JLei wrote:I'll start with last point first. Because quite frankly the 2014 Miami Heat on defense were barely the same team. It's what happens when you rely on veterans who become old. Haslem and Battier got to the point where they basically became unplayable. Their defensive ability was a big reason why the Heat's style worked so well. Battier basically retired halfway through the season and Haslem went from nominal starter in 2013 to barely playing really quick. Replacing those minutes with Rashard Lewis and James Jones minutes fundamentally changes what that team was defensively. I'm not going to get into the whole Lebron thing. He was disappointing on defense most of that season (as I noted many times throughout the Lebron threads) while also having like a top 5-6 offensive season of all time.
I think we are disagreeing on certain terms here then. Heat weren't "big", they notedly had tremendous issues with Roy Hibbert. They were long because of all the turnovers they were forcing (4th in opposing TO%). Being everywhere, scrambling and recovering and contesting. You can be smothering and long without being big.
Dwyane Wade's knee injury is really all I have to say about that 2013 playoff run. They were very fortunate to win the championship you are correct. Through the first 18 games of that playoffs he averaged 14pts on 48TS%, he was absolute garbage on both ends. Wade during the win streak was 23-6-6 on 58TS% when they looked unbeatable and through the whole season 21-5-5 on 57TS%. +9.4 on-off in the regular season to a -14.5 on-off in the playoffs.
What do you know he gets his "knee drained" puts up 24-6-4 on 53TS% over the last 4 and they take 3/4 against a team that was beating the pants off the them. Wade's injury was felt across both ends of the court. He was no longer a cutting threat off Lebron and teams just ignored him vs. him having a crazy spacing effect due to his cutting. So along with being unable to make a shot he was also making it super hard for Bron to generate offense. Over that playoffs the best Heat lineup was Bron + bench vs. the regular season where all Bron-Wade lineups merked everything because of their new found chemistry learning how to play off ball with one another. He was also not hyper active defensively. So much of the Heat's defense is based on Wade getting his gigantic wingspan and athleticism in the way of passes. He was amazing at deflecting passes and shrinking the floor when he and Bosh were blitzing.
Without a healthy Wade. That team isn't a world beating team. Wade + peak Bron's chemistry + all that shooting is what made them special. It was a ~40 game peak that you truly had to be watching closely to appreciate on both ends. Normally you wouldn't pay much attention to it. 40 games is only half a season. But they were coming off a Finals in 2011 and then a championship and it felt the culmination of everything that they were building towards.
I just don't see how anyone that was watching that team closely would have anything negatively to say about their defense other than the fact that they got killed by huge centers. They made really good/ star level perimeter players look really bad throughout the entire duration of their run together (see Parker and Ginobili in that Finals, MVP Derrick Rose, James Harden in the 2012 Finals, they made Linsanity look like he didn't belong in the NBA etc.) because of their crazy length and athleticism on the perimieter. Those guys weren't Steph Curry of course (GOAT offensive peak) but they were as well equipped as anyone to play a style that could limit him and Thompson as much as any one.
Going back to my point. Watching the OKC series only reinforces what I think about this hypothetical matchup.
Okay, so the team wasn't "big" but were "long" because they were so damn tenacious, but that went away the very next year because they were an old team. An old team apparently far more tenacious than OKC's tenacious and much higher-reaching teams. I'm skeptical.
What I will say is that I think you're in some ways combining all the Heat teams together. The team wasn't at its most tenacious in '12-13, in fact by relative defensive rating they were worse than they'd been in the prior Heatle years. You're evidently not talking about that Heat team in terms of how they appeared in any post-season, so you're focusing on what they did on their streak and chalking up the return to form afterward as being a fluke of injury. You're welcome to that belief but I don't really feel like arguing about that right now.















