RealGM Top 100 List #18

[lorak]

Isiah's advantages over Nash, without stats:

Eye test: Best lay-up shooter ever. Nash is close behind, but Isiah is better yet.

Nash efficiency at rim is amazing, almost as good as LeBron's so it's very unlikely Isiah was better here.

Played on vastly better defensive teams, even relative to their respective era. This lends plausibility to the claim that he was a better individual defender.

He was better defender but it doesn't matter much when we are comparing point guards. Pistons weren't great defensively because they had Isiah.

[penbeast0]

If I'm not mistaken:

LJ 11
Doctor MJ FJS DavidStern Gongxi Dr Mufasa drza
ElGee ronnymac2 shawngoat23 Baller 24 TMACFORMVP

Pettit 10
penbeast0 mysticbb Laimbeer JordansBulls cpower
Fencer reregistered RoyceDa59 JerkyWay Black Feet An Unbiased Fan

Barkley 3
fatal9 therealbig3 Jay From LA




Nash 10
Doctor MJ DavidStern mysticbb fatal9 RoyceDa59
ElGee JerkyWay Black Feet Baller 24 Jay From LA

Isiah 8
Laimbeer JordansBulls cpower Dr Mufasa ronnymac2
shawngoat23 TMACFORMVP Fencer reregistered

Pippen therealbig3 drza
2

Stockton FJS An Unbiased Fan
2

Gilmore penbeast0 Gongxi
2

Pretty much identical to mine

[lorak]

ElGee, Mysticbb,

I checked the numbers and I'm not wrong. Maybe you are using other formula for possessions than from b-r? Or other data source than game log from b-r? Maybe that would explain differences because team game logs at b-r had one flaw - some number of turnovers is missing. So if we sum turnovers from team game log it would be different number than total team turnovers on main team page.