David Robinson or Kevin Garnett?

Moderators: Clyde Frazier, Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal

ardee
RealGM
Posts: 15,320
And1: 5,397
Joined: Nov 16, 2011

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#21 » by ardee » Wed May 1, 2019 8:32 pm

G35 wrote:
SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:I think David Robinson was better. I like Robinson's peak better than Tim Duncan's peak.

Where I think young peak Robinson fails is leadership. If my team was full of emotionally immature players then I think KG might get more out of the team.



People seem to only consider Garnett when he was with the Celtics and not how he was when he was with Minnesota, arguably his best years.

Garnett was not much of a leader, imo. I think he was very immature and fought with teammates all the time. His "intensity" is not always the the ideal way to lead men:

- Garnett punching out Rick Rickert
http://www.startribune.com/rick-rickert-talks-about-the-time-kevin-garnett-punched-him/320963661/

We still don’t exactly know, but thanks to a D-League Diary interview with Rickert that was published today we at least have a more complete and honest picture of what happened from his perspective. Said Rickert in that interview:

“I was a rookie proving myself and going in there and giving it my all. He was the reigning MVP at the time and I was going in there and not holding back and I was playing well and for whatever reason he didn’t like that. Maybe I hit a jumper on him but he sucker punched me. All I can think of is I was playing better than he expected and he didn’t like that I was playing so well against him. Growing up he was a guy I looked at and thought was a good player, so going into playing against him I wouldn’t back down from a challenge. I guess he didn’t like that.”



- Garnett and Wally Z
https://www.cbc.ca/sports/basketball/garnett-szczerbiak-scuffle-after-practice-1.234602

Billups, who teamed with Garnett in Minnesota from 2000 to '02, says one of his most vivid memories of Garnett is from a Timberwolves shootaround in which Saunders tried to familiarize the team with its next opponent. The coach attempted to run through that team's offensive sets for the starters but was thwarted by Garnett, who refused to stop denying his player the ball during the walk-through. "I warned KG," Billups says. "I told him, 'You keep yelling this s--- at people and someone is going to come back at you.'"

That guy, Billups says, was former Wolves teammate Wally Szczerbiak. "I got along with Wally just fine, but he was kind of a know-it-all," Billups says. "I took his arrogance to be a positive all players gotta have, but KG took it a different way. It was KG's team, his voice, his show, his everything. Anyone who differed was going to be an outcast."

The tension boiled over during a November 2000 practice, when Szczerbiak reportedly got picked off and chided Garnett to call out the screens. KG responded curtly, "Play some defense," the pickoff seemingly a consequence for whatever expectation Szczerbiak wasn't meeting defensively. Szczerbiak took exception. It accelerated into a shouting match, which spilled into the training room. Punches were thrown. Ask Szczerbiak about it today and he says he was simply a young player trying to stick up for himself. "I felt like I had some leadership qualities," he says. "I'm not a guy who will take a back seat all the time, and in certain scenarios I'm going to speak up for what's right. At times it definitely got me in trouble."



- Garnett and Ray Allen
https://celticswire.usatoday.com/2018/03/12/boston-celtics-big-three-ray-allen-paints-picture-of-relationship-with-kevin-garnett-as-tenuous-from-the-start/

Deveney highlighted a number of interesting story lines from the book in a recent article, including several excerpts that suggest Allen’s notoriously icy relationship with Kevin Garnett may have been strained from the very start.

Allen recalled dribbling in front of his locker during the Celtics’ preseason trip to Rome in 2007, which was something Allen had done to prepare for games his entire career. The dribbling annoyed Garnett, though, who told Allen, “No, you’re not going to do that.”

“No,” Garnett said, “I tip way better than him, so you better give me the check.” It was the first time they’d gone to dinner together, and Allen pointed out that Garnett had no idea how much Allen tipped. “There was no point in arguing with the guy,” Allen writes. “What struck me was that he felt the need to be seen as being superior to me, even in something as petty as this.”



Garnett and Joakim Noah
https://chicago.suntimes.com/sports/joakim-noahs-hatred-for-kevin-garnett-started-when-he-was-a-rookie/

Garnett’s former teammate Paul Pierce said the first time Noah met Garnett on the basketball court, the very intense Garnett rubbed the then-rookie Noah the wrong way.

One time, he asked [Joakim] Noah if he could rub through his hair, like a female or something.…And I know that kind of made [Noah] hot. And this was when Noah was a rookie, too. I remember Noah looked up to KG. He was like, ‘Man, KG, I had your poster on my wall, I looked up to you, man.’ And then [Garnett] just said something like that, and was like ‘F— you, Noah.’ I was like, ‘Whoa.’ This kid fresh out of college, looks up to KG, just said he had his poster on the wall, and he tells him that! It crushed him. It crushed Noah.



Garnett and Tim Duncan
https://www.complex.com/sports/2016/09/meanest-things-kevin-garnett-ever-said/mothers-day

The Timberwolves faced the Spurs at the Alamodome for a first round playoff game on May 9, 1999. At some point during that game, Garnett told Duncan “Happy Mother’s Day, M***********” as the Spurs legend lined up for a free throw.

Duncan’s mother passed away of breast cancer, one day before Tim’s 14th birthday in 1990.

While this incident has never been confirmed, what is confirmed is that Duncan hates Garnett, according to a 2012 Sports Illustrated profile:

“In fact, Duncan hates Kevin Garnett. Hates him the way liberals hate Sean Hannity. This information comes from very reliable sources, who talk about how KG has made a career of trying to punk Duncan, baiting him and slapping him and whispering really weird smack into his ear. They talk about how funny this is, because the worst thing you can do as an opponent is piss off Duncan. Then, as Malik Rose says, "he f------ destroys you." Duncan's lifetime numbers versus Garnett's teams, by the way: 19.4 points per game, 11.6 boards and a 44-17 record, including the postseason.
Duncan is diplomatic about the topic. Asked if perhaps all those years battling Garnett have softened his feelings for the man, led to a Magic-Larry type of kinship, Duncan leans back on the couch in his hotel room and grins. There is a pause. A longer pause. Finally he says, "Define kinship.”



I can go all day with the fights KG has had with teammates and opponents. That's great that he has intensity and is very competitive, I like that in a player. But leadership is not getting into fights, micromanaging, and dictating.

KG fans always want to go to the stats or talk about intensity and that is why he and Tim Duncan are on the same level...that if KG and Duncan reversed situations KG would have 5 rings and Duncan might have none. That all KG needed was Pop, Manu, and Parker.

There is no chance in HELL that KG is ever the leader that Duncan or even Robinson were for the Spurs. Robinson mentored Duncan and they got along great. DRob is very underrated in how he handled Tim being drafted and passing the torch to him in his rookie season.

Robinson is a better all around player than KG, a better defender than KG, a better leader than KG, carried his teams better than KG and has better stats than KG. In 1995, Robinson's teammates were not even as good as KG's teammates in 2004. Cassell would be the best teammate Robinson ever had on the Spurs.

KG is so overrated its comical now......
I knew about the Duncan and Noah story but not the others. Man, screw KG. What an absolute nightmare of a human being. Shame Pierce and Ray saved his choking butt in the Finals and got him that ring, someone with his attitude doesn't deserve one.

Sent from my SM-G615F using RealGM mobile app
SinceGatlingWasARookie
RealGM
Posts: 11,712
And1: 2,760
Joined: Aug 25, 2005
Location: Northern California

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#22 » by SinceGatlingWasARookie » Thu May 2, 2019 2:46 am

G35 wrote:
SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:I think David Robinson was better. I like Robinson's peak better than Tim Duncan's peak.

Where I think young peak Robinson fails is leadership. If my team was full of emotionally immature players then I think KG might get more out of the team.



People seem to only consider Garnett when he was with the Celtics and not how he was when he was with Minnesota, arguably his best years.

Garnett was not much of a leader, imo. I think he was very immature and fought with teammates all the time. His "intensity" is not always the the ideal way to lead men:

- Garnett punching out Rick Rickert
http://www.startribune.com/rick-rickert-talks-about-the-time-kevin-garnett-punched-him/320963661/

We still don’t exactly know, but thanks to a D-League Diary interview with Rickert that was published today we at least have a more complete and honest picture of what happened from his perspective. Said Rickert in that interview:

“I was a rookie proving myself and going in there and giving it my all. He was the reigning MVP at the time and I was going in there and not holding back and I was playing well and for whatever reason he didn’t like that. Maybe I hit a jumper on him but he sucker punched me. All I can think of is I was playing better than he expected and he didn’t like that I was playing so well against him. Growing up he was a guy I looked at and thought was a good player, so going into playing against him I wouldn’t back down from a challenge. I guess he didn’t like that.”



- Garnett and Wally Z
https://www.cbc.ca/sports/basketball/garnett-szczerbiak-scuffle-after-practice-1.234602

Billups, who teamed with Garnett in Minnesota from 2000 to '02, says one of his most vivid memories of Garnett is from a Timberwolves shootaround in which Saunders tried to familiarize the team with its next opponent. The coach attempted to run through that team's offensive sets for the starters but was thwarted by Garnett, who refused to stop denying his player the ball during the walk-through. "I warned KG," Billups says. "I told him, 'You keep yelling this s--- at people and someone is going to come back at you.'"

That guy, Billups says, was former Wolves teammate Wally Szczerbiak. "I got along with Wally just fine, but he was kind of a know-it-all," Billups says. "I took his arrogance to be a positive all players gotta have, but KG took it a different way. It was KG's team, his voice, his show, his everything. Anyone who differed was going to be an outcast."

The tension boiled over during a November 2000 practice, when Szczerbiak reportedly got picked off and chided Garnett to call out the screens. KG responded curtly, "Play some defense," the pickoff seemingly a consequence for whatever expectation Szczerbiak wasn't meeting defensively. Szczerbiak took exception. It accelerated into a shouting match, which spilled into the training room. Punches were thrown. Ask Szczerbiak about it today and he says he was simply a young player trying to stick up for himself. "I felt like I had some leadership qualities," he says. "I'm not a guy who will take a back seat all the time, and in certain scenarios I'm going to speak up for what's right. At times it definitely got me in trouble."



- Garnett and Ray Allen
https://celticswire.usatoday.com/2018/03/12/boston-celtics-big-three-ray-allen-paints-picture-of-relationship-with-kevin-garnett-as-tenuous-from-the-start/

Deveney highlighted a number of interesting story lines from the book in a recent article, including several excerpts that suggest Allen’s notoriously icy relationship with Kevin Garnett may have been strained from the very start.

Allen recalled dribbling in front of his locker during the Celtics’ preseason trip to Rome in 2007, which was something Allen had done to prepare for games his entire career. The dribbling annoyed Garnett, though, who told Allen, “No, you’re not going to do that.”

“No,” Garnett said, “I tip way better than him, so you better give me the check.” It was the first time they’d gone to dinner together, and Allen pointed out that Garnett had no idea how much Allen tipped. “There was no point in arguing with the guy,” Allen writes. “What struck me was that he felt the need to be seen as being superior to me, even in something as petty as this.”



Garnett and Joakim Noah
https://chicago.suntimes.com/sports/joakim-noahs-hatred-for-kevin-garnett-started-when-he-was-a-rookie/

Garnett’s former teammate Paul Pierce said the first time Noah met Garnett on the basketball court, the very intense Garnett rubbed the then-rookie Noah the wrong way.

One time, he asked [Joakim] Noah if he could rub through his hair, like a female or something.…And I know that kind of made [Noah] hot. And this was when Noah was a rookie, too. I remember Noah looked up to KG. He was like, ‘Man, KG, I had your poster on my wall, I looked up to you, man.’ And then [Garnett] just said something like that, and was like ‘F— you, Noah.’ I was like, ‘Whoa.’ This kid fresh out of college, looks up to KG, just said he had his poster on the wall, and he tells him that! It crushed him. It crushed Noah.



Garnett and Tim Duncan
https://www.complex.com/sports/2016/09/meanest-things-kevin-garnett-ever-said/mothers-day

The Timberwolves faced the Spurs at the Alamodome for a first round playoff game on May 9, 1999. At some point during that game, Garnett told Duncan “Happy Mother’s Day, M***********” as the Spurs legend lined up for a free throw.

Duncan’s mother passed away of breast cancer, one day before Tim’s 14th birthday in 1990.

While this incident has never been confirmed, what is confirmed is that Duncan hates Garnett, according to a 2012 Sports Illustrated profile:

“In fact, Duncan hates Kevin Garnett. Hates him the way liberals hate Sean Hannity. This information comes from very reliable sources, who talk about how KG has made a career of trying to punk Duncan, baiting him and slapping him and whispering really weird smack into his ear. They talk about how funny this is, because the worst thing you can do as an opponent is piss off Duncan. Then, as Malik Rose says, "he f------ destroys you." Duncan's lifetime numbers versus Garnett's teams, by the way: 19.4 points per game, 11.6 boards and a 44-17 record, including the postseason.
Duncan is diplomatic about the topic. Asked if perhaps all those years battling Garnett have softened his feelings for the man, led to a Magic-Larry type of kinship, Duncan leans back on the couch in his hotel room and grins. There is a pause. A longer pause. Finally he says, "Define kinship.”



I can go all day with the fights KG has had with teammates and opponents. That's great that he has intensity and is very competitive, I like that in a player. But leadership is not getting into fights, micromanaging, and dictating.

KG fans always want to go to the stats or talk about intensity and that is why he and Tim Duncan are on the same level...that if KG and Duncan reversed situations KG would have 5 rings and Duncan might have none. That all KG needed was Pop, Manu, and Parker.

There is no chance in HELL that KG is ever the leader that Duncan or even Robinson were for the Spurs. Robinson mentored Duncan and they got along great. DRob is very underrated in how he handled Tim being drafted and passing the torch to him in his rookie season.

Robinson is a better all around player than KG, a better defender than KG, a better leader than KG, carried his teams better than KG and has better stats than KG. In 1995, Robinson's teammates were not even as good as KG's teammates in 2004. Cassell would be the best teammate Robinson ever had on the Spurs.

KG is so overrated its comical now......


You have made your point about KG's leadership. It sounds bad. Since I was finding fault with young Robinson's ability to lead I have to compare him to young KG. I did not know enough about Young KG's baggage.

I can't say anything about old Robinson's leadership which probably means it was good leadership. Pop and Duncan got all the credit for a team that had it's act together. Robinson, Malik Rose and Avery Johnson probably deserve more credit.
User avatar
oldschooled
Veteran
Posts: 2,800
And1: 2,712
Joined: Nov 17, 2012
 

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#23 » by oldschooled » Thu May 2, 2019 7:59 am

Only argument KG has over DRob is longevity imo. Peak, prime, impact-wise (we have data for DRob and he's always battling Jordan at the top), defense, DRob is just better.
Frank Dux wrote:
LeChosen One wrote:Doc is right. The Warriors shouldn't get any respect unless they repeat to be honest.


According to your logic, Tim Duncan doesn't deserve any respect.
User avatar
Zeitgeister
General Manager
Posts: 8,800
And1: 7,617
Joined: Nov 11, 2008
   

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#24 » by Zeitgeister » Thu May 2, 2019 8:47 am

SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:
G35 wrote:
SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:I think David Robinson was better. I like Robinson's peak better than Tim Duncan's peak.

Where I think young peak Robinson fails is leadership. If my team was full of emotionally immature players then I think KG might get more out of the team.



People seem to only consider Garnett when he was with the Celtics and not how he was when he was with Minnesota, arguably his best years.

Garnett was not much of a leader, imo. I think he was very immature and fought with teammates all the time. His "intensity" is not always the the ideal way to lead men:

- Garnett punching out Rick Rickert
http://www.startribune.com/rick-rickert-talks-about-the-time-kevin-garnett-punched-him/320963661/

We still don’t exactly know, but thanks to a D-League Diary interview with Rickert that was published today we at least have a more complete and honest picture of what happened from his perspective. Said Rickert in that interview:

“I was a rookie proving myself and going in there and giving it my all. He was the reigning MVP at the time and I was going in there and not holding back and I was playing well and for whatever reason he didn’t like that. Maybe I hit a jumper on him but he sucker punched me. All I can think of is I was playing better than he expected and he didn’t like that I was playing so well against him. Growing up he was a guy I looked at and thought was a good player, so going into playing against him I wouldn’t back down from a challenge. I guess he didn’t like that.”



- Garnett and Wally Z
https://www.cbc.ca/sports/basketball/garnett-szczerbiak-scuffle-after-practice-1.234602

Billups, who teamed with Garnett in Minnesota from 2000 to '02, says one of his most vivid memories of Garnett is from a Timberwolves shootaround in which Saunders tried to familiarize the team with its next opponent. The coach attempted to run through that team's offensive sets for the starters but was thwarted by Garnett, who refused to stop denying his player the ball during the walk-through. "I warned KG," Billups says. "I told him, 'You keep yelling this s--- at people and someone is going to come back at you.'"

That guy, Billups says, was former Wolves teammate Wally Szczerbiak. "I got along with Wally just fine, but he was kind of a know-it-all," Billups says. "I took his arrogance to be a positive all players gotta have, but KG took it a different way. It was KG's team, his voice, his show, his everything. Anyone who differed was going to be an outcast."

The tension boiled over during a November 2000 practice, when Szczerbiak reportedly got picked off and chided Garnett to call out the screens. KG responded curtly, "Play some defense," the pickoff seemingly a consequence for whatever expectation Szczerbiak wasn't meeting defensively. Szczerbiak took exception. It accelerated into a shouting match, which spilled into the training room. Punches were thrown. Ask Szczerbiak about it today and he says he was simply a young player trying to stick up for himself. "I felt like I had some leadership qualities," he says. "I'm not a guy who will take a back seat all the time, and in certain scenarios I'm going to speak up for what's right. At times it definitely got me in trouble."



- Garnett and Ray Allen
https://celticswire.usatoday.com/2018/03/12/boston-celtics-big-three-ray-allen-paints-picture-of-relationship-with-kevin-garnett-as-tenuous-from-the-start/

Deveney highlighted a number of interesting story lines from the book in a recent article, including several excerpts that suggest Allen’s notoriously icy relationship with Kevin Garnett may have been strained from the very start.

Allen recalled dribbling in front of his locker during the Celtics’ preseason trip to Rome in 2007, which was something Allen had done to prepare for games his entire career. The dribbling annoyed Garnett, though, who told Allen, “No, you’re not going to do that.”

“No,” Garnett said, “I tip way better than him, so you better give me the check.” It was the first time they’d gone to dinner together, and Allen pointed out that Garnett had no idea how much Allen tipped. “There was no point in arguing with the guy,” Allen writes. “What struck me was that he felt the need to be seen as being superior to me, even in something as petty as this.”



Garnett and Joakim Noah
https://chicago.suntimes.com/sports/joakim-noahs-hatred-for-kevin-garnett-started-when-he-was-a-rookie/

Garnett’s former teammate Paul Pierce said the first time Noah met Garnett on the basketball court, the very intense Garnett rubbed the then-rookie Noah the wrong way.

One time, he asked [Joakim] Noah if he could rub through his hair, like a female or something.…And I know that kind of made [Noah] hot. And this was when Noah was a rookie, too. I remember Noah looked up to KG. He was like, ‘Man, KG, I had your poster on my wall, I looked up to you, man.’ And then [Garnett] just said something like that, and was like ‘F— you, Noah.’ I was like, ‘Whoa.’ This kid fresh out of college, looks up to KG, just said he had his poster on the wall, and he tells him that! It crushed him. It crushed Noah.



Garnett and Tim Duncan
https://www.complex.com/sports/2016/09/meanest-things-kevin-garnett-ever-said/mothers-day

The Timberwolves faced the Spurs at the Alamodome for a first round playoff game on May 9, 1999. At some point during that game, Garnett told Duncan “Happy Mother’s Day, M***********” as the Spurs legend lined up for a free throw.

Duncan’s mother passed away of breast cancer, one day before Tim’s 14th birthday in 1990.

While this incident has never been confirmed, what is confirmed is that Duncan hates Garnett, according to a 2012 Sports Illustrated profile:

“In fact, Duncan hates Kevin Garnett. Hates him the way liberals hate Sean Hannity. This information comes from very reliable sources, who talk about how KG has made a career of trying to punk Duncan, baiting him and slapping him and whispering really weird smack into his ear. They talk about how funny this is, because the worst thing you can do as an opponent is piss off Duncan. Then, as Malik Rose says, "he f------ destroys you." Duncan's lifetime numbers versus Garnett's teams, by the way: 19.4 points per game, 11.6 boards and a 44-17 record, including the postseason.
Duncan is diplomatic about the topic. Asked if perhaps all those years battling Garnett have softened his feelings for the man, led to a Magic-Larry type of kinship, Duncan leans back on the couch in his hotel room and grins. There is a pause. A longer pause. Finally he says, "Define kinship.”



I can go all day with the fights KG has had with teammates and opponents. That's great that he has intensity and is very competitive, I like that in a player. But leadership is not getting into fights, micromanaging, and dictating.

KG fans always want to go to the stats or talk about intensity and that is why he and Tim Duncan are on the same level...that if KG and Duncan reversed situations KG would have 5 rings and Duncan might have none. That all KG needed was Pop, Manu, and Parker.

There is no chance in HELL that KG is ever the leader that Duncan or even Robinson were for the Spurs. Robinson mentored Duncan and they got along great. DRob is very underrated in how he handled Tim being drafted and passing the torch to him in his rookie season.

Robinson is a better all around player than KG, a better defender than KG, a better leader than KG, carried his teams better than KG and has better stats than KG. In 1995, Robinson's teammates were not even as good as KG's teammates in 2004. Cassell would be the best teammate Robinson ever had on the Spurs.

KG is so overrated its comical now......


You have made. Your point about KG's leadership. It sounds bad. Since I was finding fault with young Robinson's ability to lead I have to compare him to young KG. I did not know enough about Young KG's baggage.

I can't say anything about old Robinson's leadership which probably means it was good leadership. Pop and Duncan got all the credit for a team that had it's act together. Robinson, Malik Rose and Avery Johnson probably deserve more credit.


G35 is cherry picking specific instances of bad leadership to paint a narrative. Also, why is KG trash talking an opponent considered bad leadership?
Lenin wrote: All over the world, wherever there are capitalists, freedom of the press means freedom to buy up newspapers, to buy writers, to bribe, buy and fake "public opinion" for the benefit of the bourgeoisie.
User avatar
OdomFan
General Manager
Posts: 8,567
And1: 6,960
Joined: Jan 07, 2017
Location: Maryland
   

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#25 » by OdomFan » Thu May 2, 2019 9:52 am

I like KG but I have to take the Admiral in this. That 08 Celtics team would instantly improve a lot if you replace KG with 97 Robinson.
Image
User avatar
LA Bird
Analyst
Posts: 3,701
And1: 3,518
Joined: Feb 16, 2015

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#26 » by LA Bird » Thu May 2, 2019 12:01 pm

Not sure why leadership is such a big focus in this thread. Robinson and Garnett have diametrically different leadership styles but one is not better than the other just because they are more or less vocal. If Robinson had a better supporting cast and won more rings in the mid 90s, we would be singing praises about his quiet leadership and humility like we do with Duncan, instead of calling him soft and passive. If Garnett had a better supporting cast and won more rings in the mid 00s, his passion and intensity would be credited with motivating the best out of his teammates and he won't be criticized for being overly-competitive. The narrative of what makes a good leader can easily be shaped by team success and personally, I don't find the leadership difference between the two to be very noteworthy.

In terms of on-court play, I consider Robinson to be the better player but his overall career to be less valuable due to longevity since he came into the league too old.
pandrade83
Starter
Posts: 2,040
And1: 604
Joined: Jun 07, 2017
     

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#27 » by pandrade83 » Thu May 2, 2019 3:11 pm

OdomFan wrote:I like KG but I have to take the Admiral in this. That 08 Celtics team would instantly improve a lot if you replace KG with 97 Robinson.

08 Boston gets a lot better if you replace him with a guy who missed the whole year? Good luck with that.

Anyway - the equivalent year in Robinson’s career would’ve been ‘02 if you’re doing apples to apples. I dont think boston wins the title if you make that swap.
Gooner
Head Coach
Posts: 6,591
And1: 5,417
Joined: Sep 02, 2018
 

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#28 » by Gooner » Thu May 2, 2019 3:14 pm

I would say KG, becasue he was more of a dog.
User avatar
OdomFan
General Manager
Posts: 8,567
And1: 6,960
Joined: Jan 07, 2017
Location: Maryland
   

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#29 » by OdomFan » Thu May 2, 2019 4:21 pm

pandrade83 wrote:
OdomFan wrote:I like KG but I have to take the Admiral in this. That 08 Celtics team would instantly improve a lot if you replace KG with 97 Robinson.

08 Boston gets a lot better if you replace him with a guy who missed the whole year? Good luck with that.

Anyway - the equivalent year in Robinson’s career would’ve been ‘02 if you’re doing apples to apples. I dont think boston wins the title if you make that swap.

Then just say he doesn't get hurt in this scenario. I picked 97 because Robinson was the same age that year that KG was when he jumped to Boston.
Image
pandrade83
Starter
Posts: 2,040
And1: 604
Joined: Jun 07, 2017
     

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#30 » by pandrade83 » Thu May 2, 2019 5:12 pm

OdomFan wrote:
pandrade83 wrote:
OdomFan wrote:I like KG but I have to take the Admiral in this. That 08 Celtics team would instantly improve a lot if you replace KG with 97 Robinson.

08 Boston gets a lot better if you replace him with a guy who missed the whole year? Good luck with that.

Anyway - the equivalent year in Robinson’s career would’ve been ‘02 if you’re doing apples to apples. I dont think boston wins the title if you make that swap.

Then just say he doesn't get hurt in this scenario. I picked 97 because Robinson was the same age that year that KG was when he jumped to Boston.


Now you're creating a fictional player who is better in '97 & probably every year after that as well.

If you only look at a guy's 5-7 year prime & say OK, who was the better player & place Robinson ahead of KG on that basis, I'm fine with that. I think Robinson had a better prime than KG. From a career standpoint, KG is & should be ahead because of Robinson's relatively short prime.
HeartBreakKid
RealGM
Posts: 22,395
And1: 18,828
Joined: Mar 08, 2012
     

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#31 » by HeartBreakKid » Thu May 2, 2019 5:46 pm

oldschooled wrote:Only argument KG has over DRob is longevity imo. Peak, prime, impact-wise (we have data for DRob and he's always battling Jordan at the top), defense, DRob is just better.

What are you referring to?
User avatar
Jaivl
Head Coach
Posts: 7,153
And1: 6,801
Joined: Jan 28, 2014
Location: A Coruña, Spain
Contact:
   

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#32 » by Jaivl » Thu May 2, 2019 6:46 pm

HeartBreakKid wrote:
oldschooled wrote:Only argument KG has over DRob is longevity imo. Peak, prime, impact-wise (we have data for DRob and he's always battling Jordan at the top), defense, DRob is just better.

What are you referring to?

That family of stats where KG looks like the GOAT.
This place is a cesspool of mindless ineptitude, mental decrepitude, and intellectual lassitude. I refuse to be sucked any deeper into this whirlpool of groupthink sewage. My opinions have been expressed. I'm going to go take a shower.
SinceGatlingWasARookie
RealGM
Posts: 11,712
And1: 2,760
Joined: Aug 25, 2005
Location: Northern California

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#33 » by SinceGatlingWasARookie » Thu May 2, 2019 7:44 pm

Young Robinson looked so good, better than KG, but he did not get the job done.

Everybody remembers that Hakeem beat Robinson. The loss to the centerless Run TMC Warriors also hurt Robinson's image. https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/199105030GSW.html

How overrated were Terry Cummings, Sean Elliot, Willie Anderson and Rod Strickland?

Add Tim Hardaway, Mitch Richmond and Chris Mullin to the 91 Spurs and do they win the championship?
SelakStreet
Junior
Posts: 341
And1: 54
Joined: Jan 22, 2014

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#34 » by SelakStreet » Thu May 2, 2019 7:54 pm

SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:Young Robinson looked so good, better than KG, but he did not get the job done.

Everybody remembers that Hakeem beat Robinson. The loss to the centerless Run TMC Warriors also hurt Robinson's image. https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/199105030GSW.html

How overrated were Terry Cummings, Sean Elliot, Willie Anderson and Rod Strickland?

Add Tim Hardaway, Mitch Richmond and Chris Mullin to the 91 Spurs and do they win the championship?


And Willie Anderson ended up having the shortest peak/prime among him, Rod Strickland, Sean Elliott and Terry Cummings.
G35
RealGM
Posts: 22,534
And1: 8,076
Joined: Dec 10, 2005
     

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#35 » by G35 » Thu May 2, 2019 9:03 pm

LA Bird wrote:Not sure why leadership is such a big focus in this thread. Robinson and Garnett have diametrically different leadership styles but one is not better than the other just because they are more or less vocal. If Robinson had a better supporting cast and won more rings in the mid 90s, we would be singing praises about his quiet leadership and humility like we do with Duncan, instead of calling him soft and passive. If Garnett had a better supporting cast and won more rings in the mid 00s, his passion and intensity would be credited with motivating the best out of his teammates and he won't be criticized for being overly-competitive. The narrative of what makes a good leader can easily be shaped by team success and personally, I don't find the leadership difference between the two to be very noteworthy.

In terms of on-court play, I consider Robinson to be the better player but his overall career to be less valuable due to longevity since he came into the league too old.



If you do not understand the value of leadership by now then nothing anyone is going to say will change your mind.

But there is a reason why KG went out in the first round seven straight years.

There is a reason why they missed the playoffs three straight years.

There is a reason why players like Chauncey left the Wolves.

It's the same reason why Durant did not want to play with WB anymore. Its why Kyrie didn't want to play with Lebron anymore. There is a reason why players want to go to the Warriors.

The reason why you say if is because in reality there are not any excuses for why KG did not do more for Minnesota.

KG and DRob both had similar supporting casts (except in 2004 where KG had a superior cast) prior to Duncan being drafted.

But Robinson's teams had better RS and PS success. DRob anchored one of the biggest single season win turnarounds in league history. Robinson led the team to multiple 50+ win seasons and a 60+ win season:

Spurs win totals from 1990-1996
90 - 56 wins
91 - 55 wins
92 - 47 wins
93 - 49 wins
94 - 55 wins
95 - 62 wins
96 - 59 wins

Average wins 54.7 per season over seven seasons...during this time they went to the semi-finals four times and the WCF's once

TWolves win totals from 1996-2007
96 - 26 wins
97 - 40 wins
98 - 45 wins
99 - 25 wins (strike season)
00 - 50 wins
01 - 47 wins
02 - 50 wins
03 - 51 wins
04 - 58 wins
05 - 44 wins
06 - 33 wins
07 - 32 wins

Not counting the strike season the Wolves avg'd 43.3 wins over 11 seasons...during which time they went to the WCF's once and lost in the first round seven times.

What also should be noted during this time is that Flip Saunders was the Wolves head coach for KG's for 9 1/2 seasons. Whatever you may think about Flip he was a better than average coach compiling a .525 winning record over 1246 games.

David Robinson on the other hand, had to deal with six different coaches in seven years.

Larry Brown
Bob Bass
Rex Hughes
Jerry Tarkanian
John Lucas
Bob Hill

Some of these guys were all time bad coaches, like Jerry Tarkanian, who only coached 20 games in the NBA and quit with a record of 9-11.

Jerry Lucas' only winning seasons came while coaching Robinson...with the Spurs he was 94-49....everywhere else he coached he 79-209, coaching at Philadelphia and Cleveland. Yeah both teams got rid of Lucas before acquiring Iverson and Lebron.

Bob Hill another coach who only had winning seasons coaching Robinson; Hill was 121-43 with Robinson when he was healthy and was 189-250 without Robinson. The Spurs got rid of Bob Hill and hired Popovich right before drafting Duncan.

So when people talk about Minnesota did not put anything around KG, the Spurs did not do much better. It was just the David was just that good in the RS that he could power those Spurs to good RS records. But in the PS, yeah he did not look as good because he was getting his teams to overachieve.

If you wanted to make a current comparison, this would be Anthony Davis in New Orleans...except David Robinson was taking his teams to the PS and the second round.

But the thing is that leadership is just one aspect of this comparison, a big one imo but still just one aspect. But you notice none of the KG supporters are pulling out any stats....none whatsoever....because DRob kills him in everything. Individually its no contest, advanced, boxscore, whatever, DRob kills KG.

Then some people want to talk about KG's defense....before going to Boston, no KG-led team ever came close to being the #1 ranked defensive team or even top five.

Robinson is a GOAT level defensive anchor:

DRTG Spurs 1990-96
90 - 3rd
91 - 1st
92 - 1st
93 - 10th
94 - 9th
95 - 5th
96 - 3rd

So in those seven years, the Spurs ranked no worse than 10th defensively and twice were the best defense in the league.

OTOH, KG with all of his ability to switch and read offenses was never able to get the Wolves into the top 5 defensively:
96- 20th
97 - 15th
98 - 23rd
99 - 11th
00 - 12th
01 - 16th
02 - 15th
03 - 16th
04 - 6th
05 - 15th
06 - 10th
07 - 21st

A lot of what KG rides on is that the TWolves never put any talent around him, injuries, quality of competition, Minnesota not being a FA destination. But the same thing was true of Robinson in San Antonio, they have never been a FA destination, nor has management spent a lot of money in building a team. This is true even when Duncan was there, the Spurs have always try to stay within budget.

There is no argument for KG being better than DRob on any metric, so its so confusing that people who tout analytics, facts, objectivity, progressiveness, are still trying to build a narrative in KG's favor. The only thing you can point to is KG's longevity but then you have to balance that out with the fact it took KG three to four years to really become a difference maker and his last few years on Boston, Brooklyn, and Minnesota was just him collecting a check.

DRob was an integral part of two championships at latter half of his career, those years do count in his favor as instead of people acting like he was some five minute bench player. He was still guarding Shaq.....
I'm so tired of the typical......
User avatar
Jaivl
Head Coach
Posts: 7,153
And1: 6,801
Joined: Jan 28, 2014
Location: A Coruña, Spain
Contact:
   

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#36 » by Jaivl » Thu May 2, 2019 10:50 pm

G35 wrote:But there is a reason why KG went out in the first round seven straight years.

There is a reason why they missed the playoffs three straight years.

There is a reason why players like Chauncey left the Wolves.

(...)

KG and DRob both had similar supporting casts (except in 2004 where KG had a superior cast) prior to Duncan being drafted.

Red is false and any analysis using... any stat, really, would show you that.

Can't write a long post now - but yes there is a reason and it has next to nothing to do with KG being a dumbass. Although there is some truth in it, as LA Bird says that armchair psychoanalist **** is mostly nothing more than results-based narrative.

Hell, you even kinda say the real reason yourself:

G35 wrote:It's the same reason why Durant did not want to play with WB anymore. Its why Kyrie didn't want to play with Lebron anymore. There is a reason why players want to go to the Warriors.

GOAT supporting cast
Great supporting cast for him to be #1 - he later rectified the things he had said about LeBron
GOAT supporting cast

G35 wrote:But you notice none of the KG supporters are pulling out any stats....none whatsoever....because DRob kills him in everything. Individually its no contest, advanced, boxscore, whatever, DRob kills KG.

(...)

There is no argument for KG being better than DRob on any metric, so its so confusing that people who tout analytics, facts, objectivity, progressiveness, are still trying to build a narrative in KG's favor. The only thing you can point to is KG's longevity but then you have to balance that out with the fact it took KG three to four years to really become a difference maker and his last few years on Boston, Brooklyn, and Minnesota was just him collecting a check.

Lying is bad. I've seen - and you have too - here statistical arguments for KG over people better than DRob, and none of them disproven. Only by strawmen and putting lots of ellipsis at the end of posts, never once a honest effort.
This place is a cesspool of mindless ineptitude, mental decrepitude, and intellectual lassitude. I refuse to be sucked any deeper into this whirlpool of groupthink sewage. My opinions have been expressed. I'm going to go take a shower.
User avatar
LA Bird
Analyst
Posts: 3,701
And1: 3,518
Joined: Feb 16, 2015

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#37 » by LA Bird » Thu May 2, 2019 11:32 pm

G35 wrote:If you do not understand the value of leadership by now then nothing anyone is going to say will change your mind.

Yeah, because acknowledging differences in leadership style does not make someone a better/worse leader is equivalent to not understanding the value of leadership...

But there is a reason why KG went out in the first round seven straight years.

There is a reason why they missed the playoffs three straight years.

This is exactly the kind of result-oriented "leadership" I just criticized. KG lost so therefore he must have been a bad leader? One can be a good leader without winning a lot if his team simple didn't play good enough. Judging someone's "leadership" by how much his teams won/lost is essentially no different from ring counting.

There is a reason why players like Chauncey left the Wolves.

That reason being Dumars offered him a starting role in Detroit while McHale was an idiot who wanted to send Billups back to the bench behind an injured 32 year old Terrell Brandon who never played another minute in the NBA. Chauncey remained close friends with Garnett after leaving the TWolves as well so exactly how is he leaving a proof of Garnett's 'poor' leadership?

It's the same reason why Durant did not want to play with WB anymore. Its why Kyrie didn't want to play with Lebron anymore. There is a reason why players want to go to the Warriors.

Because the Warriors are an all time great team lucky enough to have the cap space for another superstar. Talk about leadership all you want but if Curry had the shooting touch of Ben Wallace and the Warriors were winning 40 games not 65+, nobody would be joining Golden State for "leadership". Besides, if you are going to claim Garnett's intensity is detrimental to team chemistry, how about Draymond Green and his role as the vocal leader on the Warriors?

Spoiler:
The reason why you say if is because in reality there are not any excuses for why KG did not do more for Minnesota.

KG and DRob both had similar supporting casts (except in 2004 where KG had a superior cast) prior to Duncan being drafted.

But Robinson's teams had better RS and PS success. DRob anchored one of the biggest single season win turnarounds in league history. Robinson led the team to multiple 50+ win seasons and a 60+ win season:

Spurs win totals from 1990-1996
90 - 56 wins
91 - 55 wins
92 - 47 wins
93 - 49 wins
94 - 55 wins
95 - 62 wins
96 - 59 wins

Average wins 54.7 per season over seven seasons...during this time they went to the semi-finals four times and the WCF's once

TWolves win totals from 1996-2007
96 - 26 wins
97 - 40 wins
98 - 45 wins
99 - 25 wins (strike season)
00 - 50 wins
01 - 47 wins
02 - 50 wins
03 - 51 wins
04 - 58 wins
05 - 44 wins
06 - 33 wins
07 - 32 wins

Not counting the strike season the Wolves avg'd 43.3 wins over 11 seasons...during which time they went to the WCF's once and lost in the first round seven times.

What also should be noted during this time is that Flip Saunders was the Wolves head coach for KG's for 9 1/2 seasons. Whatever you may think about Flip he was a better than average coach compiling a .525 winning record over 1246 games.

David Robinson on the other hand, had to deal with six different coaches in seven years.

Larry Brown
Bob Bass
Rex Hughes
Jerry Tarkanian
John Lucas
Bob Hill

Some of these guys were all time bad coaches, like Jerry Tarkanian, who only coached 20 games in the NBA and quit with a record of 9-11.

Jerry Lucas' only winning seasons came while coaching Robinson...with the Spurs he was 94-49....everywhere else he coached he 79-209, coaching at Philadelphia and Cleveland. Yeah both teams got rid of Lucas before acquiring Iverson and Lebron.

Bob Hill another coach who only had winning seasons coaching Robinson; Hill was 121-43 with Robinson when he was healthy and was 189-250 without Robinson. The Spurs got rid of Bob Hill and hired Popovich right before drafting Duncan.

So when people talk about Minnesota did not put anything around KG, the Spurs did not do much better. It was just the David was just that good in the RS that he could power those Spurs to good RS records. But in the PS, yeah he did not look as good because he was getting his teams to overachieve.

If you wanted to make a current comparison, this would be Anthony Davis in New Orleans...except David Robinson was taking his teams to the PS and the second round.

But the thing is that leadership is just one aspect of this comparison, a big one imo but still just one aspect. But you notice none of the KG supporters are pulling out any stats....none whatsoever....because DRob kills him in everything. Individually its no contest, advanced, boxscore, whatever, DRob kills KG.

Then some people want to talk about KG's defense....before going to Boston, no KG-led team ever came close to being the #1 ranked defensive team or even top five.

Robinson is a GOAT level defensive anchor:

DRTG Spurs 1990-96
90 - 3rd
91 - 1st
92 - 1st
93 - 10th
94 - 9th
95 - 5th
96 - 3rd

So in those seven years, the Spurs ranked no worse than 10th defensively and twice were the best defense in the league.

OTOH, KG with all of his ability to switch and read offenses was never able to get the Wolves into the top 5 defensively:
96- 20th
97 - 15th
98 - 23rd
99 - 11th
00 - 12th
01 - 16th
02 - 15th
03 - 16th
04 - 6th
05 - 15th
06 - 10th
07 - 21st

A lot of what KG rides on is that the TWolves never put any talent around him, injuries, quality of competition, Minnesota not being a FA destination. But the same thing was true of Robinson in San Antonio, they have never been a FA destination, nor has management spent a lot of money in building a team. This is true even when Duncan was there, the Spurs have always try to stay within budget.

There is no argument for KG being better than DRob on any metric, so its so confusing that people who tout analytics, facts, objectivity, progressiveness, are still trying to build a narrative in KG's favor. The only thing you can point to is KG's longevity but then you have to balance that out with the fact it took KG three to four years to really become a difference maker and his last few years on Boston, Brooklyn, and Minnesota was just him collecting a check.

DRob was an integral part of two championships at latter half of his career, those years do count in his favor as instead of people acting like he was some five minute bench player. He was still guarding Shaq.....

What part of "I consider Robinson to be the better player" do you not understand? Or are you just arguing for the sake of arguing.
ardee
RealGM
Posts: 15,320
And1: 5,397
Joined: Nov 16, 2011

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#38 » by ardee » Fri May 3, 2019 12:41 am

Zeitgeister wrote:
SinceGatlingWasARookie wrote:
G35 wrote:

People seem to only consider Garnett when he was with the Celtics and not how he was when he was with Minnesota, arguably his best years.

Garnett was not much of a leader, imo. I think he was very immature and fought with teammates all the time. His "intensity" is not always the the ideal way to lead men:

- Garnett punching out Rick Rickert
http://www.startribune.com/rick-rickert-talks-about-the-time-kevin-garnett-punched-him/320963661/




- Garnett and Wally Z
https://www.cbc.ca/sports/basketball/garnett-szczerbiak-scuffle-after-practice-1.234602




- Garnett and Ray Allen
https://celticswire.usatoday.com/2018/03/12/boston-celtics-big-three-ray-allen-paints-picture-of-relationship-with-kevin-garnett-as-tenuous-from-the-start/




Garnett and Joakim Noah
https://chicago.suntimes.com/sports/joakim-noahs-hatred-for-kevin-garnett-started-when-he-was-a-rookie/




Garnett and Tim Duncan
https://www.complex.com/sports/2016/09/meanest-things-kevin-garnett-ever-said/mothers-day




I can go all day with the fights KG has had with teammates and opponents. That's great that he has intensity and is very competitive, I like that in a player. But leadership is not getting into fights, micromanaging, and dictating.

KG fans always want to go to the stats or talk about intensity and that is why he and Tim Duncan are on the same level...that if KG and Duncan reversed situations KG would have 5 rings and Duncan might have none. That all KG needed was Pop, Manu, and Parker.

There is no chance in HELL that KG is ever the leader that Duncan or even Robinson were for the Spurs. Robinson mentored Duncan and they got along great. DRob is very underrated in how he handled Tim being drafted and passing the torch to him in his rookie season.

Robinson is a better all around player than KG, a better defender than KG, a better leader than KG, carried his teams better than KG and has better stats than KG. In 1995, Robinson's teammates were not even as good as KG's teammates in 2004. Cassell would be the best teammate Robinson ever had on the Spurs.

KG is so overrated its comical now......


You have made. Your point about KG's leadership. It sounds bad. Since I was finding fault with young Robinson's ability to lead I have to compare him to young KG. I did not know enough about Young KG's baggage.

I can't say anything about old Robinson's leadership which probably means it was good leadership. Pop and Duncan got all the credit for a team that had it's act together. Robinson, Malik Rose and Avery Johnson probably deserve more credit.


G35 is cherry picking specific instances of bad leadership to paint a narrative. Also, why is KG trash talking an opponent considered bad leadership?


Making fun of TD for his mother passing makes him just a ghastly human being. I don't know about you but if I'm on a sports team, a work team, whatever, I am less likely to follow someone like that.
ardee
RealGM
Posts: 15,320
And1: 5,397
Joined: Nov 16, 2011

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#39 » by ardee » Fri May 3, 2019 12:47 am

oldschooled wrote:Only argument KG has over DRob is longevity imo. Peak, prime, impact-wise (we have data for DRob and he's always battling Jordan at the top), defense, DRob is just better.


Even longevity wise.... KG's prime was 2000-2008, Robinson's was 1990-1998 with one season missed. Average quality was high enough for Rob for me to take his 8 years over KG's 9. Post prime, Robinson gives you 1999 where he's still arguably a top 5 player, 2000 and 2001 where he's a top 12-14 player, 2002 and 2003 where he was still a high level contributor, probably on the level of Marc Gasol this year.
Colbinii
RealGM
Posts: 34,243
And1: 21,859
Joined: Feb 13, 2013

Re: David Robinson or Kevin Garnett? 

Post#40 » by Colbinii » Fri May 3, 2019 1:46 am

Spoiler:
Kevin Garnett was the most versatile defender we have ever seen play in the NBA. He can guard every position 1-5 and he has the ability switch every pick and roll. [/b]

Kobe Bryant flies by Anthony Peeler as he brings the ball to half-court.

Image

Garnett picks up Bryant, forcing him inside to the help defense (Rasho Nesterovic)

Image

Garnett has Kobe where he wants him, trying to finish over Rasho Nesterovic while being on Kobe's blind side

Image

Garnett's length and skill allows him to block Bryant

Image

Kobe runs the pick and roll with a goal to get an isolation on the right side of the court. Garnett switches onto Kobe.

Image

Garnett forces Kobe to go inside, where his help is. Keep in mind, there are no players to the top right of the picture. The entire side of the court is open, yet Garnett is still able to force Kobe into the crowded paint. KG is also able to stay in front of a young Kobe Bryant with the use of great hand and foot work.

Image

Kobe is forced to pass the ball out to the perimeter where the Lakers will have to reset with little time left on the shot clock.

Image

A 22 year old LeBron is going 1 on 1 versus a 31 year old Kevin Garnett.

Image

LeBron begins his drive and KG is happy to force him into two other celtics defenders.

Image

Garnett stops LeBron in his tracks, forcing LeBron to pick up his dribble. LeBron attempts to do a spin move, but it works to no avail.

Image

Garnett and Pierce communicate as Garnett gets ready to switch on Wally Szczerbiak after he receives a pass from LeBron.

Image

Garnett begins to switch onto Wally Szczerbiak.

Image

Garnett is now guarding Wally Szczerbiak and is pressuring him, forcing him back and outside of the 3 point line.

Image

Garnett, originally guarding LeBron at the top of the key, is now guarding Wally Szczerbiak during the same possession.

Image

Garnett strips Wally and they are off to the races.

Image

What does this all mean?

Kevin Garnett is able to guard the best and most athletic wing players we have ever seen. He can stop LeBron and a young Kobe Bryant as they are driving to the basketball. He has the stamina to guard multiple ball handlers over a single possession.

2. Kevin Garnett is an elite rim protector

Peja grabs an offensive rebound and is looking to put the shot back.

Image

As Peja sets up his shot, Garnett hastily steps towards Peja and closes the space.

Image

Garnett meets the ball and actually grabs it and comes down with it, mid air.

Image

One thing to note about Garnett's blocks, almost all of them end up in possession of his team. Garnett isn't only an elite shot "blocker", but he is also elite at controlling the ball as he blocks the shot.

Shooting percentage of opponents within 5 feet of the rim against Kevin Garnett from 97-10:

1997: 51.3% on 26.1 attempts/game
1998: 58.2% on 24.4 attempts/game
1999: 58.8% on 20.6 attempts/game
2000: 58.0% on 21.5 attempts/game
2001: 58.0% on 22.5 attempts/game
2002: 58.2% on 20.0 attempts/game
2003: 58.1% on 20.9 attempts/game
2004: 53.7% on 20.7 attempts/game
2005: 56.7% on 22.0 attempts/game
2006: 55.1% on 23.4 attempts/game
2007: 60.1% on 22.2 attempts/game
2008: 55.5% on 16.6 attempts/game
2009: 54.4% on 17.4 attempts/game
2010: 56.5% on 17.1 attempts/game

There is a clear correlation between the amount of attempts Garnett was forced to stop at the rim and how good his fellow perimeter defenders were. When he had the likes of Sam Cassell, Latrell Sprewell, Troy Hudson, and Wally Szczerbiak defending the perimeter, he was facing many more shots at the rim. When Garnett had players like Rajon Rondo, Paul Pierce, and Tony Allen, the amount of attempts defended within 5 feet drops substantially. The shots Garnett was defending while playing with mediocre to poor defenders were likely more difficult to defend as well.

When we compare these to Tim Duncan, he was between 49% and 52% when he played next to David Robinson. Without David Robinson, he was between 53% and 56%, in line with what Garnett played with in Boston and his peak season in 2004. Dwight Howard, from 07-11, was between 55% and 59% in each of those seasons.


3. Kevin Garnett's ability to rotate on time is in the GOAT tier for defensive big men.

Garnett rotates over to help his smaller guard in the paint.

Image

Garnett is in position to meet the ball as it is still going up.

Image

Garnett's hand is about 1 foot from to the top of the backboard as he makes this block.

Image

Garnett starts on Robert Horry. An interesting part of this play is before Horry was at the top of the key, he was on the elbow. Garnett forced him back that far as he attempted to post up and receive an entry pass from the wing.

Image

Garnett follows the entry pass seamlessly and begins to rotate onto Shaq while the ball is still in the air.

Image

By the time Shaq takes one dribble, Garnett is already in position for a block attempt.

Image

Garnett is able to block Shaq from behind without a foul. The block deflects off the backboard and right into a Timberwolves hands. It was likely easier for Garnett to block the shot to the sideline and out of bounds, but his ability to control his blocks is once again at the forefront.

Image

There is no question that Garnett's defensive versatility sets him apart from every single player to ever play the game. Their were better rim protectors, but their hasn't been a player who was required to do the list of things Garnett did while in Minnesota on the defensive end.


Timberwolves/Celtics Defensive Rating with Kevin Garnett On/Off (League Rank):
2001: 102.9 (14th), 107.2 (27th)
2002: 104.2 (14th), 108.6 (Last)
2003: 102.4 (10th), 110.9 (Last)
2004: 98.5 (5th), 104.6 (20th)
2005: 106.6 (14th) , 105.3 (12th)
2006: 104.7 (11th), 105.5 (14th)
2007: 106.2 (13th), 112.5 (Last)
2008: 97.3 (1st), 101.4 (1st)
2009: 98.6 (1st), 105.8 (7th)
2010: 102.1 (1st), 106.7 (14th)
2011: 98.1 (1st), 104.4 (7th)

Garnett shows the ability to make absolutely terrible defensive players and personnel into average defensive teams. He has shown the ability to make average defensive players and personnel into very good defenses. Last, Garnett has shown that he can take already very good defenses and make them all-time great.

Here is a graph depicting the same information above.

Image

What makes Kevin Garnett great offensively?

1. Passing


Kevin Garnett is one of the greatest passing offensive big men of all-time. As an offensive anchor for the Minnesota Timberwolves from 1998 to 2007 (10 seasons), he averaged 4.9 assists per game to only 2.7 turnovers. If we look at some advanced numbers, we get 22.7 AST% to 11.9 TOV%.

From 2001 to 2007, Garnett had 570 "bad passes", which is 81 bad passes per season (or 1 per game). For a guy who averaged nearly 5 assists per game, only 1 bad pass per game is a fantastic ratio. If we compare this for Vlade Divac from 01-04, he had 85 bad passes per season, but only 3.8 assists. Chris Webber, from 01-03 had 90 bad passes per season with 4.8 assists per game.

2. Post Scoring

If you want to get a picture of the variety of post-moves Garnett had in his arsenal, look no further than this video that highlights only his 2008 season.



Here are Kevin Garnett's scoring numbers "at the rim" from 2001 - 2011 (%Assisted):

2001: 67.7% on 356 attempts (66%)
2002: 65.9% on 311 attempts (50.7%)
2003: 70.9% on 337 attempts (58.2%)
2004: 67.9% on 452 attempts (63.8%)
2005: 65.2% on 374 attempts (64.3%)
2006: 66.8% on 313 attempts (59.8%)
2007: 64.3% on 283 attempts (56%)
2008: 70.2% on 339 attempts (71.8%)
2009: 76.7% on 180 attempts (85.5%)
2010: 65.3% on 300 attempts (83.2%)
2011: 73.2% on 247 attempts (78.9%)

How does Duncan compare?

2001: 69.1% on 453 attempts (53.7%)
2002: 71.2% on 518 attempts (51.5%)
2003: 68.6% on 535 attempts (51.0%)
2004: Did not load
2005: 67.3% on 431 attempts (57.2%)
2006: 72.7% on 461 attempts (54.6%)
2007: 69.9% on 568 attempts (53.9%)
2008: 68% on 506 attempts (58.4%)
2009: 64.1% on 370 attempts (62%)
2010: 68.6% on 382 attempts (66%)

Duncan has a slight edge as a better finisher around the rim, but Garnett is still elite in this regard. Duncan takes many more shots at the rim, which is why his FG% is higher than Garnett, but does that make him a better scorer?


3. Mid-Range Shooting

What made Kevin Garnett such a fantastic offensive player, aside from his already covered elite passing skills, was his ability to score from everywhere, and specifically, score where the team needed him. Unlike Duncan, Garnett is an elite mid-range shooter.

Here are Kevin Garnett's scoring numbers "10-16 feet" and below them "16 to <3-pt" from 2001 - 2011 (%Assisted):

2001: 44.4% on 306 attempts (52.2%)
2002: 48.1% on 314 attempts (54.3%)
2003: 49.6% on 413 attempts (56.6%)
2004: 47.3% on 476 attempts (53.3%)
2005: 42.9% on 361 attempts (67.1%)
2006: 51.1% on 284 attempts (50.3%)
2007: 43.9% on 328 attempts (51.4%)
2008: 48.7% on 302 attempts (43.5%)
2009: 44.1% on 136 attempts (48.3%)
2010: 39.8% on 161 attempts (51.6%)
2011: 43.8% on 137 attempts (60%)


2001: 41.5% on 407 attempts (73.4%)
2002: 40.0% on 395 attempts (72.2%)
2003: 46.6% on 459 attempts (70.1%)
2004: 43.3% on 614 attempts (81.6%)
2005: 46.5% on 318 attempts (83.1%)
2006: 46.4% on 358 attempts (80.1%)
2007: 42.3% on 423 attempts (74.9%)
2008: 47.2% on 511 attempts (89.6%)
2009: 44.1% on 279 attempts (93.5%)
2010: 47.6% on 401 attempts (90.6%)
2011: 46.2% on 355 attempts (92.1%)

How does Dirk Nowitzki compare?

2001: 46.8% on 250 attempts (57.3%)
2002: 42.9% on 226 attempts (54.6%)
2003: 50.5% on 376 attempts (46.3%)
2004: 46.0% on 276 attempts (52.0%)
2005: 43.6% on 349 attempts (45.4%)
2006: 48.4% on 516 attempts (35.2%)
2007: 49.3% on 363 attempts (36.9%)
2008: 48.1% on 370 attempts (43.3%)
2009: 49.0% on 567 attempts (41.0%)
2010: 45.6% on 472 attempts (46.5%)
2011: 49.2% on 429 attempts (42.7%)


2001: 44.9% on 292 attempts (73.3%)
2002: 49.0% on 355 attempts (75.9%)
2003: 40.4% on 532 attempts (68.4%)
2004: 46.6% on 487 attempts (75.3%)
2005: 41.6% on 630 attempts (59.2%)
2006: 47.2% on 606 attempts (59.4%)
2007: 50.0% on 504 attempts (64.7%)
2008: 49.5% on 412 attempts (72.5%)
2009: 47.9% on 603 attempts (73.7%)
2010: 46.9% on 605 attempts (79.6%)
2011: 51.9% on 489 attempts (84.3%)

Garnett is actually better from mid-range from 01-05, and it isn't until 2009 where Dirk has a clear edge in terms of mid-range scoring. Now, my point here isn't "OMG KG IS A BETTER MIDRANGE SHOOTER THAN DIRK", rather, it is to show just how close they are in terms of mid-range shooters, like I did with Garnett and Duncan for at-rim scoring. If we are looking at it like this, we see that Kevin Garnett is a clearly superior playmaker/passer to both these bigs, and is a comparable scorer to both these all-time greats.

When looking at Kevin Garnett's offensive game, he doesn't have any weaknesses, and that is what we should look at when we look at top 10 players of all-time. Kevin Garnett is an elite mid-range and close range scorer. He provides an insane amount of spacing for his teammates, which allows him to play with any type of big man in NBA history. He can play with a low post threat like Shaquille O'Neal and he can play with a big man who has range like Dirk Nowitzki with no issues for fit. Unfortunately, a majority of Kevin Garnett's career was spent playing with big men like Rasho Nesterovic, Ervin "Not so Magical" Johnson, Cherokee Parks, Joe Smith, and Kendrick Perkins.

What does this mean for Kevin Garnett's impact on the game of basketball offensively? A ton.

If we look at Kevin Garnett's on/off for offensive through his career, we can see just how much his passing, playmaking, and scoring arsenal effect his team.

Timberwolves/Celtics Offensive Rating with Kevin Garnett On/Off (League Rank):

2001: 106.2 (8th), 101.7 (18th)
2002: 110 (2nd), 104.4 (15th)
2003: 108.5 (3rd), 93.4 (2nd to Last)
2004: 108.3 (3rd), 93.8 (Last)
2005: 108.4 (6th), 106.3 (14th)
2006: 105.3 (18th) , 95.2 (Last)
2007: 105.7 (16th), 97.3 (Last)
2008: 113.6 (2nd), 105.9 (21st)
2009: 112.8 (3rd), 109.4 (10th)
2010: 109.8 (10th), 106.7 (19th)
2011: 111.1 (6th), 101.3 (Last)

As we see here, Garnett's impact on offense is immense (just like his defense). Again, he is taking "awful" supporting offensive casts and making them into very good to great offenses (consistently top 5). At the same time, he is taking average offensive supporting casts and turning them into great offenses.

Here is a graph of the phenomena.

Image

All in all, Kevin Garnett leaves a footprint on an NBA game in more ways than any player in NBA History. He wasn't the interior force that Shaq was, he isn't the rim protector that Bill Russell was, and he wasn't the shooter that Dirk was. However, his ability to still be elite in all those categories, while being an elite playmaker, makes him a shoe-in for a top 10 player of all-time. Ironically, Garnett's biggest strengths are what kept Minnesota from being a title contender. Garnett was able to fill in so many gaps for the team that the front office rarely added any all-star level talents to play with Garnett, even though they would have fit marvelously (any all-star fits marvelously with Garnett).

Return to Player Comparisons