Lets say Peak MJ is a 100/100 and 40/100 is the lowest of all time. Rate your top 10 players in the league from here

mdonnelly1989 · Post #1 » by **mdonnelly1989** » Wed Apr 13, 2022 2:21 am

1 point can be the difference between making the all star and not. It can be the difference between making an all 1st team and making the all second team. .05 can be used.

Peak MJ 100

#1. Giannis 96
#2. KD 96
#3. Jokic 95.5
#4. Embiid 95
#5. Luka 95
#6. Curry 94.5
#7. Lebron 94.5

#8. Harden 93
#9. Tatum 92.5
#10. Ja Morant 92.5

When Healthy Kawhi is a 95.5, Lillard 93

falcolombardi · Post #2 » by **falcolombardi** » Wed Apr 13, 2022 3:49 am

100-jordan, lebron
99-kareem, shaq
98-wilt, hakeem, duncan
97-russel,magic, bird
96-curry,jokic, giannis, kobe
95-durant, kawhi
94-harden

somethingg like that?

Jaivl · Post #3 » by **Jaivl** » Wed Apr 13, 2022 7:24 am

Can't I go by VORP? This is adding a layer of confusion for no reason lol

My top 10 would be

Jokic 97
Giannis 96
Embiid 95
KD 94
Curry 94
Luka 92
Tatum 91
LeBron 90
Harden 89
Gobert/Mitchell/KAT 88

more or less

mdonnelly1989 · Post #4 » by **mdonnelly1989** » Wed Apr 13, 2022 9:46 pm

falcolombardi wrote:100-jordan, lebron
99-kareem, shaq
98-wilt, hakeem, duncan
97-russel,magic, bird
96-curry,jokic, giannis, kobe
95-durant, kawhi
94-harden

somethingg like that?

If I were doing it based on All time Peaks

#1. MJ 100

#2. Lebron 99
#3. Shaq 99

#4. Wilt 98.5
#5. Kareem 98.5
#6. Hakeem 98
#7. Bird 98
#8. Bill Russell 97.5
#9. Magic 97.5
#10. Duncan 97
#11. Kobe 96.5
#12. Oscar 96.5
#13. D-Wade 96.5
#14. David Robinson 96.5

#15. Curry 96
#16. KD 96
#17. KG 96
#18. Jerry West 96

#19. T-Mac 95.5
#19. Dr. J 95.5
#20. Bill Walton 95.5

#21. Giannis 95
#22. Barkely 95
#23. Dirk 95
#24. CP3 95
#25. Jokic 95

falcolombardi · Post #5 » by **falcolombardi** » Wed Apr 13, 2022 10:55 pm

Jaivl wrote:Can't I go by VORP? This is adding a layer of confusion for no reason lol

My top 10 would be

Jokic 97
Giannis 96
Embiid 95
KD 94
Curry 94
Luka 92
Tatum 91
LeBron 90
Harden 89
Gobert/Mitchell/KAT 88

more or less

interesting cannot disagree with much there

feyki · Post #6 » by **feyki** » Thu Apr 14, 2022 12:21 pm

Is this including the inflation or need to adjust? %53 TS, %14,5 TOV and %57 TS, %12,5 TOV are totally the two different leagues.

Mazter · Post #7 » by **Mazter** » Thu Apr 14, 2022 1:01 pm

Hmmm, so it's already pre decided that better than Jordan will never ever be possible?
The best peak ever till now can never be 100/100, everthing will eventually be beaten sometime.

Statlanta · Post #8 » by **Statlanta** » Thu Apr 14, 2022 1:07 pm

If the GOAT peak is 100

Then
I'd have Jokic at a 92
Giannis 91
Embiid/Curry 90
Doncic 88
Tatum/LeBron 86
Durant 85
Gobert 84
Paul/Booker 83

Statlanta · Post #9 » by **Statlanta** » Thu Apr 14, 2022 1:10 pm

Mazter wrote:Hmmm, so it's already pre decided that better than Jordan will never ever be possible?
The best peak ever till now can never be 100/100, everthing will eventually be beaten sometime.

Agreed I also think you could replace Jordan for whatever you think the GOAT peak is like maybe Kareem, Shaq or LeBron. There could be a new 100/100 in the near future

ardee · Post #10 » by **ardee** » Fri Apr 15, 2022 8:31 am

Personally I think the GOAT peak is '17 LeBron. I'd put '91 Jordan at 99.

Jokic 98
Giannis 97
Embiid 95
LeBron 95 (I think if he had as good a supporting cast as 2020 he'd still be in contention for best player in the league)
Durant 93
Luka 93
Tatum 92
Curry 92
Towns 89
Paul 88