ThaRegul8r wrote:He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
West did lead the Los Angeles Lakers to their first title.
Moderators: trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal, Clyde Frazier, Doctor MJ
ThaRegul8r wrote:He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
Basketballefan wrote:Well i think Peak wise Wade gets the edge, i would say West had the better career though. More quality seasons.penbeast0 wrote:JordansBulls wrote:Comes down to Julius Erving, Dirk Nowitzki, Karl Malone and Dwyane Wade for me.
In what way is Wade better than West?
colts18 wrote:ThaRegul8r wrote:He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
West did lead the Los Angeles Lakers to their first title.
I remember your posts from the RPOY project, you consistently brought it. Please continue to do so, sir. This board needs guys like you to counteract ... worthless posters
Retirement isn’t the end of the road, but just a turn in the road. – Unknown
ThaRegul8r wrote:Mikan had already led the Lakers franchise to a handful of titles before West got there.
ThaRegul8r wrote:colts18 wrote:ThaRegul8r wrote:He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
West did lead the Los Angeles Lakers to their first title.
Mikan had already led the Lakers franchise to a handful of titles before West got there.
Doctor MJ wrote:Basketballefan wrote:Well i think Peak wise Wade gets the edge, i would say West had the better career though. More quality seasons.penbeast0 wrote:
In what way is Wade better than West?
So here's the thing I've been thinking about recently with Wade:
His entire prime as an alpha took place on meh team offenses. Even in the title year of '06 where he went nuclear, he didn't make his team's offense unstoppable, he just kept them afloat while the team won with defense. (Miami beat Dallas with a 101 ORtg in the series, where in the previous round a very injured Phoenix team put 111 ORtg on Dallas, and the Spurs went for 110.)
So there's an issue I think in how people tend to perceive Wade:
When an alpha wins a title, it's like he becomes a "made man". People don't question him. He's "proven" he can do what every star is ideally able to do.
However if you're an offensive star who wins a title with a team that won because of its defense, all you've proven is that is that if you build a great defensive team this offensive star is good enough to pull you to mediocrity on the weak side of the ball.
This is a criticism that's not new around the PC board. It gets brought up with Isiah and with AI and we tend to focus on efficiency issues. Very understandable of course, and Wade has good efficiency so it's all good, right?
I'm not so sure. He always had a simplistic game, succeeding in spite of the fact that he's quite a bit worse at shooting than other superstar guards. And of course his inability to shoot well has everything to do with why it took such innovative thinking for Miami to fully blossom with the Heatles. Wade's clearly not build to be a second option (he's not horrible, but he's not as good as his alpha talent would typically yield), but even as a first option, do we see him as a guy who would let you simply built to elite team offense?
West by contrast? Short of you utterly in disbelief when people call him a great talent, I don't see how there's any doubt as to whether he could lead a great offense. He basically lived in good offenses, working sometimes as a second option, and working sometimes as more of a point guard than a shooting guard. He seems to have taken to the Princeton like a boss as well. His playmaking and his shooting let him have a much more diverse game that's not nearly so predictable.
RebelWithACause wrote:ThaRegul8r wrote:colts18 wrote:West did lead the Los Angeles Lakers to their first title.
Mikan had already led the Lakers franchise to a handful of titles before West got there.
Colts focused on the bolded, Mikan led the Minneapolis Lakers. Same franchise, different cities.
ThaRegul8r wrote:penbeast0 wrote:JordansBulls wrote:Comes down to Julius Erving, Dirk Nowitzki, Karl Malone and Dwyane Wade for me.
In what way is Wade better than West?
He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
I remember your posts from the RPOY project, you consistently brought it. Please continue to do so, sir. This board needs guys like you to counteract ... worthless posters
Retirement isn’t the end of the road, but just a turn in the road. – Unknown
Doctor MJ wrote:Basketballefan wrote:Well i think Peak wise Wade gets the edge, i would say West had the better career though. More quality seasons.penbeast0 wrote:
In what way is Wade better than West?
So here's the thing I've been thinking about recently with Wade:
His entire prime as an alpha took place on meh team offenses. Even in the title year of '06 where he went nuclear, he didn't make his team's offense unstoppable, he just kept them afloat while the team won with defense. (Miami beat Dallas with a 101 ORtg in the series, where in the previous round a very injured Phoenix team put 111 ORtg on Dallas, and the Spurs went for 110.)
RebelWithACause wrote:Alpha years as in 2009 and 2010?
Basketballefan wrote:You act as if Wade had a lot of good offensive players around him in his prime...that 06 title team had Shaq and Antonie Walker as their 2nd and 3rd leading scorers, and when the finals rolled around he completely carried them on the offensive end their 2nd leading scorer wasn't even getting 15 ppg.
Basketballefan wrote:...
I'm not at all advocating Wade for this spot, but i feel your assessment is disrespect and really underrating him and his abilities. Nobody's claiming him to be Nash or LBJ on offense.
HomoSapien wrote:Warspite, the greatest poster in the history of realgm.
Warspite wrote:Only DrJ and Hakeem are top 20 all time in blocks and steals.
Doctor MJ wrote:I'll refrain from voting at this point, but I'll give my thoughts at the moment:
Jerry West is the guy I'm sort of in love with. Right now. To me he seems like a guy on the low end of the top tier of offensive GOAT contenders and so far as I can tell a legit defensive force. I have him ahead of Oscar on my list. I find him most impressive...but there is a longevity issue to consider, particularly relative to...
Karl Malone. I really don't know if I can put West over Malone.
8. The only thing of relevance is how a player helps his team win, which means the player in question’s performance will be evaluated. If that player has a poor performance and another player picks up the slack to help his team win, then that player receives no bonus for his teammate bailing him out. Conversely, just as a doctor can try to the best of his ability to help keep a patient alive but fail, so can a player try to the best of his ability to help his team win but ultimately fail. His individual performance will be assessed, and if he didn’t help his team lose, he will incur no penalty. However, if he was instrumental in his own team’s defeat, he will be penalized accordingly.
11. A player does not cease to help his team win after passing his peak/prime. He may not be able to make as large a contribution as he formerly did due to age, but continuing to contribute to team wins to the extent one is able is still valuable to the team he plays for and helps the team obtain the ultimate objective. A player’s career consists of more than just his peak, as he won’t be at his peak for his entire career. Only seasons in which a player helped his team win will be considered in the overall evaluation.
10. The object of the game is to help your team win. In lieu of actually achieving that objective, helping your team get as close to it as possible. Helping your team get to the semifinals > losing in the opening round; helping your team get to the conference finals > losing in the semifinals; helping your team get to the Finals > losing in the conference finals. Getting closer to the ultimate goal of winning is always a positive. Finishing farther away from it is always a negative. Helping your team get to the Finals but losing is always better than losing in an earlier round.
I remember your posts from the RPOY project, you consistently brought it. Please continue to do so, sir. This board needs guys like you to counteract ... worthless posters
Retirement isn’t the end of the road, but just a turn in the road. – Unknown
Doctor MJ wrote:
What I'm saying is that Wade actually hasn't directly shown us that much. He's shown us that he can will a team's offense from bad to mediocre, which is great, but it's not the same as leading stellar team offense, and I find myself wondering if he's a guy more ideally suited to the former than the latter. This is not simply due to the fact he hasn't shown it, but also due to the fact that this is something we tend to see from volume scorers.
ThaRegul8r wrote:colts18 wrote:ThaRegul8r wrote:He led a team that never won anything before to a title.
Duh.
West did lead the Los Angeles Lakers to their first title.
Mikan had already led the Lakers franchise to a handful of titles before West got there.
RayBan-Sematra wrote:RayBan-Sematra wrote:[...]
Regarding West defensively.
I am thinking that West was one of the greatest help defenders ever at the guard position.
He had underrated athletic ability combined with ultra long arms and amazing timing.
Even at age 35 while only playing 30mpg he averaged nearly 3spg/1bpg.
He was probably a lock for 3+spg / 1+bpg in his actual Prime.
I think Jerry is clearly the best candidate for this spot.
He was a better scorer and playmaker then Erving and while I am high on Erving's defensive ability West was no pushover on that end.
ThaRegul8r wrote:“What people don’t realize is that Jerry was one of the greatest defensive guards ever,” Red Auerbach said (Terry Pluto, Tall Tales: The Glory Years of the NBA, in the Words of the Men Who Played, Coached, and Built Pro Basketball, p. 191). The NBA All-Defensive Teams didn’t exist until West’s ninth season in the league, but in the six years that he played, he was a four-time First Team selection (1970-73) and one-time Second Team selection (1969).
“His offense is so great that people sometimes overlook the other things he does for his team,” Wilt Chamberlain said of West. “By his mere presence he creates so many mismatches. He has such quick hands that he is always a threat to steal the ball. I don’t think Jerry is as great on one-on-one. You know where he has to guard a guy one-on-one. Like maybe Howard Komives. But what Jerry is able to do is play his man tough enough and then when the man passes off, he’s able to anticipate the pass and steal the ball as quick as anyone in the league. He’s just a good all-around basketball player and I don’t think there’s anyone better” (Williamson Daily News, Jan 6, 1971).
“I wish they had kept track of steals when Jerry and I played because we would have been the league leaders,” Lenny Wilkens said. “He had hands that were as quick as a snake’s tongue” (Terry Pluto, Tall Tales, p. 191). Steals weren’t kept until the 1973-74 season—West’s last in the league, but in the first year they were recorded, West had 10 steals in a game Dec. 7, 1973 in a 115-111 loss to Seattle to set a single-game record. Feb. 3, 1974, West had 19 points, 14 rebounds, 10 assists and seven steals in a 124-91 win over Portland. In the 1973-74 season, West had 81 steals in 31 games (2.62 spg), in 967 minutes at 35 years old. His steal percentage was 3.6, and his block percentage 1.1.
In Game 3 of the 1962 NBA Finals against the Boston Celtics, West stole Sam Jones’ in-bounds pass to Bob Cousy at midcourt with three seconds left and scored on a layup to give the Lakers a 117-115 win. In Game 2 of the 1963 Western Division Finals against the St. Louis Hawks, West “stole a Hawk pass in the dying seconds […], dribbled into scoring range and swished the ball for the deciding basket” (Gettysburg Times, Apr 2 1963) for a 101-99 win. Jan. 17, 1968, West had seven rebounds, 10 assists and 12 steals. Nov. 9, 1968, West had 29 points and nine steals as the Lakers beat the Celtics 116-106 for their ninth straight victory. Dec. 6, 1968, West had eight steals in a 99-94 win over Atlanta. In Game 6 of the 1970 Western Division Semifinals against the Phoenix Suns, West scored a game-high 35 points “and was credited with an unofficial 12 steals defensively” (Ocala Star Banner, Apr 8, 1970) in a 104-93 Laker win which tied the series at 3-3 after being down 3-1. Nov. 11, 1970, West had 26 points, 11 assists and nine steals in a 149-124 win over Seattle. Dec. 13, 1971, West had 23 points, 15 assists and seven steals in a 129-114 win over Portland for the Lakers’ 22nd consecutive win. In the 1972 All Star Game, West had 13 points on 6-for-9 shooting—seven in the fourth quarter, six rebounds, five assists and six steals in 27 minutes and hit the game-winning 21-footer over Walt Frazier for a 112-110 West win. Jan. 23, 1972, West “scored 37 points, made at least nine steals, hit 15 of 26 shots, passed off for 13 assists and generated sparks in a sizzling fast break” in a 118-105 win over Milwaukee. Nov. 11, 1972, West had 27 points, 10 assists and 10 steals in only three quarters in a 118-88 win over Cleveland.Jerry West Nips Hawks In Clutch
ATLANTA (AP) — “They don’t call Jerry West ‘Mister Clutch’ for nothing,” said Los Angeles Coach Bill Sharman after the veteran guard sparked the Lakers to a last-minute 102-100 National Basketball Association victory over the Atlanta Hawks.
A steal by West from the Hawks’ Pete Maravich in the closing minutes, sealed the Lakers’ victory Sunday afternoon before a crowd of 8,478 at the Omni and a national television audience.
West, incidentally, led the Lakers with 37 points. Maravich had 28 for the Hawks.
“People keep saying he’s going to slow down,” Sharman said of West. “But he doesn’t. That steal from Maravich decided the game.”
Until that point, the Hawks only trailed by a point at 95-94. Then West went into his act and the Lakers had a 99-94 edge and eventually the game.
“In close games, West seems to take over,” said Sharman of his 34-year-old backcourt ace.
(Waycross Journal-Herald, Jan 15, 1973.
http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=HQ ... 12,1356092)
Mar. 2, 1973, Lakers’ coach Bill Sharman said, “Jerry West is the greatest defensive guard who’s ever played in the NBA” after West had 19 points, eight assists and nine steals in 33 minutes after coming back from a 10-game injury hiatus to lead the Lakers to a 108-88 win over Chicago. Mar. 25, 1973, West had six steals in the third quarter and blocked a shot by Spencer Haywood as the Lakers went from a 47-43 halftime lead to a 79-63 lead after three, in a 109-93 win over Seattle. Seattle coach Bucky Buckwaiter said, “when Jerry West dies, they ought to cut off his hands and bronze them.”Bill Sharman wrote:Although they didn’t keep track of the stats as they do today, I would say that Jerry West blocked more shots and had more steals than any guard who ever played in the NBA. He had those long arms and great quickness that was very deceptive until he stole the ball from you a few times. […] He is one of the very few players that was a true superstar on offense and defense. There are only a couple of other players in the history of the league that you can say that about at both ends of the court. Many are superstars at one end, but not both.
“West’s size is deceiving,” wrote Phil Elderkin. “While he is only 6ft. 3in. and 185 pounds, his arm span from fingertip to fingertip is 81 inches. He has the reach of a man 6-7 or 6-8.” “Red used to say that you don’t judge a player by only his height, you need to consider the length of his arms,” John Havlicek said. “Jerry had something like a 39-inch sleeve. He was 6-foot-2, but he had the arms of a man 6-foot-7. That made him so tough when he guarded you. He could use those long arms to poke away your dribble, I mean really pick your pocket” (Terry Pluto, Tall Tales, p. 191).
“Coach John Kerr of the Bulls proved he knows whereof he speaks before last night’s game when he was asked for an opinion on West’s switch to guard Robinson. ‘He is the best defensive guard in the league,’ Kerr said” (Robert Logan, “Lakers Deals Bulls 3D Playoff Loss: West Stops Robinson in 93-87 Victory.” Chicago Tribune, Mar 30, 1968). In an ESPN SportsNation Chat with Sam Jones, Jones said: “I think the best player that I had play defense against me was Jerry West. He had long arms and you knew he was going to have a lot of points. When you played against him, you had to bring it offensively and defensively.”
“Jerry was so methodical,” John Vanak said. “He wore you out with his jump shot, his relentless defense, and unlike a lot of guards, he had enough guts to go under the basket for rebounds” (Terry Pluto, Tall Tales, p. 191).
I remember your posts from the RPOY project, you consistently brought it. Please continue to do so, sir. This board needs guys like you to counteract ... worthless posters
Retirement isn’t the end of the road, but just a turn in the road. – Unknown
Chuck Texas wrote:You are actually making a great case for Dirk here in place of Moses because Dirk was a terrific defensive rebounder which is more valuable and he always got back on defense which is a large part of a guy who to the eye test isn't as impressively defensively as some other guys always rates well in +/- and RAPM.
ThaRegul8r wrote:...