Adding Kobe! West and Oscar played age 22–35. Let’s look at Kobe age 21–34 (2000–2013, i.e. first non-negative RAPM year until achilles injury).DraymondGold wrote:Oscar vs West: Team Offenses
...
Regular Season Offenses:
-Oscar Career rORTG: +3.3 (+3.3 without rookie/last year, +2.6 without Kareem/rookie years)
-West Career rORTG: +2.1 (+2.6 without rookie/last year, +2.5 without Wilt/rookie years)
-Kobe sample rORTG: +3.2 (+3.3 without first/last year, +2.9 without Shaq/last years)
5-year stretches of +3 rORTG: Oscar has 7 (4 without Kareem), Kobe has 7 (4 without Shaq), West 0.
Single year stretches with +3 rORTG: Oscar has 8 (4 without Kareem), Kobe has 7 (3 without Shaq), West 4 (2 without Wilt).
Single year stretches with +5 rORTG: Oscar has 2 (+7.1 in ’71, 5.8 in ’72, both with Kareem) , Kobe has 2 (+5.4 in ’01, +5.5 in ’08, one with Shaq), West has 2 (+5.1 in ’68 and +6.1 in ’72, one with Wilt).
Takeaways: In regular season, Oscar & Kobe' offenses > West. Oscar was slightly more consistent without Kareem and slightly better peaks with Kareem, though Kobe and West had slightly higher highs than Oscar without their all-time big men.[/u]
Postseason Offenses:
-Oscar Career PS rORTG: +3.8 (+3.5 without rookie/last year, +3.9 without rookie/Kareem years)
-West Career PS rORTG: +4.0 (+4.1 without rookie/last year, +6.0 without rookie/Wilt years).
-Kobe sample PS rORTG: +5.8 (+5.4 without first/last year, +4.7 without last/Shaq years)
5-year stretches with +4 PS rORTG: Kobe has 7 (4 without Shaq), West has 6 (4 without Wilt), Oscar 2.
5-year stretches with +5 PS rORTG: Kobe has 6 (4 without Shaq), West has 4 (3 without Wilt), Oscar 0.
3-year stretches with +5 PS rORTG: Kobe has 6 (3 without Shaq), West has 5 (5 without Wilt!), Oscar 1.
Single year stretch with +5 PS rORTG: Kobe has 7 (3 without Shaq: +6.8 in ’08, +6.4 in ’09, +6.9 in ’20), West has 4 (3 without Wilt: +8.6 in ’63, +6.9 in ’65 without Baylor, +7.8 in ’66), Oscar has 3 (2 without Kareem: +7 in ’63, + 7.2 in ’66).
Takeaways: In the playoffs, West's offenses >= Kobe > Oscar. Kobe seems to have the best on average, but the advantage comes pre-peak Kobe during peak Shaq (though there is a case for good scalability for that team). West looks better than Kobe or Oscar during their respective peaks without their all-time big men. West has the better average in the non Wilt/Kareem/Shaq years, the better 3-year samples, and the better single-year samples
Edit: Obligatory qualifier, 1) these are team stats. They depend on teammates, not just the single star. 2) These three played 40 years apart so the offenses look very different across these two eras. 3) Defense matters, both individually and when looking at team results.
But since there’s a focus on team offense for these players, I thought it would be interesting to compare the results.