Post#1819 » by Doctor MJ » Mon Mar 28, 2022 7:37 pm
So I'll just say it:
If the Celtics end up with a better record than the Bucks/76ers, with Tatum continuing to play like he has and continuing to rack up massive +/- stats, I don't see any good reason why people should think it obvious that Giannis & Embiid should rank higher on an MVP list than him.
I don't think anyone's crazy for having an ordering of the 3 with Tatum at the bottom, but if you're not even considering it, to me you're really not evaluating Tatum through the same criteria you're looking at Giannis & Embiid, and I think that means you have to go back to the drawing board.
With Giannis in particular - who I'm not at all looking to say I'm skeptical of what he can do - there's been a pretty major change in what his regular season impact has looked like these past two seasons compared to his MVP years that people seem to want to overlook despite the fact that Giannis has been pretty open about not taking the regular season as seriously as he did previously, and the Bucks having a disappointing record compared to what we would expect from an NBA champion at their best.
(Not saying Embiid's necessarily even as strong as Giannis to be clear, but at least in his case this is clearly his best regular season to date.)
Getting ready for the RealGM 100 on the PC Board
Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!