Moderators: Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal, Clyde Frazier
SmartWentCrazy wrote:Who would you rather have for this season alone? Who would you rather have going forward? Personally, I think this question is ridiculous, but a poster on our forum keeps debating elsewise.
Please help settle this debate.
BlackIce wrote:I'm not sure Kaminsky is better then Trevor Booker, let alone Devin Booker.
Darth Celtic wrote:HoopsMalone wrote:If anyone can provide reasoning as to how Devin Booker was more valuable than Frank Kaminsky LAST YEAR, I am all ears. That is an incredibly difficult, if not impossible, claim to substantiate. The gap was seemingly quite large last season.
I will acknowledge that this upcoming season is up for debate as Frank has looked quite bad in preseason. I still find it very unlikely that Booker will surpass him this season.
Long term is anyone's guess, I'm not all that interested in having an in-depth conversation about who will be better five years from now as I think that conversation might detract from the initial premise that Frank was more valuable than Booker LAST SEASON.
Once we have established Frank's position of superiority last year, perhaps we can move to a "who has more future potential" discussion. Again, I believe it is Frank...though I won't rule out the possibility completely that Booker develops into a very good player.
18 to your 1. Are you ready to stop quardrupling down on a dumb statement?
Saberestar wrote:I could understand comparing Kaminsky to TREVOR Booker because of their similar position and role on their teams.....but to DEVIN Booker??
Look at the results from the poll...enough said.
In2ition wrote:Ah, but you haven't been paying attention this year. Booker has upped his defensive game this year too, and is improving almost on a daily basis on that side of the ball. He's not perfect on that end and still makes some mistakes, but is light years ahead of where he was last year. It's easy to parrot what everyone was saying last year. Need to see him now.
In2ition wrote:HoopsMalone wrote:Frank hit a rough patch for a few games no doubt. He started off slow last year and still was better than Booker though.
Clifford has screwed our lineups up completely. Let's see if things get right now with Batum back.
How's this going? Are you still doubling down on this comparison? Has Batum come back yet to help Frank take his game to the next level?
Dr Positivity wrote:Wonder how this thread will look in 2 years...
HoopsMalone wrote:Saberestar wrote:I could understand comparing Kaminsky to TREVOR Booker because of their similar position and role on their teams.....but to DEVIN Booker??
Look at the results from the poll...enough said.
Apparently too much was assumed and not enough was said! Or certainly not heard!
Frank FTW!
HoopsMalone wrote:Don't look now but as of today I am winning the argument!!!