bosh or amare?

[tsherkin]

No, no, let's not call the man dumb.

Wrong, surely, but not dumb.

And you are guilty of being incorrect yourself; Amare's mid-range jumper is fantastic, and he has a pretty solid face-up game, too.

[MaryvalesFinest]

Amare definately, his sick dunks make him even more valuable. He was good before Nash even came, he averaged like 20-9. Ever since the Shaq trade he was one of the highest scoring players in the league averaging 30 per game. Bosh is a good player but still would rather have Amare.

[Jase]

Amare > Bosh

The athleticism really puts Stoudemire over the edge here. I'm not saying he is a better player because he has "sick dunks" or anything, but he is much more difficult to defend because of that. Many times in the past two seasons, I have seen him go up for a dunk, get fouled, and still make the shot. The athleticism and strength make him very effective.

[fivas14]

Amare.