10 best SG based on 4 year stretches

[Narigo]

1. 88-91 Jordan
2. 06-09 Kobe
3. 17-20 Harden
4. 09-12 Wade
5. 88-92 Drexler
6. 01-04 McGrady
7. 78-81 Gervin
8. 95-98 Miller
9. 83-86 Moncrief
10.00-03 Allen

[LAL1947]

Man, do I love threads like this one. It gives me yet another opportunity to do some "basketball math".

So dear ole Timmy Duncan played with a Top 10 SG Of All Time (some have Manu as high as #7 in this poll)... and a Top 10-20 PG Of All Time... and is the Best PF Of All Time... and had the team with the best depth... and had the best FO... and had the best coach... and is supposedly better than Kobe/Shaq.... and yet he couldn't manage a single repeat?!

Something isn't adding up here, Jack!

[Dutchball97]

Man, do I love threads like this one. It gives me yet another opportunity to do some "basketball math".

So dear ole Timmy Duncan played with a Top 10 SG Of All Time (some have Manu as high as #7 in this poll)... and a Top 10-20 PG Of All Time... and is the Best PF Of All Time... and had the team with the best depth... and had the best FO... and had the best coach... and is supposedly better than Kobe/Shaq.... and yet he couldn't manage a single repeat?

Something isn't adding up here, Jack!

Talk about someone living rent free in your head lmao.

[flaco]

Man, do I love threads like this one. It gives me yet another opportunity to do some "basketball math".

So dear ole Timmy Duncan played with a Top 10 SG Of All Time (some have Manu as high as #7 in this poll)... and a Top 10-20 PG Of All Time... and is the Best PF Of All Time... and had the team with the best depth... and had the best FO... and had the best coach... and is supposedly better than Kobe/Shaq.... and yet he couldn't manage a single repeat?

Something isn't adding up here, Jack!

What isn't adding up here is that Parker was a top 10-20 PG of all time. The way I see it, he was a score-first guard who was forced to run the point cause he would have been undersized at SG. I mean, he was nothing special as a facilitator. Fortunately for him, he was playing alongside 2 high-BBIQ, team-first players in Timmy and Manu. He was also a below average shooter who was scoring most of his points via slashing. Long story short, he was an undersized slasher. Never understood the hype. Had he been selected by a different team, I bet he would have had a rather mediocre career. I would argue he's one of the most overrated players of all time.

If you ask me, Duncan is the modern-day Bill Russell: the ultimate team player, the ultimate winner. The guy won 5(!) rings playing for a small-market team! It doesn't get much more impressive than that! I consider him a GOAT candidate.

[70sFan]

Man, do I love threads like this one. It gives me yet another opportunity to do some "basketball math".

So dear ole Timmy Duncan played with a Top 10 SG Of All Time (some have Manu as high as #7 in this poll)... and a Top 10-20 PG Of All Time... and is the Best PF Of All Time... and had the team with the best depth... and had the best FO... and had the best coach... and is supposedly better than Kobe/Shaq.... and yet he couldn't manage a single repeat?

Something isn't adding up here, Jack!

What isn't adding up here is that Parker was a top 10-20 PG of all time. The way I see it, he was a score-first SG who was forced to run the point cause he was undersized at SG. I mean, he was nothing special as a facilitator. Fortunately for him, he was playing alongside 2 high-BBIQ, team-first players in Timmy and Manu. He was also a below average shooter who was scoring most of his points via slashing. Long story short, he was an undersized slasher. Never understood the hype. Had he been selected by a different team, I bet he would have had a rather mediocre career. I would argue he's one of the most overrated players of all time.

If you ask me, Duncan is the modern-day Bill Russell: the ultimate team player, the ultimate winner. The guy won 5(!) rings playing for a small-market team! It doesn't get much more impressive than that! I consider him a GOAT candidate.

Ignore him, his whole contribution to this board is trying to prove how much better Kobe was compared to Duncan and how we all overrate Timmy.

[Dutchball97]

Man, do I love threads like this one. It gives me yet another opportunity to do some "basketball math".

So dear ole Timmy Duncan played with a Top 10 SG Of All Time (some have Manu as high as #7 in this poll)... and a Top 10-20 PG Of All Time... and is the Best PF Of All Time... and had the team with the best depth... and had the best FO... and had the best coach... and is supposedly better than Kobe/Shaq.... and yet he couldn't manage a single repeat?

Something isn't adding up here, Jack!

What isn't adding up here is that Parker was a top 10-20 PG of all time. The way I see it, he was a score-first SG who was forced to run the point cause he was undersized at SG. I mean, he was nothing special as a facilitator. Fortunately for him, he was playing alongside 2 high-BBIQ, team-first players in Timmy and Manu. He was also a below average shooter who was scoring most of his points via slashing. Long story short, he was an undersized slasher. Never understood the hype. Had he been selected by a different team, I bet he would have had a rather mediocre career. I would argue he's one of the most overrated players of all time.

If you ask me, Duncan is the modern-day Bill Russell: the ultimate team player, the ultimate winner. The guy won 5(!) rings playing for a small-market team! It doesn't get much more impressive than that! I consider him a GOAT candidate.

Ignore him, his whole contribution to this board is trying to prove how much better Kobe was compared to Duncan and how we all overrate Timmy.

Don't people get tired of derailing threads with controversial takes all the time? It is almost impressive to turn a top 10 SG thread into a Duncan vs Kobe/Shaq discussion. It seems like whenever a one-topic poster calms down for a bit the next one takes their place.

[LAL1947]

Hehe, it sure is fun invading this little "Timmy was better than Kobe/Shaq" safe-space on RealGM.

This is how the rest of the world sees it though. Lebron has since moved up a tier, as this is an older pic.



derailing post, stick to the topic

[Dutchball97]

Hehe, it sure is fun invading this little "Timmy was better than Kobe/Shaq" safe-space on RealGM.

derailing post, stick to the topic

You also think Kobe is a tier above Bird, Wilt and LeBron? Just based on a picture you found online or can you actually back that up yourself?