do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time?

Moderators: trex_8063, PaulieWal, Quotatious, penbeast0, Doctor MJ, Clyde Frazier

Is Shaq top 5

Yes , #5 or even higher
No, but still top 10
Not in my top 10
Total votes: 72

Posts: 656
And1: 30
Joined: Dec 29, 2012

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#41 » by TheBomb81 » Sun Aug 11, 2019 6:06 pm

1993Playoffs wrote:
No-more-rings wrote:Nah, more like 6th or 7th for me, but i can see the argument. It’s just hard to ignore how many games me missed during his prime and post prime for that matter too. On top of that he just wasn’t a consistently good defender after like 05 or so.

zero playoffs games missed is pretty impressive though

He only missed the playoffs twice in 1993 and 2009.
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 41,035
And1: 9,059
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Treys are for 'Kicks!...and Steph Curry

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#42 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Aug 11, 2019 9:10 pm

1993Playoffs wrote:The more and more I evaluate his career I'm left with one prevailing thought.........The amount of pure destruction to opposing teams this guy did in his peak and prime is simply unmatched. Even Jordan and LeBron were never quite as unstoppable as peak Shaq imo.

I also think he was a better basketball player with the better peak and prime than his contemporary who is ranked higher most places in Duncan,

of course he had his faults like FT shooting and pick and roll D but his man to man Defense was pretty great in his career

but do you have Shaq in your top 5? he was such a unique and dominant player its getting hard for me to leave him ouy imo

Top 10 not Top 5. There's a simple question here relating to Duncan that's important:

If you were drafting these guys for the future of your franchise, who would you expect to give you more?
The answer is clearly Duncan for reasons that have to with attitude.

I tend to make some allowances for stars who had some attitude problems early on but figured it out while still relatively early in their prime, but Shaq never changed. He just proved over and over again that he would inevitably have drama wherever he was, and once he caused that drama, it was only a matter of time before he'd be gone.

And yet still, I have Shaq in my Top 10 because he was that freaking good.
In another world...
Your Longshoremen of Long Beach...

And now introducing...
The Song of Westeros...
LeBron James
John Stockton
Bobby Jones
Rudy Gobert
Khris Middleton
Connie Hawkins
Otto Porter
Ryan Anderson
Posts: 2,596
And1: 1,449
Joined: Dec 09, 2018

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#43 » by freethedevil » Sun Aug 11, 2019 9:16 pm

Definitely has an argument for it.
Posts: 566
And1: 105
Joined: May 18, 2014

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#44 » by EasternHeretic » Mon Aug 12, 2019 1:42 am


Think that's my top 5
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,932
And1: 4,313
Joined: Sep 26, 2017

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#45 » by iggymcfrack » Mon Aug 12, 2019 4:58 am

Pg81 wrote:To me he has no case for top 5 whatsoever. Considering his height and athleticism he was a comparatively poor rebounder compared to all time greats like Kareem, Wilt and Russell. My main problems with him are his attitude which led to him being out of shape at the beginning of the season and not being able to play a lot of minutes comparatively speaking. Shaq only reached 40 mpg once in his career, Wilt for example averaged almost a staggering 46 minutes, Russell a great 42 minutes and Kareem 37 over a 20 year career. I am also not convinced that he has THE greatest peak ever, though he for sure has an argument. Wilt, MJ, LeBron, Kareem and Duncan 03 all have cases for an equal maybe even better peak considering they could play more minutes, played more games and were never out of shape on top of being arguably better defenders, so it depends on what exactly you value. Shaq was an intimidating presence in the paint but so where the others, but Shaq was poor at help defense, especially on p&r. On top of all of that he was a noticeably worse rebounder, never won a rebounding title, unlike Wilt, Russell and Kareem. I do not expect a SG like MJ or SF like LeBron to win a rebounding title, not their job in the end considering their ball handling and passing duties on their team.
Lastly his competition at the center position during the 3 peat was pretty lackluster imho, best being Mutombo who was what, top 50 all time? Otherwise he was mostly competing against slow, old heavily declining centers like Rik Smits and Sabonis who were a shadow of their former self, and it cannot be denied that he was allowed to get away with murder. What he was allowed to do to Mutombo in 2001 was imho a disgrace, hammering elbows into his face, shoulder tackles and just in general barreling through him and the zone with hardly any care for whistles. Was not a pretty sight either.

This isn’t true at all. Shaq was a significantly better rebounder than Kareem if you look at TRB% and he got a much higher share of his rebounds on the offensive glass where they’re more valuable. Wilt and Russell are harder to compare because they played before that stat was available. Also, Shaq’s 27th all time in minutes and 6th all time in playoff minutes. He’s much better at staying on the floor than he gets credit for. Obviously, someone playing in the 2000s isn’t gonna play as many minutes as Wilt but his durability is very underrated.
User avatar
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,434
And1: 3,572
Joined: Jan 28, 2014
Location: A Coruña, Spain

Re: do you consider Shaq a top 5 player of all time? 

Post#46 » by Jaivl » Mon Aug 12, 2019 11:13 pm

I don't, but he has a clear argument.
Maf wrote:I'd undestand if anyone had KG outside top ten PF's. Having him top five all-time? Often I jokingly rank Kyle Korver as the GOAT but I never try to fake serious discussion about it.

ShawnKemp96 wrote:Infact he made a lot more steals than the statisticians think.

Return to Player Comparisons