Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST)

Moderators: Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal, Clyde Frazier

sp6r=underrated
RealGM
Posts: 20,749
And1: 13,415
Joined: Jan 20, 2007
 

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#41 » by sp6r=underrated » Sun May 9, 2010 12:40 am

You'll enjoy the scouts description of Rasho:

Everything Rasho Nesterovic does is quiet. He tends to disappear against the better players, and he's almost an afterthought when you're making a game plan against the T-Wolves....


Bet his agent didn't tell the spurs about that quote in the off season
Image
bastillon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,927
And1: 664
Joined: Feb 13, 2009
Location: Poland
   

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#42 » by bastillon » Sun May 9, 2010 12:49 am

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/ ... /index.htm

Paul Pierce being described as no D. funny what one year playing with Garnett makes of you.
Quotatious wrote: Bastillon is Hakeem. Combines style and substance.
sp6r=underrated
RealGM
Posts: 20,749
And1: 13,415
Joined: Jan 20, 2007
 

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#43 » by sp6r=underrated » Sun May 9, 2010 12:55 am

The sporting news NBA preview

Lakers

Big Talk: While C Shaquille O'Neal's fitness to start the season is in doubt, SG Kobe Bryant's fitness never has been better. O'Neal had surgery September 11 to remove bone spurs from his arthritic right big toe, and the three-time NBA Finals MVP could miss the first week or two. Meanwhile, Bryant spent the summer working out and reported to camp sporting 15 pounds of new muscle. All of which means that in their now-friendly battle for center stage, Shaq again has conceded November to Kobe. As for the months ahead, a pain-free O'Neal and a stronger Bryant offer opponents little hope for a Lakers downturn.

Supporting arguments: An essentially unchanged cast features PG Derek Fisher and PF Samaki Walker in improved health and SF Devean George continuing to improve off the bench. For Fisher, this should be his first 80-game season since 1997-98 after missing the first 62 and 12 games of the past two years because of foot injuries. With the Lindsey Hunter experiment over, Fisher is secure again in the guard spot alongside Bryant. Walker is feeling good after knee and elbow problems limited him to 12.6 minutes per game and reduced his effectiveness in the playoffs. George survived a year of uncertainty after the Lakers declined to pick up his option in 2001, but now he faces the pressure of living up to a new four-year, $ 18.45 million contract.

THE DISSING INGREDIENT: The Lakers are thin in the backcourt behind Bryant and Fisher, so PG Brian Shaw, 36, will be asked to play the 20 or so minutes a night the first-guard-off-the-bench slot could demand. Shaw is touting improved fitness, but he's coming off career-low averages in minutes (10.9), points (2.9) and assists (1.5). SG Kareem Rush is the team's most promising rookie in years, but coach Phil Jackson never is in a hurry to lean on kids. --Kevin Modesti

Deveney's take

The status of Shaquille O'Neal's health always is a concern, but he should be fit in time for a late May redux against the Kings.


Timberwolves

Big Talk: Statistically, SF Kevin Garnett is almost a lock for another 20-10-5 (points, rebounds, assists) season, but his impact goes beyond the numbers--in both positive and negative ways. With the retirement of SF Sam Mitchell, Garnett will assume the role of team leader, on the floor and in the locker room. He's a great teammate who plays with desire and has a terrific work ethic--which leads to the downside. Garnett has had trouble maintaining his energy at late-season and postseason crunch time, and he has yet to carry this team when the clock is winding down and the Timberwolves need points in a crucial game. Will he make those big fourth-quarter shots this season?

Supporting arguments: Wally Szczerbiak's move from small forward to shooting guard last year helped showcase his perimeter skills and took some of the pressure off him as a defensive player. He has improved his footwork on defense and spent much of the offseason working on his ballhandling. The most important player on the team, however, might be PG Terrell Brandon. He sat out the end of last season with a knee injury, and preseason reports on the knee aren't overly optimistic. If he can't play, the offense will be in big trouble. Chauncey Billups, who filled in nicely for Brandon last year, signed with the Pistons as a free agent. Newcomer Troy Hudson probably is the No. 2 choice at point guard, and European import Igor Rakocevic is getting a look in camp.

THE DISSING INGREDIENT: SG Anthony Peeler quickly is wearing out his welcome in Minnesota. A streaky shooter, Peeler's defensive lapses and poor shot selection were major concerns last season for a team that could use his potential firepower off the bench. The uncertainty in the backcourt would be lessened if the veteran could be counted on to take pressure off the young point guards, but no one expects that to happen. --John Millea

Deveney's take

Unless Terrell Brandon's knee is healthy by January, this team could be due for a swift decline without a playmaking point guard.


Spurs

Big Talk: PF Tim Duncan is coming off an MVP season with career-best averages in points (25.5), rebounds (12.7), assists (3.7) and free-throw shooting (79.9). Already the league's second-most dominant player--behind Lakers C Shaquille O'Neal--Duncan should be more aggressive than ever. He has confidence in his left knee, something he lacked at the start of last season. With C David Robinson retiring after this season, Duncan understands the team is his to lead. If the supporting cast makes shots within the team's motion offense, Duncan should have his best year yet.

SUPPORTING ARGUMENTS: Though PG Tony Parker was a clutch performer as a rookie, his overall shooting--41.9 percent from the field, 32.3 percent on 3-point attempts and 67.5 percent at the foul line--obviously needed work. During the offseason, he worked on finishing his follow-through motion and on developing a teardrop runner he can release in the lane. Now more confident in his game and more comfortable with his teammates, Parker should be a better all-around point guard. No Spur has added more to his game over the past few seasons than PF Malik Rose. Already noted for his limitless energy, rebounding and versatile defense, Rose developed a consistent midrange jumper last year. This summer, he worked on his ballhandling. With Robinson's durability in doubt, Rose may get more playing time than last year.

the dissing ingredient: The Spurs can survive without Robinson for stretches, but they won't be able to get past Shaq and the Lakers if Robinson is not healthy. The good news for the team is Robinson's back didn't need surgery. The bad news is a disk particle still is floating loose in his back and could cause problems again. In an effort to stay healthy, Robinson spent the summer strengthening his abdominal muscles and improving his running and jumping technique. --Johnny Ludden

Deveney's take

Don't expect David Robinson to spend the season collecting farewell gifts. He will contribute as long as he's suiting up for the Spurs.


T-MAC

There's a sense of relief by the time you pull up to the winged "1" that sits square in the middle of the gate outside Tracy McGrady's deluxe Orlando home, complete with a basketball court in the front yard and jet skis emblazoned with Orlando Magic logos in the lake out back. McGrady has been bobbing and weaving through traffic in his plush white Bentley--his "cruising car," he says--and you can't help but worry that you will lose him among the cars on Florida's Route 4. But then you remember that there probably aren't that many Bentleys mixed into central Florida traffic. And when you watch McGrady pull the Bentley into his garage, where a slumbering silver Ferarri sits, well, you realize things could have been worse. "You kept up," McGrady says in mock surprise. He smiles. "I thought I might lose you out there."

Hmm. If you're not mistaken, McGrady is talking a little smack to you and your rental car. Of course, it's a Chevy Malibu, so there is no effective rebuttal. When McGrady sees you're wearing jeans on a 90-degree September day in Orlando, he can't help but say, "You must be enjoying this weather. I would not even call this hot. It could be a lot hotter." Wait, did he just trash talk the sun?


This is Tracy McGrady, NBA superstar and proud talker of trash. McGrady simply likes talking. He would just as readily trash talk your lame set of wheels while standing in his driveway as he would trash talk some lame effort to guard him on the court. McGrady trash talks during games, in the locker room and in the media. You get the feeling that on garbage collection day, he waits by the curb to trash talk the trash collectors. "Hey, I don't mind mixing it up with anyone who wants to," McGrady says. "As long as they take it the right way. I'm not out to hurt anyone's feelings."

There's the rub for McGrady: Folks don't take it the right way, and he winds up portrayed as a self-centered blowhard. As McGrady sees it, there has been a decline in the rivalry-building ragging that fueled NBA showdowns during his childhood. There still is plenty of junk being jawed in the NBA, but many players are restrained by the threat of technicals, fines and public opinion. McGrady finds this lamentable and aims to change it.

"I don't know when people got so sensitive," McGrady says. "Muhammad Ali would never be able to talk the way he did today. If I say I am one of the top five players in the league, people say, 'Why did he say that? Why is he talking about himself?' It does not matter if it's true."

Just 512 months ago, as the Magic's season was ending thanks to a first-round playoffs loss to the Hornets, McGrady took a public flogging for stating that he was the best player in the series. He said that if Hornets star Baron Davis put up better numbers, it was because he had better players around him. McGrady's point about truth in trash talk seems valid--among the floggings, few stopped to ask whether what McGrady said was true. Few considered that there isn't a general manager in his right mind who would swap McGrady for Davis. Few asked whether the well-stocked Hornets really were better off than the Magic, who have not been able to surround McGrady with much talent, thanks to Grant Hill's recurring foot injury.

McGrady just shrugs. "Clearly, he had a lot more depth than we did," he says. "That's what I was dealt. I was not putting down my teammates. I love my teammates. It was just reality. Look at what Baron Davis has on his team. He's got guys who can rebound, who can score and who play defense like (crazy). People said I was disrespecting my team. That's not it."

That sort of criticism, McGrady says, does not bother him. He is not going to clip his lips simply because some people don't like what he has to say. He thinks he could average a triple-double someday. Ask him who he'd pick first if he were building a team from scratch, and he won't hesitate: "Me." Who does the best job of guarding him? "Ain't no one," he says. "No one who can do it every night."

McGrady is 23, still two years away from his prime by his reckoning, and probably the NBA's most gifted player. Certainly, no player will be called upon to carry a bigger load for his team, and if you're forecasting the MVP race, that makes McGrady the top candidate. He followed a breakthrough year in 2000-01 (26.8 points, 7.5 rebounds and 4.6 assists), with a big '01-02 (24.8 points, 7.9 rebounds and 5.3 assists). He can score from the perimeter and the post, frequently defends the opponent's top player, passes like a point guard and rebounds like a power forward. Shouldn't he be given some trash-talking latitude?

"With his skills," says Bucks guard Sam Cassell, "Tracy has the right to talk all he wants. He can back it up."

Cassell would know, because it was against the Bucks in the opening round of the 2001 postseason that McGrady first began carving out his identity. He still smiles when recalling that series, in which he averaged 33.8 points, 8.3 assists and 6.5 rebounds in a four-game defeat. What stood out even more than McGrady's play was the force of his personality. He talked trash like Oscar the Grouch, barking in the ear of Glenn "Big Dog" Robinson--"You're gonna be locked down all night" was among the few lines he used that are suitable for print. Indeed, McGrady held Robinson to 14.6 points per game, 7.4 below his average. He labeled Robinson "the Big Puppy" and said the Bucks "ain't crap."

"That," McGrady says, "was fun as hell. Brings a smile to my face just thinking about it."

That's all McGrady says he wants to do--bring a little fun to the game, especially in the playoffs. The Bucks and the Magic had a simmering rivalry, with an ongoing feud between coaches George Karl and Doc Rivers adding intrigue. Why not give the rivalry a little boost by adding a McGrady-Robinson subplot?

"There should be more of that," McGrady says. "In the playoffs, it's a different game. I am going to be in your ear. You want to talk s-- to people and see if they bring their A-game. You want to do some talking because it forces you to bring out your own A-game.

"Look back to when Michael Jordan played Magic (Johnson) or Jordan faced the Pistons, or Celtics-Lakers. You think Magic was just quiet out there? Larry Bird would be out there telling people what he was going to do, then he'd do it. You think the Pistons weren't talking ... to Jordan? They hated each other. That was fun to watch. Those were the series that people could not miss.

"You are sitting there watching, wondering what is going to happen next--a fight, maybe, or somebody making a big shot to shut somebody else up. You read quotes in the paper and say, 'Can you believe he said that about this guy?' People are a lot more willing to watch those kinds of games. Then they want to watch the next game to see what happens next, what the next chapter in the story is.

"That's what I try to bring back. Talking s--, having two teams that hate each other, having a rivalry. What's wrong with two teams hating each other? I just wanted to start something up. I just wish other teams and players did more of that."

McGrady says it is not really decorum and civility that keeps many players from getting into free-flowing talking battles. Rather, it is the fear of embarrassment, the fear of landing on television in an unfavorable light.

"There is really not that much trash talking in the league," McGrady says. "I think a lot of guys are scared to talk noise because you're putting yourself on the line when you do. A lot of guys don't want to get into it, because they know you will bust their asses, and there is nothing they can do about it. Then you're gonna hear it from the fans, from the press, but worst of all, you're gonna hear it from me." McGrady is sitting, resting his elbows against the gray marble of his kitchen table, contemplating used-up defenders from his past in the way that Willie Nelson and Julio Iglesias recall all the girls they've loved before. For a 6-8 player with McGrady's level of skill, versatility and swagger, what often gets lost is how smart a player he is. A defender might give him trouble on a particular night, but a bit of film study and a consultation with coaches usually provides a remedy. Last season, McGrady struggled in a game against the Raptors because of the way hefty 6-9 forward Jerome Williams was guarding him--Williams was tight on him, putting his arm in McGrady's back as soon as McGrady got the ball, and setting his feet soon thereafter. Usually against someone Williams' size, McGrady penetrates and blows by him, but Williams was getting position too quickly and too solidly.

"Next time, I did not let him get his feet set," McGrady says. "As soon as I got the ball, I acted, I moved. That's the kind of thing you have to do."

In the playoffs, against the Hornets, McGrady was having a tough time with 6-1 guard David Wesley. McGrady had a serious size advantage, so he was trying to post up Wesley and shoot over him. But in the first game of the series, Wesley was giving McGrady slight bumps as he went up for shots, and it caused McGrady to misfire--he was 8-for-21 from the field in that game.

"Second game, after I watched the film, I faced him up," McGrady says. "It was over from there."

As McGrady has sharpened his tongue, he also has sharpened his mental approach to the game. He can rattle off the way defenders play him with ease and knows the best way to attack.

"You never want to do the same thing twice with him," says Bulls forward Jalen Rose. "He will figure you out pretty quickly, and he has the tools to expose you if he does."

Still, the one tool McGrady says he must work on is leadership. McGrady accepts responsibility for the two early postseason exits in his two years in Orlando. The series two seasons ago against the Bucks was fun, but the first-round loss to the Hornets last spring stung. "Depressing," he says. "I failed." McGrady moped for much of the summer, doing rehab to help his back, which he admits is not 100 percent. He traveled, mostly to get out of Orlando--zipping off to Los Angeles, Hawaii and Cancun, keeping his mind off basketball.

"You can tell he is a guy who plays with hunger," says new Hornets guard Courtney Alexander. "He is not a good loser. This guy works his tail off, and he does not care about his stats. He's been around long enough now to know that does not matter. He's hungry to win, and I think if he keeps that, it could be scary in a couple of years."

After spending one postseason as a trash-talking, first-round novelty with impressive numbers, McGrady believed he should have carried the Magic further in the playoffs last year. Indeed, the Magic had a lead in the fourth quarter in three of the games against the Hornets, including Game 1, when the Hornets closed out the game thanks to a steal in the waning seconds by Davis, who slapped the ball from McGrady's hands.

"That's the next step for him," says one Eastern Conference scout. "He has got to carry the team into the second round and forget about them not having a frontcourt, forget about whether Grant Hill is healthy. This is a huge year for Tracy McGrady. He can win games by himself. The Magic should get to the second round, no matter what, because of him."

If he does, you better believe he is going to get there with his tongue wagging.

"We're going further this year," McGrady says. "And when we do, I am going to have a whole new set of talk ready to go."

And, just to get in one last bit of ribbing, McGrady smiles and adds, "Bring your tape recorder." TSN


Nets

Big Talk: Jason Kidd is the Nets' best player, and he easily is the best all-around point guard in the league. His arrival last summer, says coach Byron Scott, changed the entire outlook of the organization. Kidd does so many things well--passing, rebounding, defending and, most important, leading--that few take much notice of his inability to hit consistently from the outside, a skill he would like to improve. His 39.1 percent shooting from the floor and and 32.1 percent from 3-point range were the only smudges on a season in which he finished second in MVP balloting.

SUPPORTING ARGUMENTS: Kenyon Martin led the Nets' balanced offensive attack last season with a 14.9-point average from the small forward position. Now that he's being asked to take over for the departed Keith Van Horn at power forward, Martin must concentrate more on rebounding and playing tougher defense. His strength and quickness always have allowed the Nets to match him up against opponents' top scorers. Now Martin, who spent the offseason adding muscle to his 6-9, 234-pound frame, also will be asked to bang inside with the big men. After four knee surgeries in five years, SG Kerry Kittles appeared in all 110 games last year--preseason, regular season and postseason--and thrived running the wing for Kidd. No Net gets downcourt faster than Kittles--not even Kidd--and that speed should continue to play a big role in the offense.

THE DISSING INGREDIENT: At 36 and with diminishing offensive skills, is C Dikembe Mutombo in the wrong place at the wrong time? He's a defensive and rebounding force, but there are questions whether he will help or hinder the Nets' free-flowing offense. The team needs its center to be the fulcrum of the halfcourt offense, and Mutombo must prove capable of handling the ball and making the necessary decisions. --Don Burke

Deveney's take

Dikembe Mutombo makes this a better defensive team, but he's no sprinter and will be a drag on the Nets' running offense.
Image
bastillon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,927
And1: 664
Joined: Feb 13, 2009
Location: Poland
   

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#44 » by bastillon » Sun May 9, 2010 1:02 am

THE DISSING INGREDIENT: SG Anthony Peeler quickly is wearing out his welcome in Minnesota. A streaky shooter, Peeler's defensive lapses and poor shot selection were major concerns last season for a team that could use his potential firepower off the bench.


year, defensive stopper :bowdown:
Quotatious wrote: Bastillon is Hakeem. Combines style and substance.
User avatar
TMACFORMVP
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 18,947
And1: 161
Joined: Jun 30, 2006
Location: 9th Seed

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#45 » by TMACFORMVP » Sun May 9, 2010 1:50 am

These are great reads.
Prolific Scorer
Banned User
Posts: 5,881
And1: 1
Joined: Aug 07, 2008

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#46 » by Prolific Scorer » Sun May 9, 2010 2:25 am

Duncan
Garnett
McGrady
Bryant
Shaq
User avatar
Silver Bullet
General Manager
Posts: 8,313
And1: 10
Joined: Dec 24, 2006

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#47 » by Silver Bullet » Sun May 9, 2010 2:34 am

NO-KG-AI wrote:It's also a 6 game sample(of which he was never able to come close to replicating again), that was more the fault of the opposing team anyway.

Garnett/Hudson should never be able to go 6 games with Shaq and Kobe.


I don't know how you people do it - but nobody here seems to remember the Wolves I remember - they had a pretty good team and it was not all Garnett.
User avatar
NO-KG-AI
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 43,774
And1: 19,454
Joined: Jul 19, 2005
Location: The city of witch doctors, and good ol' pickpockets

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#48 » by NO-KG-AI » Sun May 9, 2010 2:52 am

You always remember teams a lot better when you don't like the player.

I saw those Wolves a whole lot more back then, and since.
Doctor MJ wrote:I don't understand why people jump in a thread and say basically, "This thing you're all talking about. I'm too ignorant to know anything about it. Lollerskates!"
User avatar
Silver Bullet
General Manager
Posts: 8,313
And1: 10
Joined: Dec 24, 2006

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#49 » by Silver Bullet » Sun May 9, 2010 3:06 am

NO-KG-AI wrote:You always remember teams a lot better when you don't like the player.

I saw those Wolves a whole lot more back then, and since.


And so did I, you make it sound like it was KG and a bunch of perpetual screwups - and I like KG just fine, it just annoys me when people throw around phrases like best power forward in the game - I have no problem with anybody saying he's the 2nd best PF of the decade (that's where I have him).
Sedale Threatt
RealGM
Posts: 50,741
And1: 44,621
Joined: Feb 06, 2007
Location: Clearing space in the trophy case.

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#50 » by Sedale Threatt » Sun May 9, 2010 3:36 am

1. Duncan -- I'd pick him first just for the near quadruple double in the Finals, let alone the fact he had a great season. Absolutely epic in the playoffs.

2. KG -- Don't really like him quite this high, but I have to respect the all-around game. He was awesome on both ends, and that puts him over everybody but Duncan.

3. Kobe -- Going with the homer edge to put him over McGrady. He was probably getting a bit overrated on D at this point, but he's still WAY better than McGrady.

4. Shaq -- His last uber-elite season. The slacking really started to take its toll, though. Great when healthy, but the whole "company time" pissed me off so he's fourth.

5. McGrady -- Outstanding season. This probably shouldn't play a factor, but I view this as something of a fluke season, which mars the luster in my mind.
drza
Analyst
Posts: 3,518
And1: 1,859
Joined: May 22, 2001

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#51 » by drza » Sun May 9, 2010 3:53 am

Unfortunately it's a weekend, so I don't have a lot of time to post, but I did want to get at least some of my 2 cents out there whenever I get a minute. In 2003 Garnett had one of the best seasons that I've ever seen, doing several things that are either rare or have flat out never been done before. Since my time is short, I'll pick one area to start with.

In '03 Wally Szczerbiak was injured for half the season. So for the first half of the year, the Timberwolves trotted out this line-up:

PG: Troy Hudson (undrafted, multiple CBA stints, had never been a full-time starter, in his career.
SG: Anthony Peeler (journeyman, undersized chucker at SG)
SF: Kendall Gill (34-year old journeyman swing, on his last legs before retirement)
C: Rasho (decent role-player)

and Kevin Garnett.

About halfway through the year Wally came back. Now, I've seen Wade in '09, Kobe in '07 and '06, and even KG in '05 get love despite not having a good supporting cast. I suspect in this thread I'll see the same with TMac. And those were all great seasons. But I never saw any player carry a cast that untalented to such a strong season. I've said this before in threads, but in one like this maybe someone will take me up on this challenge...has there EVER been a worse 2 - 5 starting line-up on a 51-win team in NBA history? If so, I haven't heard it.

Kobe, Wade, TMac, even 2005 KG got their teams into the low-40s of wins. But KG took half a season of Wally, Rasho, and several players that wouldn't have started (some of whom wouldn't have even been in the 9-man rotation) on any other team in the league and carried them to 51 wins in a stacked Western Conference. That's the first of several accomplishments he had that season that made him worthy of the player of the year for '03.
Creator of the Hoops Lab: tinyurl.com/mpo2brj
Contributor to NylonCalculusDOTcom
Contributor to TYTSports: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTbFEVCpx9shKEsZl7FcRHzpGO1dPoimk
Follow on Twitter: @ProfessorDrz
Sedale Threatt
RealGM
Posts: 50,741
And1: 44,621
Joined: Feb 06, 2007
Location: Clearing space in the trophy case.

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#52 » by Sedale Threatt » Sun May 9, 2010 5:38 am

So what would that make, four first-place votes for KG?
User avatar
mopper8
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 42,618
And1: 4,870
Joined: Jul 18, 2004
Location: Petting elephants with the coolest dude alive

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#53 » by mopper8 » Sun May 9, 2010 5:40 am

Sedale Threatt wrote:1. Duncan -- I'd pick him first just for the near quadruple double in the Finals, let alone the fact he had a great season. Absolutely epic in the playoffs.

2. KG -- Don't really like him quite this high, but I have to respect the all-around game. He was awesome on both ends, and that puts him over everybody but Duncan.

3. Kobe -- Going with the homer edge to put him over McGrady. He was probably getting a bit overrated on D at this point, but he's still WAY better than McGrady.

4. Shaq -- His last uber-elite season. The slacking really started to take its toll, though. Great when healthy, but the whole "company time" pissed me off so he's fourth.

5. McGrady -- Outstanding season. This probably shouldn't play a factor, but I view this as something of a fluke season, which mars the luster in my mind.


This list IMO is perfect, order and reasoning. Especially re: 4 & 5
DragicTime85 wrote:[Ric Bucher] has a tiny wiener and I can prove it.
Sedale Threatt
RealGM
Posts: 50,741
And1: 44,621
Joined: Feb 06, 2007
Location: Clearing space in the trophy case.

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#54 » by Sedale Threatt » Sun May 9, 2010 5:45 am

Thank you.
User avatar
Dr Positivity
RealGM
Posts: 62,281
And1: 16,253
Joined: Apr 29, 2009
       

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#55 » by Dr Positivity » Sun May 9, 2010 6:09 am

1. Duncan - 23/13/4/3 with all-time defense, Spurs finish 1st overall, MVP, Spurs go through Kobe and Shaq and win the title. Plus this is done with one of the more shakier superstar supporting casts. Duncan's playoff averages btw are insane: 25/15/5/3 .58 TS%. Duncan in 03 is almost the best year you can possibly have
2. Garnett - Led a pretty meh team to 51, great two way player. The clear #2 IMO. He actually came pretty damn close in MVP voting, which is impressive considering the wins differential
3. Tmac - Insane statistical year and the Magic finish a decent 10th offensively despite a scrubass lineup. His impact was felt
4. Kobe - Shaq was better, but 82 games of Kobe > 67 of Shaq
5. Shaq - Still Shaqtus, but only 67 games. I'd have put him over KG if he played more
Liberate The Zoomers
Gongxi
Banned User
Posts: 3,988
And1: 28
Joined: Mar 12, 2010

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#56 » by Gongxi » Sun May 9, 2010 6:32 am

ElGee wrote:Gongxi - Duncan's greater defensive contribution doesn't get him the nod over McGrady?


Not with the production McGrady put up, no. His season really was reaching stratospheres that only Jordan and James have attained as swingmen.
User avatar
ronnymac2
RealGM
Posts: 11,003
And1: 5,070
Joined: Apr 11, 2008
   

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#57 » by ronnymac2 » Sun May 9, 2010 6:41 am

Okay, unless I see some crazy "best post I've ever seen" type of post, Duncan is number one here. I like it when my guy closes out teams with 37-16 performances and near quad-doubles. It impresses me.

Kobe is over McGrady. Although Kobe was injured in the playoffs (hurt his shoulder), he played well. Plus, I feel McGrady's playoffs weren't too hot either considering he had a 3-1 lead and then collapsed.

The big thing is that Kobe's defense was better. Kobe's defense really was elite this year, while McGrady's was just very good.

KG is very likely to be in my top five this year. I'm watching some Lakers vs. Wolves playoff games from this year, and KG was just nasty. In this thread, his team is getting a little underrated. They suck relative to the competition, but they aren't THAT bad. Still, KG was awesome.

Shaq is impressing me. I didn't remember much from this Minny-LA series, but as I watch Shaq annhilate the Wolves with 34-23-6-2-insane dunks-dominant offensive rebounding that KG himself can't stop-elite defense (yes, Shaq' playing great d here) performance, I'm remembering how damn dominant Shaq still was. He was injured in 02 for most of the playoffs; I think this playoff run is technically even better. He killed the Spurs, too; I remember that series. Maybe Duncan is number one for me because he broke my heart. You do that, you must be that damn good. haha

I'll take some time to vote for this one.
Pay no mind to the battles you've won
It'll take a lot more than rage and muscle
Open your heart and hands, my son
Or you'll never make it over the river
Gongxi
Banned User
Posts: 3,988
And1: 28
Joined: Mar 12, 2010

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#58 » by Gongxi » Sun May 9, 2010 6:51 am

Like I said before, there's three guys you can legitimately put at #1 (or four if you prize Shaq's dominance when he played more than most), so I'm not gonna get bothered too much, but you can say Kobe's defense was better than McGrady's, but...

#1- Individual defense is less important than individual offense in professional basketball anyway.

#2- McGrady's offense (and rebounding) weren't just better than Kobe's. They were echelons better. It was, as I mentioned, comparing a prime Jordan or prime LeBron to Kobe. It simply wasn't close.

You'd really have to be big on individual defense and team success- like really big- to go with Kobe over McGrady.
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 52,698
And1: 21,648
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Cali
     

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#59 » by Doctor MJ » Sun May 9, 2010 7:08 am

One thing I don't think's been mentioned in the Kobe vs McGrady debate: Kobe played about 450 more minutes in the regular season. Now if you think McGrady was having a much bigger impact, that 450 minutes shouldn't stop you from picking him. Don't kid yourself though, the Magic could have easily gone up a couple seeds if McGrady had played more - I'll be probably picking Kobe over McGrady because I consider their level of play close, and I can't see giving up 400+ minutes to have McGrady instead of Kobe.
Getting ready for the RealGM 100 on the PC Board

Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!
tkb
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 10,759
And1: 198
Joined: Mar 19, 2005
Location: Norway
   

Re: Retro POY '02-03 (ends Tue morning PST) 

Post#60 » by tkb » Sun May 9, 2010 7:24 am

Alright, I'm going with this as my vote:

1. Tim Duncan
2. Kevin Garnett
3. Kobe Bryant
4. Tracy McGrady
5. Shaquille O'Neal

HM: Dirk Nowitzki

Return to Player Comparisons