Texas Chuck wrote:I would take Dame over AD. Not the rest of those names, but I would AD. AD is a very talented player and he was great in the playoffs last year, but I'm just not buying him elevating a team without Lebron more than Dame and I'd honestly expect less.
And its funny you mention Mitchell because I think he is getting badly overrated just as Murray was pre-injury. He's just the scorer for a team that is about Gobert first and a bunch of smart veterans who all really know how to play and who play at both ends. He gets a lot of hype for stuff that isn't really about him. Just as AD got a big Laker bump like all that absurd talk about him being DPOY last year. He was great defensively in the playoffs but in the regular season a relative bunch of players were clearly better.
AD to me though is like Durant, on his own, it won't be too impressive, but start adding talent around him, and there's not much of a drop-off in terms of his individual play, and he basically just keeps being additive.
I have criticisms of AD too, but at minimum, he's a defensive force with basically no weakness on that end of the floor, and offensively, he's got great hands, is a great finisher, and is a very good jump shooter. He's like the perfect modern big, like a new age KG.
Lillard is a big time scorer, but I mean, as a small guard, he's either bad or average at everything else (he's not a great passer I don't think, and his defense is poor).
I think it's fair to knock AD down a peg compared to other top 5 talents, but Lillard isn't up there with him imo. Lillard is a scoring guard with incredible shot making ability...but how much better is he than say, Kyrie or Trae, for example? I mean, that applies to them too. I wouldn't dream of putting them up there with Davis, and Lillard is more on that level than say, Steph Curry, imo.