Garnett MVP should have been unanimous as well. There was no one close to him that year

Again, then you punishing Curry for his finals but awarding KG for not having to judge his playoffs because of him missing it in 2005.